March 19, 2024
March is Women’s History Month—a celebration of women’s contributions to history, culture, and society. There are so many amazing women writers!
First Word: “Writing is a process, a journey into memory and the soul. Write what should not be forgotten.” Isabel Allende
Announcements: There will be five Tuesdays in April. An in-person gathering in the works?
Manuscript Discussion: Six member writers gathered in person or by Zoom to discuss six submissions.
Kashmira S. submitted chapters 4-5 of the Agaria story.
The group as a whole enjoyed it. There were some questions about logistics. For example, how Chitrak ended up sleeping there and needed clarification. There was also a comment about how mother’s skin may have suffered under the harsh sun and if Karna should mention that. Please remember that Karna is a boy and it is important to the story later on. Thank you for all your feedback.
Jack F. submitted chapter 12 of Jesus Walked into the IHOP
I was pleasantly surprised by the positive comments on the Imagine chapter. I do need a bright chapter on this part of the book because the next set of His adventures is still rather heavy. Jesus, like Christianity, has his ups and downs.
Taking April off for hip replacement will allow some writing time as well as research time. Who knows, maybe he goes to India next instead of Africa? Thanks for all the comments.
Amit T. and Kashmira S. INFTP, chapters 39 and 40
- Kedar’s reaction is very passive when he sees Uma with Hari. A more spirited reaction on his part is necessary than to just give in.
2. Kedar’s reaction to when Hari mentions Uma’s family is also very mild.
3. Should Uma take the lead in finding Kedar?
4. Show more of Kedar’s reflection on immediate past in his current thinking.
Suzanne G. submitted Chapter 21 of Kaleidoscope
Wendy thought the first two paragraphs could be stronger with some rewriting. She didn’t like the reference to the movie. It took her out of the scene. She wanted more detail in the sex scene. Larry thought the scenes were going the way they should and is hoping for a story climax soon. Several people don’t like the character of Emily (she seems unreal) nor Carey and Brandon’s fear of her. Kashmira wants more of a growth arc for Brandon. He’s too unsure of himself and their relationship. Amit thought the descriptions often slowed the story down. As always, thanks to everyone for your comments. They are helpful and much appreciated.
Wendy B. What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 15-16
Excellent feedback on fine-tuning the chapters. Flush out Clarksville with descriptions other than the church scene. Some solid word choices suggested. Changing whistle pigs to ground hogs—but don’t you just love the word(s) whistle pigs? Good chapter ending.
The short story, Jingle Bell Ginny, was also well received by the group. Interesting to know that It’s a Wonderful Life, did not become the Christmas classic it is today until almost thirty years after its 1946 release!
Next Up on April 3rd: Bob K, Suzanne G, Larry S, Wendy B, and Kashmira S and Amit T. One open slot.
Thank you all for forwarding your summaries in a timely fashion. Good luck to Jack on his hip replacement. Happy Easter!
Last Word: “The beginning is always today.” Mary Shelley