Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘Writing Critique’

Tuesdays with Story

August 15, 2023

The First Word…

People don’t talk like this, theytalklikethis. Syllables, words, sentences run together like a watercolor left in the rain. To understand what anyone is saying to us we must separate these noises into words and the words into sentences so that we might in our turn issue a stream of mixed sounds in response.

~BILL BRYSON

Summary of Tuesday’s meeting:

–Suzanne Gillingham (Kaleidoscope, 12-13) Larry would like to see the actual introductions at the party and not a summary. Jamie agreed. Jack thought that once again, I used too many conjunctions. Thanks everyone for the feedback.

–Amit Trivedi & Kashmira Sheth (If Not for the Partition, 23-24) Kedar’s letter can be improved by making it more universal than personal by adding broader historical facts. Need more reaction from Virabha before answering Kedar who says he wants to stay in Girnar and not go back to Uma. Chapters are bit slow moving and need some more action to hold interest. These are important chapters and need to be improved to maximize impact.

–Jack Freiburger (Chapter X – A Jew): Not much feedback given.

–Jaime Nelson Noven (New York After All, Charlie Memoir8) Not a lot of changes were recommended, but the group generally liked it and is curious to see where it’s all leading.

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays with Story
August 1, 2023

The first word . . .

Tension from Nothing:

Step 1: Find in your story a moment when nothing at all is happening.

Step 2: Identify the point-of-view character. Write down whatever emotion he is feeling at this moment. Also, write down its opposite.

Step 3: Note three or more details of the time and place of this dead moment. What objects are around? What exact kind of light, or darkness? At what pace is time moving? What mood is in the air? What is different now than a day ago?

Step 4: How would your character describe the state of his/her being at this moment?

Step 5: Create a passage in which this moment of action is filled with everything you created in the steps above, especially the contrasting emotions.

Some experience is intangible, yet that which is not outwardly active can still be dynamic. Every minute has a mood. Every moment has meaning. Mood is built from environmental details and meaning proceeds from emotions. Tension springs from the weaving of these elements into a passage that precisely captures small visual details and surgically dissects the enormous feelings that fill a silence.

The Fire in Fiction: Passion, Purpose, and Techniques to Make your Novel Great

–Donald Maass

Tuesday evening

Six TWS writers attended the meeting. Here is a summary of what was said:

–Judy Cummings (A Real Hero, Chapters 26-28)

Kashmira and Larry remarked on the tone shift in the scene where Steve confronts the Wolf on the river trail. They suggested transitioning to this scene more smoothly by having Steve give up all belief in his conspiracy theories just before the Wolf appears. That way both the reader and Steve will be surprised that Steve was actually correct in sensing there was danger afoot.

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays With Story

July 18, 2023

First Word…

The secret of it all, is to write in the gush, the throb, the flood, of the moment – to put things down without deliberation – without worrying about their style – without waiting for a fit time or place. I always worked that way. I took the first scrap of paper, the first doorstep, the first desk, and wrote – wrote, wrote…By writing at the instant the very heartbeat of life is caught

Walt Whitman

 

Tuesday evening…

Six TWS writer attended the meeting (two in person four via Zoom). Here is a summary of what was said:

Larry F. Sommers, Brother’s Blood, Chs. 3-7:  

An in-depth discussion of chapters to date brought forth the following points: (1) By group consensus, Jag is still not likeable and the narrative is not very engaging. (2) Jack and Judy pointed out that the reader does not get deep enough into Jag’s head. (3) Jack suggested that more physical scene-setting could place Jag in his landscape and thereby make his personality more accessible. (4) Also, Jack mentioned, all of Jag’s calculations and actions seem tied to economic goals—but is that what he really wants, or is there some higher, more spiritual or transcendent need he is addressing? (5) Kashmira wants to see humanity in Jag, who seems to be all calculation and no heart. He should grow emotionally, she points out, in response to Hal’s accident. In addition to these deep structural concerns, Jack pointed out that Taylor needs to see the injured Hal before he can utter concerns based on his fall; and Jaime insisted that Doc Bede needs to be more forthcoming about Hal’s condition, perhaps with more medical lingo. This is all terrific feedback, and I shall ponder it deeply and thoroughly. Thanks, everybody.

Amit Trivedi: If Not fot the Partition, Chs 20-22

Here are the main comments:

Uma’s chapter moves slowly as far as her getting ready to leave Sihor. Needs more urgency and emotions. Papa’s chapter was powerful. POV change for Papa’s (Instead of Uma or Kedar) chapter was a problem though.

