Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘Writing Critique’

March 19, 2024

March is Women’s History Month—a celebration of women’s contributions to history, culture, and society.  There are so many amazing women writers!

First Word: “Writing is a process, a journey into memory and the soul. Write what should not be forgotten.” Isabel Allende

Announcements:  There will be five Tuesdays in April. An in-person gathering in the works?

Manuscript Discussion: Six member writers gathered in person or by Zoom to discuss six submissions.

Kashmira S. submitted chapters 4-5 of the Agaria story.

The group as a whole enjoyed it. There were some questions about logistics. For example, how Chitrak ended up sleeping there and needed clarification. There was also a comment about how mother’s skin may have suffered under the harsh sun and if Karna should mention that. Please remember that Karna is a boy and it is important to the story later on. Thank you for all your feedback. 

Jack F.  submitted chapter 12 of Jesus Walked into the IHOP

I was pleasantly surprised by the positive comments on the Imagine chapter.  I do need a bright chapter on this part of the book because the next set of His adventures is still rather heavy.  Jesus, like Christianity, has his ups and downs.

Taking April off for hip replacement will allow some writing time as well as research time.  Who knows, maybe he goes to India next instead of Africa? Thanks for all the comments.

Amit T. and Kashmira S. INFTP, chapters 39 and 40

  1. Kedar’s reaction is very passive when he sees Uma with Hari.  A more spirited reaction on his part is necessary than to just give in. 

2.  Kedar’s reaction to when Hari mentions Uma’s family is also very mild. 

3.  Should Uma take the lead in finding Kedar?

4. Show more of Kedar’s reflection on immediate past in his current thinking.

Suzanne G. submitted Chapter 21 of Kaleidoscope

Wendy thought the first two paragraphs could be stronger with some rewriting. She didn’t like the reference to the movie. It took her out of the scene. She wanted more detail in the sex scene. Larry thought the scenes were going the way they should and is hoping for a story climax soon. Several people don’t like the character of Emily (she seems unreal) nor Carey and Brandon’s fear of her. Kashmira wants more of a growth arc for Brandon. He’s too unsure of himself and their relationship. Amit thought the descriptions often slowed the story down. As always, thanks to everyone for your comments. They are helpful and much appreciated.

Wendy B. What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 15-16

               Excellent feedback on fine-tuning the chapters. Flush out Clarksville with descriptions other than the church scene. Some solid word choices suggested. Changing whistle pigs to ground hogs—but don’t you just love the word(s) whistle pigs? Good chapter ending.

               The short story, Jingle Bell Ginny, was also well received by the group. Interesting to know that It’s a Wonderful Life, did not become the Christmas classic it is today until almost thirty years after its 1946 release!

Next Up on April 3rd:  Bob K, Suzanne G, Larry S, Wendy B, and Kashmira S and Amit T. One open slot.

Thank you all for forwarding your summaries in a timely fashion. Good luck to Jack on his hip replacement. Happy Easter!

Last Word: “The beginning is always today.” Mary Shelley

Read Full Post »

March 5, 2024

First Word… “If you don’t have time to read, you don’t have the time (or the tools) to write. Simple as that.” —Stephen King

Which begs the question, what are you reading? I am spellbound with Attica Locke’s novel, Bluebird, Bluebird.

Announcements:  Larry reported recent contacts with currently inactive members Mike A, Judy C, John S, and Paul W. All are doing well and send along their best regards to the group. Look for Mike, Judy, and maybe Paul to return to active participation soon. John is still extremely busy in the cow business.

Manuscript Discussion: Eight member writers and one guest gathered in person or by Zoom to discuss six submissions.

Larry F. S. Brother’s Blood, Ch. 9: Jack suggested the search plane’s recovery by crane ought to be mentioned as well as its launch by catapult and also gave some help on sharpening the tension between ROTC boys and regular Navy crew members. Suzanne pointed out that Peggy could easily be confused with Margaret, since Peggy is a short form or nickname for Margaret. There was general agreement that more conflict is needed. Thanks, everyone.

Jack F. Jesus  Walked Into the IHOP. It is very helpful for me to get Amit and Kashima’s assessment of my work, unclouded by theological presumptions all Christians have. They seem to be enjoying the story as story, which is necessary for anyone to read the eventual full piece. They asked if Jesus visited India, as some Hindu tests make that suggestions.  Very briefly I found the following.

