Sept 19, 2023
The first word…
“If you write one story, it may be bad; if you write a hundred, you have the odds in your favor.” Edgar Rice Burroughs. He also said, regarding the pulp fiction magazines of that time, “… if people were paid for writing rot such as I read in some of those magazines, that I could write stories just as rotten.” And then he went on to write “Tarzan,” which spawned a “Tarzan” empire.
Comment Summaries
A grand total of six people presented work on Tuesday. Here are summaries of critiques.
Larry Sommers, Military Memoir, Chapters 3-4: There was consensus it was well-written, and especially that Chapter 4, the introduction to the Chinese language by Robert Tharp, was explained clearly and with just enough detail to make it interesting and swift. Jack pointed out that the scene in Ch. 3 with Sergeant Decouteau focused too much on him and not enough on my own reactions. Jaime pointed out that in Chapter 4 by having Tharp read our minds, I introduced unneeded duplication. Thanks, everybody!
Jaime presented a chapter of New York, After All. Kashmira suggested dialing back on the description of the new office at the beginning of the chapter, and Jack wondered if it’s worth introducing a new space at all if she’s going to leave it. We discussed hotdesking and whether elevators would work if things have gotten so bad that there’s no internet or cell phones. A very good question on how fast these paper samples are arriving from China. Larry liked the part about paper and recalled the newspaper being printed on the back of wallpaper during the Siege of Vicksburg. Mike liked the scenes with Danny and felt bad for the collapse of their friendship. Thanks, all!
Mike Austin, Backroads (working title) Mike presented chapters 10-11. Right off the bat, we found that there are too many “thems” in just a few paragraphs. Which tells Mike, once again, how valuable it is to read the piece out loud. The chapters were favorably received in spite of this. There needs to be more provocation from Smitty that causes Ida to take up her pitchfork against him. And we need to have more of a reaction from Nick after the knife is thrown at him. Or perhaps not even have the knife thrown, and save the real confrontation for Ida. Thanks!
Amit and Kashmira submitted chapters 27-28 of INFP
Some felt that the pov from Ba and Gauri Kaki was breaking up the flow. Although Amber thought it worked fine. Jaime thought two in a row was a difficult transition. Verb tenses were not always right. There were some formatting issues.
Emotional depth was good. Thank you.
Kashmira submitted two picture books.
Jungle Meeting: Amber liked the revised version. Larry suggested a slight tweak at the end and also a possible title, I’m Going to a Meeting.
Poet’s Daughter: Jack suggested a few word additions/changes for flow as well as meaning. He also suggested extra space/ breaking up lines for emphasis. Mike wondered about using, “monstrous worm” in the first poem. Larry thought the pain of separation came though the story. Thank you.
Rupa submitted her picture book Flying Like Bees. Larry thought it was a well-structured story. Judy thought it needed a better transition and more active role from mom. Jaime wanted a clearer understanding of passage of time. Amber liked the story. She couldn’t tell what mom can and can’t do. Larry like that vagueness. Thank you all.
Who’s next?
Presenters for October 3rd so far are:
Judy Cummings
Mike Austin
Larry Sommers
So we have a few open slots. Feel free to jump in.
Announcement:
Congratulations to writer Amber Boudreau! She was awarded third place in the Best of Madison in the Local Author category.
On writing…
A Writer’s Conceit
Paper is immune to the corrosive effects of a good story.
A story is like acid, eating a hole in you until you spill it out onto paper. When it hits the page it does not eat the paper but simply spreads over it in a pattern of black marks, which can be rearranged however you see fit without any further holes being eaten in anybody—except, perhaps, the reader.
—Larry F. Sommers
Next month our editor will be Kashmira Sheth. Thanks for reading!
Leave a Reply