Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘book-reviews’

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
11/3/2026

First word:

“Hiring someone to write your autobiography is like hiring someone to take a bath for you.” – Mae West


Tuesday evening. . .

7 writers attended the meeting. 5 presented:

Bob K. – Say What You Want, Ch. 7: The good news is that Updike and Lennie are becoming more fully rounded characters, each with virtues and faults, each mirroring the dystopia around them. Some thoughts came in regarding the makeshift manner in which gasoline is distributed as the social order crumbles.

Kashmira S – Kashmira submitted two picture book manuscripts:

–To the Zoo We Go: the feedback was positive. A few tweaks are needed and illustrations can make the story come alive. It can add a lot of humor.


–Made to Dance: also had a positive response. Again, there was a suggestion to change the word epic. Other than that the repetition of drum sound adds a lot to the story. Just need to find a fantastic illustrator.

Sue G. – Betrayal of Sabathea, Ch.19: Overall, the comments were favorable regarding the chapter. There was a suggestion that Max should describe his headache less clinically, such as “it felt like someone was hitting my head with a baseball bat”. Other comments were that there should be fewer references to the screaming/yelling children and more about Max’s feelings about the situation.

Sue G. – Betrayal of Sabathea, Ch. 20: The reviewers didn’t have any suggestions regarding submission changes and were interested with where the story was going.

Sara H. – YOUTH Phase II:

  • Nice flow to excerpt
  • Initial introduction is jarring, but then the rest flows fine
  • Topical/timely subject matter
  • Last part should be kept in, but for excerpt contest purposes, leave out
  • Make the stakes higher for mom to give her kids up: she’ll seem more sympathetic
  • Make it clearer she didn’t have a choice
  • Make the money for college more? Delete money part all together?
  • Do I need therapist scene? No consensus
  • Larry has specific suggestions regarding first paragraph
  • Name protagonist earlier on, maybe through dialogue
  • Start with mother losing kids?
  • Colons and semi-colons are too much
  • More interaction between Louise and husband earlier on


November 13th Presenters:

Larry S.

Sue G.

Kashmira S.

The Last word:

“The man with a new idea is a crank until the idea succeeds.”

-Mark Twain

Read Full Post »

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
Feb 3, 2026

The first word . . .

“I write entirely to find out what I’m looking at, what I see and what it means. What I want and what I fear.” Joan Didion

“Writing is a job, a talent, but it’s also a place to go in your head.” Ann Patchett

Seven writers met, in person and via Zoom. The following six presented work. 

Tuesday Evening . . .

Susan S (Bienvenue a Nice)

Positive feedback with only a couple of minor edit suggestions.

Bob K (Call Me)

Call Me works as a slice-of-life piece, but less so as an actual story. Mainly because there is no real conflict or growth. Nothing at stake. Larry pointed out that the introduction of the arguing couple and the woman at the jewelry counter raises the tension which gives the situation greater depth. A small improvement. Another small improvement is that the relationship between the central characters is better defined than before. Thanks to all for the excellent comments.

Jack F (A Walk Upon the Water Chaps 54-55)

We got Lester into a suit and Skip into a handpainted tie.  Readers seemed to appreciate the change in Lester and found it believable. These were slight chapters, move the story ahead chapters, and I received multiple typo corrections.

Larry S (Brother’s Blood Chap 22-23)

No detailed report. All comments were considered and the necessary changes to the manuscript were made accordingly,

Sue G (A Sparkle in the Swamp 2nd half)

Overall, the critiques were positive. There were some rephrasing suggestions to tighten up the dialogue. Also, several people thought it would be good to show Marcus smiling, winking, etc at Emily, causing her to misinterpret these behaviors.

Kashmira S (Veena’s Story Chaps 34-37)

Kashmira submitted chapter 34-37 of Veena’s story. The historical part of the story comes out well. Sardar being arrested and jailed and how it encourages people needs to be reworked to make it clear. Dadima’s character is well developed throughout the story and her death scene was moving. Veena’s concerns and participation in the freedom fight is believable. Overall, good chapters.

Who’s up next . . .  

Susan S.

Larry S.

Sue G.

Kashmira S.

Jack F.

Mike A.

For the good of the order . . . 

If you’re looking for a small, but excellent writer’s conference try The Lakefly Writer’s Conference. It will be held in Oshkosh on May 1-2, 2026

The last word . . .

“When a reader puts a story aside because it ‘got boring,’ the boredom arose because the writer grew enchanted with his powers of description and lost sight of his priority, which is to keep the ball rolling.” Stephen King

And for the fun of it . . .

“Many people hear voices when there is no one there. Some of them are called ‘mad” and are shut up in rooms where they stare at the walls all day. Others are called ‘writers’ and do pretty much the same thing.” Ray Bradbury

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays with Story

September 2, 2024

The first word…

From “How to Write Good,” by Michael O’Donoghue: “My advice to the would-be-writer is that he start slowly, writing short undemanding things, things such as telegrams, flip-books, crank letters, signature scarves, spot quizzes, capsule summaries, fortune cookies and errata. Then, when he feels he’s ready, move up to the more challenging items such as mandates, objective correlatives, passion plays, pointless diatribes, minor classics, manifestos, mezzotints, oxymora, exposes, broadsides, and papal bulls.”

Meeting on Tuesday evening, five writers presented their work for discussion.

Kashmira and Amit,  untitled story.

Relationship between Sanjay and Himanshu is not clear…

The opening line is a bit confusing – need to be be reworked

Overall the chapters are interesting and the story has a lot of potential.