A seminar was also organized under the aegis of Jagannath Gabeshana Parishad where eminent scholars like Dr Harekrushna Satapathy, Dr Siddheswer Mohapatra, Jagabandhu Padhi, Dr Debendra Dash and others deliberated over the Hindu religious texts which mentioned the activities of Jesus. Dr Trebst said 2,000 years ago Puri was a famous seat of learning and history has revealed that over the centuries religious leaders of various sects and cults had visited this holy shrine. It was most likely that Jesus had also visited this holy seat of learning, he said, though adding that it was a very difficult task to trace the history of his visit to Puri.

It appears I must do more research. Wendy and I have exchanged emails regarding her corrections and questions, all very helpful.

Amit T. INFTP

1.  Weave in the theme of abandonment and chaos (British leaving) in Kedar’s chapter. 2.  Tighten-up the paragraph pertaining to Mohan Kaka. 3.  Use holy man instead of Sadhu 4.  Kedar’s poem should also emphasize abandonment and sense of loss.

Thanks all for reading. Amit and Kashmira 

Kashmira S. Kashmira submitted the first three chapters of her MG novel about agarias. Overall, it was well received. The name of the protagonist made people think it was a girl. There was a discussion about what a flock of flamingos are called. Also, many felt that more details about the setting, salt pan etc. would be nice to have. Thank you all for your comments and feedback.

Editor’s Note: According to Wikipedia, Agariya or Agarias translates as Salt Farmers. Kashmira, please correct if not correct.

Jaimie N.  We took up a rewrite of chapter 7 of New York, After All. The group asked for a sense of how Lindyhop feels about her family’s living conditions when she is living in Carnegie Hall. It also needs to be clearer that she had been told by her family that her father died when she was five. The “four men” who are missing from the table should also probably be named. Thanks, all!

Wendy B. What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 13-14. Thoroughly enjoyed the well-deserved evisceration of June’s tracking of her father. Having fun writing something doesn’t count for much! The group is correct; it’s out of character for June, reads rather cutesy and contrived, and totally lacks tension. It’s great to get such invaluable feedback! That’s the big picture, too many smaller suggestions to mention. Thank you all:)

Next Up on March 19:  Bob K, Suzanne G, Kashmira S and Amit T, Wendy B, and Jack F.

Last word… “We write to taste life twice, in the moment and in retrospect.” —Anais Nin

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays With Story

February 20, 2024

First Word…

 

To choose to write is to reject silence.

—Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

Tuesday evening…

Six TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, five of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Bob K. – Say What You Want, Ch. 3, A minor character, Mead, was introduced in this chapter. Several comment came in about the office situation at the Department of Free Speech and the air of mystery and dread surrounding Mead’s job. Suzanne felt the conversation between Mead and Colvin (another minor character) accurately reflected office talk. The rubberized helmet thing connected to the machine on Mead’s desk was unclear to several readers. Great comments, all.

Wendy B. – What Blood Runs Through Me, Chs. 10-12,   The Sommer family saga continues with the funeral for Tommy. Earl (father) returns home after missing the funeral and becomes a person of interest with Homicide Detective Taggert. It just goes to show you, you can never proofread a chapter too many times. Big picture comments include the need to flush out Liz and Earl’s characters/presence/dialogue more. Several people zoomed in on the misplaced apostrophe on pluralizing Mallory as Mallory’s. It should be Mallorys. A lesson to be learned–shy away from tricky names like Jones, which becomes Joneses or if referring to their house becomes Joneses’ house. Noting several other grammatical errors was greatly appreciated. Obviously not my strong point…Thank you! 

Kashmira S. & Amit T. – If Not For the Partition, Chs. 35-37,

—The writing is good. There was confusion about Dr. Masa/Dr. Kaka.

—Need some ideas as to how long Uma and Kedar have been separated.

—Kedar needs to have some growth and emotional maturity. Show how he has changed after going through such violent experiences. 

Larry F. S. – Brother’s Blood, Ch. 9, start: Jack thought there were a couple of nautical things Jag would already know, about squads and airplanes. Wendy wanted to know what a bosun was. Everyone felt the four-paragraph section at the end was too much telling and not enough showing. Kashmira wanted Jag to have some correspondence with, or thoughts of, his family.  Good comments all. Thanks.

Suzanne G. – Charles, There was a general consensus that my piece read more like a first chapter than a short story. It needed some change to happen in Charles, as well as more information on Justin and their relationship. One person suggested a creepier beginning would increase the creepiness of the story.  Thanks everyone for the comments. I greatly appreciate them.

Here’s who’s up on March 5…

Kashmira S.

Wendy B.

Suzanne G.

Jack F.

Larry F.S.

Jaime N. N.

Our Editor for March…

Wendy Bialek will serve as editor of Writer’s Newsletter. She is always on the lookout for good things to include, and so if you have something you want her to include, do email it to her.

