Tuesdays With Story
November 7, 2023
First Word…
“Write what should not be forgotten.”
— Isabel Allende, author
Tuesday evening…
Five TWS writers attended the meeting via Google Meet, four of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:
—Larry F. Sommers, Brother’s Blood, Ch. 1-2: There was general agreement that the new Chapter 1 makes Jag a more understandable and sympathetic character, even though he’ll never be warm and fuzzy. Jaime said there are too many names to keep track of in Ch. 1, and perhaps Wendell’s plan to bribe the pilot into aerobatics could be introduced earlier and smoother. Someone suggested that Pop might be made a bit softer edged in Ch. 1 because he has not yet had to face the Depression. But maybe he is a WWI veteran and thus inured to sudden death. Good things to think about. Thanks, everybody.
—Bob Kralapp, Whistling in the Dark, short story: The characters need to be developed. And then the relationships between them need to be spelled out. These were the two main comments that I received. Others focused on the moodiness and underlying tension of the story, as well as the possible psychological dimension of the mysterious goings-on in the basement. Thanks, all.
—Mike Austin, Backroads, chapters 18-20. Thanks everyone for the great comments and suggestions. I see that I actually have to sit down and do some research, and pin down a more definite time, especially regarding when Edgar’s father would have lost the farm. I was also repeating Edgar’s backstory with first him and then Ethel talking about it. Thanks again!
—Suzanne Gillingham submitted a rewrite of Chapter 14 of Kaleidoscope. Jamie thought that Brandon’s panic at not knowing where Carey was worked well. She also thought there needed to be a sub-plot or two. Larry mentioned he feels whipsawed with all of the highs and lows in Brandon’s and Carey’s relationship–a scene or two with them spending time with friends and without a crisis would help. Bob thinks Lily is a great character but isn’t integrated into the story. Mike is having trouble liking either character, and especially doesn’t like Carey’s cruelty toward Brandon. He too liked Lily and her “groundedness.”
Thanks for the comments. I have much to think about.
Here’s who’s up (so far) on November 21…
Jaime Nelson Noven, New York After All
Mike Austin, Backroads
Suzanne Gillingham, Kaleidoscope
Second Word…
The very reason I write is so that I might not sleepwalk through my entire life.
From National Geographic, by way of Larry Sommers…
“Storytelling is universal and is as ancient as humankind. Before there was writing, there was storytelling. It occurs in every culture and from every age. It exists (and existed) to entertain, to inform, and to promulgate cultural traditions and values.”
Our Editor for November…
Bob Kralapp has taken on Writer’s Mail for the month of November. Send him the good stuff.
Last Word…
“A well-thought-out story doesn’t need to resemble real life. Life itself tries with all its might to resemble a well-crafted story.”
― Isaac Babel, author
Leave a Reply