Tuesdays With Story
October, 3rd 2023
First Word…
“When I sit down to write a book, I do not say to myself, ‘I am going to produce a work of art.’ I write it because there is some lie that I want to expose, some fact to which I want to draw attention, and my initial concern is to get a hearing.”
—George Orwell
Tuesday evening…
Seven TWS writers attended the meeting via Google Meet, six of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:
Judy Cummings: A Real Hero, Chapters 30-32: Everyone thought the final chapters wrapped things up well and ended the story on a hopeful note. Kashmira suggested removing the earlier fishing scene so as to give more punch to the final family fishing scene. Larry questioned the use of the verb “bobbing” for turtle fishing. Thanks for the feedback, everybody!
Jaime Nelson Noven: a chapter of New York, After All.
We discussed whether we have a clear sense of what Charlie wants from life. The group generally felt the scene in the truck works, despite Jaime’s concerns about it being melodramatic. Kashmira suggested cutting the last line of the chapter.
Bob Kralapp: Whistling in the Dark.
Response to Whistling in the Dark was positive, though a few readers mentioned feelings of frustration. Some wanted a stronger connection between the mysterious presence in the basement and the bottled-up anger of the downstairs person. The climactic argument between Kevin and the narrator deals too much with the possible causes and needs to focus instead on Kevin’s response.
Mike Austin: Backroads, Chapters 12-14
The chapters were well received, but still need work. The jump in the story from Ida to Mary and Alice is confusing. Who are they and why are they suddenly in the story? Everyone liked Ida, and the general feeling was that she should stay in or return at some point after having invested so much in her story. I can also cut out Nick and the others traveling north and cut out the introductory piece for Mary. There needs to be more about Nick and what he’s feeling. There’s not enough depth to him. Thanks, everyone!
Larry F. Sommers, Military Memoir, Ch. 5:
Some people were unfamiliar with the term “Gentleman’s C.” Kashmira wanted a bit more on what made me fall in love with Joelle. Some people raised in the Lutheran tradition resonated with my description of studying Luther’s Small Catechism. Thanks, everyone.
Kashmira Sheth & Amit Trivedi: If Not For the Partition
Kashmira and Amit submitted a rewrite of the chapter from Kedar’s POV. It was well received and everyone thought it worked better than the one from Ba’s POV. There is a need for more internal thoughts and some revision regarding the language. Thanks, everyone for all your comments and edits.
Here’s who’s up on October 17…
Larry F. Sommers
Mike Austin
Bob Kralapp
Amit and Kashmira
There are two more spots left.
Last Word…
“Inspiration may sometimes fail to show up for work in the morning, but determination never does.”
— K.M. Weiland
Leave a Reply