WISCONSIN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES, ARTS AND LETTERS

Our 2024 writing contests are open for submissions. Sean Enfield will judge the fiction contest. Dorothy Chan will judge the poetry contest.

Contest Deadline: MARCH 15, 2024

Entry fee: $10 Academy members / $15 non-members

Judges: Sean Enfield for fiction and Dorothy Chan for poetry

Prizes: 

  • 1st-place winners receive a one-week artist residency at Shake Rag Alley Center for the Arts in Mineral Point.
  • Win cash prizes: $500 for 1st place, $250 for 2nd place, and $100  for 3rd place.
  • Read at the 2024 Wisconsin Book Festival.
  • 1st-3rd-place winners are published in print and online issues of Wisconsin People & Ideas magazine. 

Last Word…

“There is no time for despair, no place for self-pity, no need for silence, no room for fear. We speak, we write, we do language. That is how civilizations heal.”

— Toni Morrison

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays with Story
December 5, 2023

The first word . . .

“Truth is stranger than fiction but it is because fiction is obliged to stick to possibilities; truth isn’t.” Mark Twain

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)

Some excellent suggestions were made for the three chapters reviewed. First and foremost was the need to identify that June is the narrator and not a reference to the month of June. Needless to say, this caused some confusion. Also pointed out was the need for reorganizing some of the sentences and paragraphs, as well as trimming certain descriptions. The suggestion for increased internal thought was spot-on and greatly appreciated. Thank you all for taking the time to review!

Mike A. (Backroads, Chapters 21-22)

Mike A., Backroads Chapters 21-22, received favorable reviews all around. There was some confusion about Red being the bank robber and whether Stevens had hired him, or he was robbing it on his own (which he was).  I also need to use more active verbs instead of passive. And I just looked up “past simple vs past progressive” in reference to “He wore” (for instance) versus “He was wearing.” I hadn’t thought about there being words to define those forms, but see that those are forms I need to keep in mind. I’m learning grammar! Thanks everyone. 

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays With Story

November 21, 2023

First Word…

“Stories have to be told or they die, and when they die, we can’t remember who we are or why we’re here.”

— Sue Monk Kidd, author

Tuesday evening…

Five TWS writers attended the meeting via Google Meet, two of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

—Suzanne Gillingham, Kaleidoscope, Ch. 15,16. Jack had some structural comments. Wendy thought there should be a better description of the room Brandon’s Mom’s things were stored in, as well as more of a reaction from Brandon on the discovery of the package. She commented there should be a better transition to the bar in San Francisco and a better description of the place. Mike likes where the story is going and enjoyed Brandon’s interactions with his family. He also thought the story needed a better transition to the bar in SF. Larry thought it was a good idea to take Brandon to SF–more interactions with someone other than Carey. He liked the complexity of the Grandmother but said adding in interactions with Brandon’s Dad was too much family too soon. He noted there was more explaining and internal dialog than needed. And there should be a better transition to the bar in SF. (I see a pattern here. Lol) Judy also commented on the excessive internal dialog. Jamie wanted more of a reaction from Carey to Brandon’s synesthesia. Thanks everyone for their comments. I appreciate them all!

—Jaime Nelson Noven, New York, After All, Ch. 1. The group took up a rewrite of New York, After All chapter one. The group generally thought the scene was believable and worked well in present tense. It was suggested that the orange could be replaced by something that set the dystopian scene better. Jack suggested giving Shabbos another line of context. Wendy liked the last sentence of the first paragraph and recommended it as the opening sentence of the novel. She also suggested adding more tension to the missing boy, especially since this is the central conflict of the book. Thanks, all!

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays With Story

November 7, 2023

First Word…

“Write what should not be forgotten.”

— Isabel Allende, author

Tuesday evening…

Five TWS writers attended the meeting via Google Meet, four of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

—Larry F. Sommers, Brother’s Blood, Ch. 1-2: There was general agreement that the new Chapter 1 makes Jag a more understandable and sympathetic character, even though he’ll never be warm and fuzzy.  Jaime said there are too many names to keep track of in Ch. 1, and perhaps Wendell’s plan to bribe the pilot into aerobatics could be introduced earlier and smoother. Someone suggested that Pop might be made a bit softer edged in Ch. 1 because he has not yet had to face the Depression. But maybe he is a WWI veteran and thus inured to sudden death. Good things to think about. Thanks, everybody.

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays With Story

October 17, 2023

First Word…

Make the heart the pen, the intellect the writer, write that which has no end or limit. 

