Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story

August 6th, 2024

The first word…

“Work like hell! I had 122 rejection slips before I sold a story.” F. Scott Fitzgerald.

Tuesday’s Meeting

Five writers met on Tuesday to discuss four pieces of writing from four works in progress. Here are their summaries of comments they received:

What Blood Runs Through Me-Wendy B. The rewrite of the baseball game scene was well received-with some reservations! Clarification needs to be made upfront exactly where Michael will be spending his Sunday afternoon (game or Mom’s), and if at Mom’s maybe add a little guilt that he missed Mark game. Some confusion also on time and place when reviewing report on the basement stairs. Adding mention of Poe re fear of bodies buried in basement and several other great thoughts. As always, need to up the tension on Mom’s illness and dying wish to identify the killer. Thank you all!

Continue Reading »

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays With Story

July 16, 2024

First Word…

 

“The only way you can write the truth is to assume that what you set down will never be read. Not by any other person, and not even by yourself at some later date. Otherwise you begin excusing yourself. You must see the writing as emerging like a long scroll of ink from the index finger of your right hand; you must see your left hand erasing it.”

—Margaret Atwood

Tuesday evening…

Six TWS writers attended the meeting via Google Meet, four of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Kashmira S. – Agaria, Ch. 17-18

The feeling is that this is a good coming of age story and shows his struggles well. Still, a doubt was raised about the poetic language from such a young protagonist. One comment was that Chachaji’s reaction to poverty should be shown. More detail about painting etc. is not needed and the story is moving at the right pace. Thank you all for all your comments. 

Wendy B. – What Blood Runs Through Me (Michael), Ch. 26

Two chapters were presented. In an effort to paint a more complete portrait of Michael, I fell into an old bad habit–adding too many little side stories that don’t move the main story ahead. Thankfully, you all made note of this and suggested the baseball chapter either be pared down or deleted. It has, and a revised chapter will be presented in August. Too bad, I really liked it! But as Stephen King once said, “Kill your darlings even when it breaks your egocentric little scribbler’s heart, kill your darlings.” Appreciate your catching all the other snafus, too.  

Jack F. – A Walk Upon the Water, Ch. 1 and 2

Many helpful comments from Larry and Kashmira as I try to get the first four chapters off the ground, or perhaps out of the water.

This novel has been lingering for years and I’d like to get it in publishable form before finishing Jesus.

Larry F. S. – Brother’s Blood, Ch. 12 partial

There was a general feeling that this chapter so far is somewhat sketchy and needs more information filled out, especially on Jag’s and Harold’s reactions on seeing each other after Jag’s long absence; also on physical details such as the recently acquired car, the distance from Henderson Station to Loseyville, etc. Margaret needs to be more present in Jag’s homecoming. Perhaps the chapter could end when Jag and Harold go to sleep after their conversation about Harold’s accident. Thanks, everybody, good comments.

Here’s who’s up on July 16…

Kashmira S.

Wendy B.

Jack F.

Suzanne G.

Larry F. S.

Next Word…

“The first line must convince me that it somehow embodies the entire unwritten text,”

—William Gibson

Announcement…

Larry would appreciate it if members who can do so would each send him a check for $16.87, to defray one month’s Zoom expense. Just this once, hopefully. Earnings from Izzy and the republication of Price of Passage are just around the corner. Thanks for your help.

Our Editor for August…

Mike takes on Writer’s Mail for the next two issues. He is always on the lookout for good things to include, and so if you have something you want her to include, do email it to him.

Anna DeForest on Writing Without Artifice…

To know what you cannot know, you have to see what you cannot see. You are in possession of a brain, a perceptual device which works hard by design to make sure you stay the same person you were yesterday. Most of all, it will show you what you have already seen, and tell you things that you believe already. In the common language you feed to it, your dominant hemisphere chatters endlessly, barely listening to itself. So to learn to see, you learn to see beyond what the mind tries to show you, and to learn to speak, you learn to listen below the common language, to find instead, as Jack Gilbert called it, the fresh particularity of difference.

     The writing I admire and aim to produce works in a language that is entirely without artifice. This means, to be direct, short blunt words without flourish, minimal description, limited internality, and a lot of direct observation of the external world. I prefer to write in the first person, for the same reason, an atheist stance—there is no one outside of the story, there is no place outside from which to tell it. The narrator is only a person desperate for a voice, desperate to name experience, to bring our vast amorphous perceptions under that pretense of control we only get from language. Something clear to anyone with eyes in their head is that the world is at heart unknown and unknowable, mostly unsayable—and still the writer’s task is to try and try to approach this place to which you know you will never arrive. None of this, you might note, is invention. There is nothing to make up.

— excerpted from Literary Hub, July 19, 2024

Last Word…

 “The very reason I write is so that I might not sleepwalk through my entire life.”

— Zadie Smith

Writer’s Mail

July 3, 2024

First Word…

“A word after a word after a word is power.”