Kashmira Sheth: Go to Sleep Baby Rakshasi

Comments were made regarding Dad’s response to Mayika and also using more appropriate (like tiger/hunting) request by Baby Rakshasi. Also everyone felt that the illustration will add a lot to the story. Thank you for your comments.

Being a Toddler is Not Terrific:

The main question was who the audience is for the story. There were also other comments regarding the flow etc. of the story. Thank you.

Judy Cummings: A Real Hero, Chapters 24-25.

Recommendations were made to linger a bit on Steve’s disappointment when he thought his team would lose the scrap contest and spend less time on Steve’s discovery that Miss Brown is related to Blue-Eyes and more time on what this means to him. Thanks, everyone. 

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays with Story
6/10/23

Please note: the TWS meeting scheduled for June 20th did not take place. The next Newsletter will arrive after July 18th.

The first word . . .

“Be bold on the page. Don’t cower. Don’t conform to society when you sit down at the desk. Tear it down. Question everything. Enact subversion. Enact indecency, outrage, unsavory desire.” —Joshua Ferris, author (interview on LitHub)

Tuesday evening on Zoom . . .

Nine TWS writers flocked together to work through the short stories and chapters of six of their colleagues. Here is some of what was said:

— Mike Austin (Backroads, chapters 4-7) . . . I received a lot of great input for Backroads. Chapter five was the weakest of the chapters, and needs some development, but is still worth keeping in with some work. The introduction of Ben’s crew on the dock is confusing at times, and it’s hard to tell who is who and just when they came into the picture. Ben needs to be a little less verbose so that he keeps his dark character. If he talks too much, he loses that. And Nick needs more internal observations going on with each situation. He still somewhat one-dimensional. Everyone seems to like the Ida character, but it seems that introducing someone new this far in needs more context. For that, I’ll just have to keep going ahead and see how it works out. Thanks everyone!

— Judy Cummings (A Real Hero, chapters 21-23) . . . Cut the wordiness, specifically the conjunctions. Give Steve a stronger, angrier reaction to Margaret calling him a lazy patriot. This will both be a more appropriate build up to Steve’s explosion at the end of the chapter and make Margaret’s comment about no one ever wanting to kiss Steve seen less out-of-left field. Let the reader know where in the Bible Steve is searching for answers to his big questions. Thanks for the feedback!

— Bob Kralapp (“Nostalgia” rewrite) . . . Reaction to Nostalgia was mixed. The story’s underlying air of threat and expectancy, though interesting, was not enough to sustain it. The passage with the woman with pale green hair needs to be reimagined. The description of how she and her daughter are positioned at the hurricane fence is not clear. Also, the feelings motivating David’s fascination with the scene need to be explored.

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays With Story

May 16, 2023

First Word…

“Create dangerously, for people who read dangerously. This is what I’ve always thought it meant to be a writer. Writing, knowing in part that no matter how trivial your words may seem, someday, somewhere, someone may risk his or her life to read them.”

— Edwige Dandicat, Create Dangerously

Tuesday evening…

Eight TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, six of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Judy Cummings – A Real Hero, Chs. 18-20. Larry noted that the wording of the Bible verse referenced in Chapter 18 did not exist in 1944. Amber suggested that Steve might reveal some jealousy of Gordy’s ability to keep his innocent fantasies about superheroes. There was discussion of the likelihood of a deep foxhole near the river caving in and a recommendation to move it to higher ground. Thanks for the feedback.

Jack Freiburger – Jesus at the Ihop, Ch. VII. The written comments I received were very helpful and had some questions.  Made a few edits as a result.

The discussion mostly had to do with adding a foil for Jesus.  I read ahead and we have two more chapters without a interlocutory in the chapters, until we get to the Jew in the Basket. Chapter VIII for next time is again in the mind of Jesus and the next is a travelog.  I’ll consider once we get to Chapter XI and we see how things are going.  J

Kashmira Sheth & Amit Trivedi – If Not For the Partition, Chs. 18, 19. The chapters worked well. Larry pointed out the tense shift in Kedar’s chapter. Jack wanted to tweak a few sentences in Uma’s chapter and mention the food from the previous chapter. Judy wrote in her note that she wanted to see Uma thinking more about the resistance against the government rather than her personal loss. She also thought that the flashback was too long and Virabha’s chapter should be told from Kedar’s POV. Overall, everyone liked the new part.

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story Newsletter

April 4th Meeting

The First Word

“Advice? I don’t have advice. Stop aspiring and start writing.

—Alan Wilson Watts

Nine writers met via Zoom to offer input for the submitted stories and to watch Larry spill his wine. In truth, it was more heard than seen, and free of profanity. Wonderful restraint on Larry’s part.