Guru Nanak Ji, Founder of Sikh Faith

 

Tuesday evening…

Three TWS writer presented on October 17th meeting. Here is a summary of what was said:

Larry F. Sommers, Would Blue Yonder memoir, Ch. 6: Jack and Judy wanted to see more of Larry’s reaction in the historical section about Chairman Mao and the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution. Jack was looking for a bit more enlightenment in the passage about the LSD trip. Bob reflected that some of this chapter is a matter of “stirring sediment” in the depths of my psyche, and I could exploit that better, or further. Thanks, everybody. Feeling my way on this, a little at a time.

Mike Austin, Backroads, Chapters 15-17. These chapters were well received. There was confusion about the struggle in the bottom of the gully about who was dragging Mary back down, who was dropping a rock, and why Smitty was choking Mary when his object was rape. And at some point while I was re-writing, I changed Smitty’s name to Ned. Which was odd, because actually Pat had been Ned. And, again, I need to have more of Nick’s feelings in here. He needs to have some more depth and development. Thanks everyone!

Amit Trivedi and Kashmira Sheth: If Not for the Partition, Chapters

1 The scene where Uma is trying to find out where Jaya is from needs to be better developed.  Maybe Uma thinks about the conversation and later figures out the answers. 2. Beethoven’s symphony and pastoral landscape connection is not very convincing.  Kedar’s memory about listening to the music with Uma should be brought out more. 3. Two-word town name scene seems author intrusion. Should be rewritten. 

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays With Story

October, 3rd 2023

First Word…

“When I sit down to write a book, I do not say to myself, ‘I am going to produce a work of art.’ I write it because there is some lie that I want to expose, some fact to which I want to draw attention, and my initial concern is to get a hearing.”
—George Orwell

Tuesday evening…

Seven TWS writers attended the meeting via Google Meet, six of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Judy Cummings: A Real Hero, Chapters 30-32: Everyone thought the final chapters wrapped things up well and ended the story on a hopeful note. Kashmira suggested removing the earlier fishing scene so as to give more punch to the final family fishing scene. Larry questioned the use of the verb “bobbing” for turtle fishing. Thanks for the feedback, everybody! 

Jaime Nelson Noven: a chapter of New York, After All.

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Sept 19, 2023

The first word…

“If you write one story, it may be bad; if you write a hundred, you have the odds in your favor.” Edgar Rice Burroughs. He also said, regarding the pulp fiction magazines of that time, “… if people were paid for writing rot such as I read in some of those magazines, that I could write stories just as rotten.” And then he went on to write “Tarzan,” which spawned a “Tarzan” empire.

Comment Summaries

A grand total of six people presented work on Tuesday. Here are summaries of critiques.

Larry Sommers, Military Memoir, Chapters 3-4: There was consensus it was well-written, and especially that Chapter 4, the introduction to the Chinese language by Robert Tharp, was explained clearly and with just enough detail to make it interesting and swift. Jack pointed out that the scene in Ch. 3 with Sergeant Decouteau focused too much on him and not enough on my own reactions. Jaime pointed out that in Chapter 4 by having Tharp read our minds, I introduced unneeded duplication. Thanks, everybody!

Jaime presented a chapter of New York, After All. Kashmira suggested dialing back on the description of the new office at the beginning of the chapter, and Jack wondered if it’s worth introducing a new space at all if she’s going to leave it. We discussed hotdesking and whether elevators would work if things have gotten so bad that there’s no internet or cell phones. A very good question on how fast these paper samples are arriving from China. Larry liked the part about paper and recalled the newspaper being printed on the back of wallpaper during the Siege of Vicksburg. Mike liked the scenes with Danny and felt bad for the collapse of their friendship. Thanks, all!

Mike Austin, Backroads (working title) Mike presented chapters 10-11. Right off the bat, we found that there are too many “thems” in just a few paragraphs. Which tells Mike, once again, how valuable it is to read the piece out loud. The chapters were favorably received in spite of this. There needs to be more provocation from Smitty that causes Ida to take up her pitchfork against him. And we need to have more of a reaction from Nick after the knife is thrown at him. Or perhaps not even have the knife thrown, and save the real confrontation for Ida. Thanks!

Amit and Kashmira submitted chapters 27-28 of INFP

Some felt that the pov from Ba and Gauri Kaki was breaking up the flow. Although Amber thought it worked fine. Jaime thought two in a row was a difficult transition. Verb tenses were not always right. There were some formatting issues. 

Emotional depth was good. Thank you. 

Kashmira submitted two picture books.

Jungle Meeting: Amber liked the revised version. Larry suggested a slight tweak at the end and also a possible title, I’m Going to a Meeting.