Kashmira’s story – Valmiki

Group liked the story and Valmiki’s character

The scene between the parents in the car can be toned down a bit.

The humor is well done throughout.

 .

Thanks!

Larrry S., Brother’s Blood, Ch12-13: Need to spell out more details on timing of Jag’s flight home, how Pop found out about the damage to the car, etc. Pop’s response to the damage seems strangely subdued; use Harold’s internal reaction to put that in context.  Thanks, all. Very helpful.

Suzanne Kaleidoscope (Chapters 31 and 32)

There were a couple of thoughts that I should use Grandmother’s mansion as a metaphor for her personality. More detail should be added, including more descriptions of the paintings. There should be more buildup over Rattlesnake Man–escaping before Carey and Brandon leave for San Francisco, and adding in more throughout the book of Carey’s worry over Rattlesnake Man. There should be more tears, either from Brandon or his grandmother over the revelation they both have synesthesia. Kashmira wants to see more about Carey and Brandon’s time in Puerto Rico which could be a way to add more depth to their relationship.

As always, thanks for the feedback! My book is stronger because of it.

What Blood Runs Through Me by Wendy B. Chapters were well received. Suggestions mostly focused on the small details that can make or break a story. Deleting a few unnecessary adjectives, shifting sentences to different location, checking the time frame on slang. Officer Montgomery as a new character was liked. And yes, Larry, only a slight exaggeration that Chicago streets can have more potholes than pavement. Thank you all for your feedback.

Our next meeting will be September 17. Writers volunteering to present their work are:

         Paul W

         Kashmira S

         Amit T

         Larry S.

         Wendy B.

Your editor for this issue is Mike Austin. Blame him. Suzanne Gillingham is editor for September 17th. If you have any news of writing events or information, send them to Suzanne.

The final word…

         “If you write one story, it may be bad; if you write a hundred, you have the odds in your favor.” Edgar Rice Burroughs

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays with Story
June 18, 2024

The first word . . .

The secret of it all is to write…without waiting for a fit time or place. – Walt Whitman

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)

Wendy’s ‘What Blood Runs Through Me’ submission included the opening and closing paragraphs from Part 1 and the transition into Part 2. Suzanne posed the excellent question of why Tommy’s ghost doesn’t appear anywhere except the opening lines of chapter one. She also noticed a disconnect in the time line between parts one and two. Other suggestions included increasing the urgency of Michael’s investigation due to June’s failing health and using the scrapbook throughout the story. Great suggestions! Thank you all.  

Suzanne G. (Kaleidoscope Ch. 26)

Per the group-two of the scenes in the chapter need some clarification. In the first scene, there was a consensus that it’s confusing for there to be no emotions from Michael and Joe, even if Brandon doesn’t see any colors. Wendy and Amit had some problems with Brandon hiring a PI, without asking Carey if it was okay. Kashmira thinks Brandon is preoccupied with his relationship with Carey. Larry had a few minor questions but overall thought the chapter flowed well. Thanks to all for the input. I very much appreciate your comments. 

Amit T. and Kashmira S. INFTP – Chapter 48-end of story

1.  Story ending was well done and satisfying.

2.  The dialogue between Uma and Hari needs to show more emotions from both of them. It is good now but can be improved.

3. Need to show what Kedar and Hari are thinking of each other. Absence of this leaves the reader wondering.

4. Sail boat scene is done very nicely.

Thanks, all.

Bob K. Say What You Want, chapter 6:

Everybody loved this chapter – the dialogue, the character descriptions, etc. Except that the first half did not measure up with the second. Point taken. The second half could benefit from a little more scene painting and a lot more reaction from Lennie and Mead. The other thing was the final sentence. Opinion was split between appreciating that the mention of an umbrella bookended the chapter and suggesting that the sentence be dropped altogether. Thanks all for the thought-provoking comments.

Kashmira S.  Agaria’s Story Ch.13-14

The story seems to be moving along well. There were some questions about the Hamsa and the Karna’s question about him being a pet of Hamsa. The Nala and Damyanti story is working out well. The swing scene needs to be flashed out more. The pace is good. More description about the city through Karna’s eyes is needed. Thank you all!

Who’s up next . . . 

Wendy B.

Suzanne G.

Kashmira S.

We have three more slots open.

The last word . . .

“A writer can do nothing for men more necessary, satisfying, than just simply to reveal to them the infinite possibility of their own souls.” — Walt Whitman.

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays with Story
December 5, 2023

The first word . . .

“Truth is stranger than fiction but it is because fiction is obliged to stick to possibilities; truth isn’t.” Mark Twain

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)

Some excellent suggestions were made for the three chapters reviewed. First and foremost was the need to identify that June is the narrator and not a reference to the month of June. Needless to say, this caused some confusion. Also pointed out was the need for reorganizing some of the sentences and paragraphs, as well as trimming certain descriptions. The suggestion for increased internal thought was spot-on and greatly appreciated. Thank you all for taking the time to review!

Mike A. (Backroads, Chapters 21-22)

Mike A., Backroads Chapters 21-22, received favorable reviews all around. There was some confusion about Red being the bank robber and whether Stevens had hired him, or he was robbing it on his own (which he was).  I also need to use more active verbs instead of passive. And I just looked up “past simple vs past progressive” in reference to “He wore” (for instance) versus “He was wearing.” I hadn’t thought about there being words to define those forms, but see that those are forms I need to keep in mind. I’m learning grammar! Thanks everyone. 

(more…)

Read Full Post »