Submission Summaries

Bob Kralapp, “Delay”

The areas of the story that need work include the ending, which reads as inconclusive. As it stands, there is little evidence to judge how Kathe’s folks will react to the gas station incident Baker must reveal. Likewise, it isn’t clear whether Baker and Kathe are suited for each other, and there needs to be some narrative backfill in order to bring it all together. The nature of the drinking game around the kitchen table should be clarified. Thanks, all, for the helpful comments.

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays with Story
March 7, 2023

The first word . . .

“Each writer is born with a repertory company in his head. Shakespeare has perhaps 20 players. … I have 10 or so, and that’s a lot. As you get older, you become more skillful at casting them.”
—Gore Vidal

Tuesday evening on Zoom . . . and in person at Larry’s place, eight TWS writers gathered together to critique the chapters and a short story 6 of their colleagues shared with the group. Here is some of what was said:

— Kashmira Sheth & Amit Trivedi (chapters 8-10, If Not For the Partition) . . . 1. Tense is not right in some places. 2. Uma’s letter to Rukhi seems more distance and detached. & 3. The cricket scene was very effective.

— Suzanne Gillingham (chapters 1&2 rewrite, Kaleidoscope) . . . There was universal agreement that Chapters 1 and Chapter 2 should be expanded to include more information on why Brandon, as a child, thought he was seeing souls, on the loneliness of the two men, and on their attraction to each other. Jack suggested expanding “routes” to include Brandon’s lack of routes in his life. Larry gave some suggestions on making my writing more personal.  Amit would like to see some difference in how the two characters react. Right now their reactions seem too similar. Thanks everyone! I appreciate the input.

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays With Story

February 21, 2023

First Word…

“Writing is not an exercise in excision, it’s a journey into sound.”

—E. B. White, author, essayist

Tuesday evening…

Eight TWS writers met via Google Meet to discuss works-in-progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

—Kashmira Sheth (Raj’s Coat Story)… Kashmira submitted a picture book manuscript. Most of the comments were positive. Jack and Larry suggested some tweaking about the food and also the ending. Bob liked the part with pockets and said it was magical! Amit suggested changing, “buttons running up and down,” to “buttons flying up and down.” Judy suggested adding smell, texture etc. in certain parts of the story.  Amber enjoyed the story. Thank you!

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays With Story

February 7,, 2023

First Word…

“Be a good steward of your gifts. Protect your time. Feed your inner life. Avoid too much noise. Read good books, have good sentences in your ears. Be by yourself as often as you can. Walk. Take the phone off the hook. Work regular hours.”

—Jane Kenyon, from A Hundred White Daffodils

Tuesday evening…

Eight TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, five of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

—Amber Boudreau…Amber read from chapter 25 of her urban fantasy Second Act. Most seemed to agree both chapters moved the story along well, but the beginning of chapter 25 could use some work in grounding the reader in the main character’s point of view. Unbeknownst to Amber, some people didn’t receive the chapters, so there weren’t a ton of comments. Therefore, it was amazing and people can’t wait to read more.

—John Freiburger…Started the revised, amended continued etc. Jesus Walked into the Ihop.

The brief email sent to explain the concept was recommended as a forward to separate a consideration of the Christian message from Iconoclasm. It seems the work is now willingly accepted as speculative Christology.

The voice is light, colloquial, and at times humorous in the first two chapters, which will require effort to continue. If you too found yourself to be 2000 years old, resurrected from the dead and somewhat lost in ever-changing cultures and “Christian” religions that are wildly at odds with each other, you might also have a skeptical voice and a somewhat perplexed and humorous approach to the world.

—Judy Cummings… A Real Hero, Chapters 12-13

There was some discussion over whether the plot was developing too quickly. A suggestion was made to lengthen the timeline in order for Steve’s dad to develop more trust in Blue-Eyes. The group highlighted some places where readers’ believability was stretched. Thanks for the feedback. 

—Amit Trivedi…If Not For The Partition, Chapters 4, 5

Write in depth the  ‘monkey’ and ‘train’  scenes. Cut the too childish love scenes. The flashback was too long. Also, it was hard to figure out when it was over. Since the book is in present tense, it was suggested to consider using past tense for flashbacks. Thanks, Amit.

—Bob Kralapp…Paper Wasps, a short story.

Reaction to the story was mixed. Some wanted more from the ending, while others felt that it was satisfying. Scenes presented in the first part were somewhat muddy and needed to be crisper. Many good buildups were created (the bully girl, the drugstore conversation, the damp garbage bag that didn’t rip open, etc.), but were left undeveloped. Thanks to all for the excellent comments.

—Larry F. Sommers… Untitled WWII novel, first two chapters.