Poet’s Daughter: Jack suggested a few word additions/changes for flow as well as meaning. He also suggested extra space/ breaking up lines for emphasis. Mike wondered about using, “monstrous worm” in the first poem. Larry thought the pain of separation came though the story. Thank you.

Rupa submitted her picture book Flying Like Bees. Larry thought it was a well-structured story. Judy thought it needed a better transition and more active role from mom. Jaime wanted a clearer understanding of passage of time. Amber liked the story. She couldn’t tell what mom can and can’t do. Larry like that vagueness. Thank you all.

Who’s next?

Presenters for October 3rd so far are:

Judy Cummings

Mike Austin

Larry Sommers

So we have a few open slots. Feel free to jump in.

Announcement:

Congratulations to writer Amber Boudreau! She was awarded third place in the Best of Madison in the Local Author category.

On writing…

A Writer’s Conceit

Paper is immune to the corrosive effects of a good story.

A story is like acid, eating a hole in you until you spill it out onto paper. When it hits the page it does not eat the paper but simply spreads over it in a pattern of black marks, which can be rearranged however you see fit without any further holes being eaten in anybody—except, perhaps, the reader.

—Larry F. Sommers

Next month our editor will be Kashmira Sheth. Thanks for reading!

Read Full Post »

September 5, 2023

TWS member John Schneller posted this in our newsletter a few years ago. I like the sentiment, so am re-posting it:

“A mistake for authors is defining their author platform as a list of people to market their next book on social media.

If you view your author platform as nothing more than transactional relationships, it will fail. If you view it primarily as sharing your heart and caring for a group of people, it will have far more value and possibly be responsive when you have a book.” 

Dan Balow, Steve Laube Literary Agency

Summary of Tuesday’s Meeting

There were five presenters at Tuesday’s meeting. Here are the summaries of the feedback they received.

Larry F. Sommers, Military Memoir 1-2: Judy was momentarily disoriented by the parenthetical “(or affirm)”  in the enlistment oath. Kashmira wanted concrete examples of the training methodology outlined in the first paragraphs of Ch. 2 and also looked for clearer suggestions of the author’s estrangement from the Air Force enlistment process and the prospect of future military service. These are very helpful comments. Thank you

Kashmira submitted two picture book manuscripts.

Overall, both the manuscripts needed some work. Walls was difficult to visualize as a picture book and needed more personal focus. Aaaarow! could use some tweaking, especially, the ending. Aaaarow title also was questioned. Everyone liked the child’s voice though. Thank you all.

Judy Cummings, A Real Hero, Chapters 29-30: The way I set up the revelation that Miss Brown is Blue-Eyes’ mother was done well. The humorous tone is consistent throughout the story. Tone down Steve’s observations of Miss Brown’s clothing. The appearance of the editor at the POW camp in the early morning is too coincidental. Thanks for the input. 

Amber Boudreau, Star-Crossed. Amber read from the beginning of Chapter 2 of her new effort, a timey-wimey romance, called Star-Crossed. Several people thought it wasn’t a bad rough draft to the start of a novel. Larry and Kashmira wanted the name of the ex-fiance to be brought up earlier. Judy and a few others got lost in the interiority of the main character. The start leads to some confusion with the main character on the train and then her going through her morning prior to getting on the train. All in all, it was generally well-received but could use some editing. 

Amit Trivedi, If Not for the Partition

Here is the feedback for If Not For The Partition.

1.  A reminder of what a mangalsutra is will be helpful

2.  Show Kedar’s internal thoughts after he writes poetry..

3  Need to describe the age or children in Uma’s classroom.

Presenters for September 19th

Jamie Nelson Noven

Amit Trivedi

Larry Summers

Kashmira Sheth

Mike Austin

FIFTH TUESDAY:  The next Fifth Tuesday is October 31. At least two members expressed reservations about gathering on Halloween. We’ll discuss it again on Sept. 19, when more members may chime in.

Also, as a result of the discussion last night, the next time we hold a Fifth Tuesday–whenever that is–we’re going to try a suggestion from Jerry Peterson regarding the writing challenge. Instead of up to 500 words, we’re going to insist on exactly 69 words (not including title)–no more, no less. Prose or poetry, but responsive to the agreed-upon prompt and exactly 69 words. Jerry claims this has been very popular in the Beloit group.

And a final thought, again about caring:

“Find a subject you care about and which you in your heart feel others should care about. It is this genuine caring, not your games with language, which will be the most compelling and seductive element in your style.”

Stephen King

Read Full Post »

Older Posts »