September 5, 2023
TWS member John Schneller posted this in our newsletter a few years ago. I like the sentiment, so am re-posting it:
“A mistake for authors is defining their author platform as a list of people to market their next book on social media.
If you view your author platform as nothing more than transactional relationships, it will fail. If you view it primarily as sharing your heart and caring for a group of people, it will have far more value and possibly be responsive when you have a book.”
Dan Balow, Steve Laube Literary Agency
Summary of Tuesday’s Meeting
There were five presenters at Tuesday’s meeting. Here are the summaries of the feedback they received.
Larry F. Sommers, Military Memoir 1-2: Judy was momentarily disoriented by the parenthetical “(or affirm)” in the enlistment oath. Kashmira wanted concrete examples of the training methodology outlined in the first paragraphs of Ch. 2 and also looked for clearer suggestions of the author’s estrangement from the Air Force enlistment process and the prospect of future military service. These are very helpful comments. Thank you
Kashmira submitted two picture book manuscripts.
Overall, both the manuscripts needed some work. Walls was difficult to visualize as a picture book and needed more personal focus. Aaaarow! could use some tweaking, especially, the ending. Aaaarow title also was questioned. Everyone liked the child’s voice though. Thank you all.
Judy Cummings, A Real Hero, Chapters 29-30: The way I set up the revelation that Miss Brown is Blue-Eyes’ mother was done well. The humorous tone is consistent throughout the story. Tone down Steve’s observations of Miss Brown’s clothing. The appearance of the editor at the POW camp in the early morning is too coincidental. Thanks for the input.
Amber Boudreau, Star-Crossed. Amber read from the beginning of Chapter 2 of her new effort, a timey-wimey romance, called Star-Crossed. Several people thought it wasn’t a bad rough draft to the start of a novel. Larry and Kashmira wanted the name of the ex-fiance to be brought up earlier. Judy and a few others got lost in the interiority of the main character. The start leads to some confusion with the main character on the train and then her going through her morning prior to getting on the train. All in all, it was generally well-received but could use some editing.
Amit Trivedi, If Not for the Partition
Here is the feedback for If Not For The Partition.
1. A reminder of what a mangalsutra is will be helpful
2. Show Kedar’s internal thoughts after he writes poetry..
3 Need to describe the age or children in Uma’s classroom.
Presenters for September 19th
Jamie Nelson Noven
Amit Trivedi
Larry Summers
Kashmira Sheth
Mike Austin
FIFTH TUESDAY: The next Fifth Tuesday is October 31. At least two members expressed reservations about gathering on Halloween. We’ll discuss it again on Sept. 19, when more members may chime in.
Also, as a result of the discussion last night, the next time we hold a Fifth Tuesday–whenever that is–we’re going to try a suggestion from Jerry Peterson regarding the writing challenge. Instead of up to 500 words, we’re going to insist on exactly 69 words (not including title)–no more, no less. Prose or poetry, but responsive to the agreed-upon prompt and exactly 69 words. Jerry claims this has been very popular in the Beloit group.
And a final thought, again about caring:
“Find a subject you care about and which you in your heart feel others should care about. It is this genuine caring, not your games with language, which will be the most compelling and seductive element in your style.”
Stephen King