In this version the older brother, Jag, is more relatable as a brother. He still needs more interiority, more sense of his remorse over Hal’s injury. The early morning scene placed in front of the coal mine scene helps fill out the context, but the opening dream sequence either needs to be cut entirely (John) or greatly enhanced (Jack). Thanks, everybody. Your feedback has been very helpful.

February 21, here’s who’s on deck…

John Schneller – Precious Daughter

Paul Wagner – ?

Judy Cummings – A Real Hero

Amit Trivedi – If Not For the Partition

Jack Freiburger – ?

Amber Boudreau – Second Act

Bob Kralapp takes on Writer’s Mail for the month of February.

Cliches…

The standard opinion is to steer clear of cliches. (Avoid them like the …) Which is

reasonably good advice on its face. And then there is the advice to approach them with caution. Know what you’re dealing with. Also good advice. Being informed. First, there is the cliched phrase. And then there is the cliched situation. Beginning a story with a dream being one of the latter. Reasons for avoiding it come down to it being a ‘bait and switch’ tactic. That is: the reader is presented with a situation that has little or nothing to do with the story that follows. The one novel I know of that starts with a dream is Ursula Le Guin’s The Lathe of Heaven. And that opening isn’t even a dream, but a description of the dreamer awakening. Which is to say, a reclaiming of the cliche, a reimagining of what was an exhausted convention. Whether that sort of opening can ever be used again is open to debate. Probably not. But it goes to the point that an informed writer can breathe life into the deadest of dead clichés.

Last Word…

“I approach the work as though, in truth, I’m nothing and the words are everything. Then I write to save my life. If you are a writer, that will be true. Writing has saved my life.”

—Louise Erdrich

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays with Story
January 3, 2023

The first word . . .

“The profession of book-writing makes horse racing seem like a solid, stable business.”

John Steinbeck

Tuesday Evening . . .

Mike Austin (The Reed Gang, Chapter 1)

Chapter 1 of The Reed Gang (working title) was well received. I need to change some names. Red and Ned just doesn’t work. And I need to introduce the characters more, with descriptions. We had some discussion about the drunk girl, and whether she should be older. But having her younger has more of an impact. Nick’s involvement with the other four needs to be explained, and I’m thinking that I’ll move that introduction so it’s before this chapter. Thanks!

Kashmira Sheth (I Am From Here Too, first 15 pages)

Kashmira submitted the first fifteen pages of her novel in verse, I am From Here Too. The main thing discussed was how to weave a conflict or a hint of it earlier. The writing worked well for the most part. There was also a discussion about writing about Sikh faith and what kind of research was needed. 

Larry F. Sommers (Untitled, Chapters 1 and 2)

Larry F. Sommers, Untitled WWII novel, Chs. 1 and 2:  The main point all agreed on was that Jag, and to some extent, Hal as well, are not likable characters. Too cold and self-involved. More human facets of their inner lives need to be disclosed. It was suggested that the first paragraph, introducing Hal, be omitted to begin with the second graf on the coal-scooping action. John pointed out that tidying up the coal dust partway through the job didn’t make sense, and he suggested that Hal and Jag hold an active productivity competition. Great feedback, everybody, thanks.

Amit Trivedi (If Not for the Partition, Chapters 1 and 2)

Overall the revised chapters were received very well. A few changes were suggested regarding reducing the number of characters in the first chapter, changing the order of paragraphs and giving more details about the bazaar (scent and sounds) and a bit more explanation of the geo-political background.

Thanks all!

Judy Cummings (A Real Hero, Chapters 8 and 9)

The group gave overall positive feedback on these chapters, specifically the protagonist’s struggle between duty and young romance, the voice, and the emotional pull whenever the protagonist’s missing brother is mentioned. Larry suggested changing the German so it’s clear to the reader that the protagonist isn’t fluent in the language. Thanks for the feedback, everyone.

Who’s up next . . . 

Jack Freiburger

Amber Boudreau

Amit Trivedi

Judy Cummings

Kashmira Sheth

Suzanne Gillingham

For the good of the order . . .

Our Fifth Tuesday gathering will be held Jan. 31 at Jack’s place, Hickory Knoll Farm. It will be potluck. Jack will inform us what he’s providing and what we need to bring ourselves. 

The writing prompt is “The best prank ever.” Any form or format, 500 words max. Send to Larry by the end of Monday, January 30. 

The last word . . .

“Literature abhors the typical. Literature flows to the particular, the mundane, the greasiness of paper, the taste of warm beer, the smell of onion or quince.” 

Richard Rodriguez

Read Full Post »

« Newer Posts - Older Posts »