Tuesdays with Story
September 2, 2024
The first word…
From “How to Write Good,” by Michael O’Donoghue: “My advice to the would-be-writer is that he start slowly, writing short undemanding things, things such as telegrams, flip-books, crank letters, signature scarves, spot quizzes, capsule summaries, fortune cookies and errata. Then, when he feels he’s ready, move up to the more challenging items such as mandates, objective correlatives, passion plays, pointless diatribes, minor classics, manifestos, mezzotints, oxymora, exposes, broadsides, and papal bulls.”
Meeting on Tuesday evening, five writers presented their work for discussion.
Kashmira and Amit, untitled story.
Relationship between Sanjay and Himanshu is not clear…
The opening line is a bit confusing – need to be be reworked
Overall the chapters are interesting and the story has a lot of potential.
Kashmira’s story – Valmiki
Group liked the story and Valmiki’s character
The scene between the parents in the car can be toned down a bit.
The humor is well done throughout.
.
Thanks!
Larrry S., Brother’s Blood, Ch12-13: Need to spell out more details on timing of Jag’s flight home, how Pop found out about the damage to the car, etc. Pop’s response to the damage seems strangely subdued; use Harold’s internal reaction to put that in context. Thanks, all. Very helpful.
Suzanne Kaleidoscope (Chapters 31 and 32)
There were a couple of thoughts that I should use Grandmother’s mansion as a metaphor for her personality. More detail should be added, including more descriptions of the paintings. There should be more buildup over Rattlesnake Man–escaping before Carey and Brandon leave for San Francisco, and adding in more throughout the book of Carey’s worry over Rattlesnake Man. There should be more tears, either from Brandon or his grandmother over the revelation they both have synesthesia. Kashmira wants to see more about Carey and Brandon’s time in Puerto Rico which could be a way to add more depth to their relationship.
As always, thanks for the feedback! My book is stronger because of it.
What Blood Runs Through Me by Wendy B. Chapters were well received. Suggestions mostly focused on the small details that can make or break a story. Deleting a few unnecessary adjectives, shifting sentences to different location, checking the time frame on slang. Officer Montgomery as a new character was liked. And yes, Larry, only a slight exaggeration that Chicago streets can have more potholes than pavement. Thank you all for your feedback.
Our next meeting will be September 17. Writers volunteering to present their work are:
Paul W
Kashmira S
Amit T
Larry S.
Wendy B.
Your editor for this issue is Mike Austin. Blame him. Suzanne Gillingham is editor for September 17th. If you have any news of writing events or information, send them to Suzanne.
The final word…
“If you write one story, it may be bad; if you write a hundred, you have the odds in your favor.” Edgar Rice Burroughs
Read Full Post »