— Margaret Atwood

Tuesday evening…

Seven TWS writers attended the meeting via Google Meet, four of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Kashmira S. – Kashmira submitted chapters 15-16 from Agaria. Here were some comments. Great scene setting. Karna has a good heart. His life seems very different than Chitrak’s life. One critical comment was about watercolor painting. It needs more fleshing out. Make the process more challenging for Karna. Need to say who is Ritish Bhai. It needs more work to make it feel magical. Thank you for the comments and suggestions.

Wendy B. –What Blood Runs Through Me/Part 2

The two chapters were well received, and many excellent comments were made. As always, the need to increase the tension (especially in regard to June’s failing health) was voiced. Kashmira suggested Michael’s troubled sleep with an overactive mind trying to figure things out. Made a few notes where he puts pressure on himself. An example or two of Tag being ‘troubled, moody, and secretive” will be added. Will add Michael pondering if they took crime scene photos and fingerprints back in the 30’s. A great way to show how out of his depth he is. Will add Michael going to other precincts to talk to cops about the Others. Many great suggestions that will enrich the story. Thanks!

Jack F. – Received very good reading of Barn Swallows, a minimalist style new poem. Kashmira though she’d read it before, but I think she is recalling Last Hay and Avibus, both of which deal with the same subject, but in different poetic forms.

Suzanne G. – Kaleidoscope, Ch. 27

Mike thinks the story is getting stronger as the characters have grown.  Kashmira thought there were too many extraneous details and that the mention of colors was uneven. Jaime liked that Brandon is learning people’s expressions and not completely relying on his synesthesia to know what people are feeling. Several people mentioned that the scenes concerning Carey giving up his apartment and Lily wanting to move needed to be strengthened. As it’s written it’s confusing. Also confusing was why a businessman like Michael would hire Brandon for consulting work without knowing more about Brandon and the work he does now or why Brandon would consider quitting his job when it’s one small consulting gig. Thanks everyone for the comments. They make my work stronger. 

Here’s who’s up on July 16…

Amit T.

Kashmira S.

Jack F.

Wendy B.

Congratulations Kashmira…

I’m From Here Too (Peachtree) was published on July 2.

“A strong introduction to Sikh culture and faith.”—Booklist

“[A] moving verse novel . . . Sheth evocatively explains Sikhism in this compassionate story in which characters combat hate with reason.”

—Publishers Weekly

“An informative coming-of-age journey.”—Kirkus Reviews

THE 2024 PAGE ONE PRIZE FOR NOVELISTS

Submissions Open June 17 – July 17, 2024

The Gutsy Great Novelist Page One Prize, brought to you by award-winning novelist and writing teacher Joan Dempsey, is open to all writers internationally over 18 who are working on an as-yet-unpublished novel. 

This annual prize aims to find the best first page of a novel-in-progress written in the English language. 

On August 19, 2024, the three prize winners, honorable mentions and finalists will be announced here on the website and via social media, and all entrants will be contacted via email about the results. All winners and honorable mentions will have their Page One Prize-winning entries showcased on this website.

+ CHECK YOUR ELIGIBILITY

+ READ THE SUBMISSION GUIDELINES & SUBMIT NOW

Last Word…

“There is no time for despair, no place for self-pity, no need for silence, no room for fear. We speak, we write, we do language. That is how civilizations heal.” — Toni Morrison

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
June 18, 2024

The first word . . .

The secret of it all is to write…without waiting for a fit time or place. – Walt Whitman

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)

Wendy’s ‘What Blood Runs Through Me’ submission included the opening and closing paragraphs from Part 1 and the transition into Part 2. Suzanne posed the excellent question of why Tommy’s ghost doesn’t appear anywhere except the opening lines of chapter one. She also noticed a disconnect in the time line between parts one and two. Other suggestions included increasing the urgency of Michael’s investigation due to June’s failing health and using the scrapbook throughout the story. Great suggestions! Thank you all.  

Suzanne G. (Kaleidoscope Ch. 26)

Per the group-two of the scenes in the chapter need some clarification. In the first scene, there was a consensus that it’s confusing for there to be no emotions from Michael and Joe, even if Brandon doesn’t see any colors. Wendy and Amit had some problems with Brandon hiring a PI, without asking Carey if it was okay. Kashmira thinks Brandon is preoccupied with his relationship with Carey. Larry had a few minor questions but overall thought the chapter flowed well. Thanks to all for the input. I very much appreciate your comments. 

Amit T. and Kashmira S. INFTP – Chapter 48-end of story

1.  Story ending was well done and satisfying.

2.  The dialogue between Uma and Hari needs to show more emotions from both of them. It is good now but can be improved.

3. Need to show what Kedar and Hari are thinking of each other. Absence of this leaves the reader wondering.

4. Sail boat scene is done very nicely.

Thanks, all.

Bob K. Say What You Want, chapter 6:

Everybody loved this chapter – the dialogue, the character descriptions, etc. Except that the first half did not measure up with the second. Point taken. The second half could benefit from a little more scene painting and a lot more reaction from Lennie and Mead. The other thing was the final sentence. Opinion was split between appreciating that the mention of an umbrella bookended the chapter and suggesting that the sentence be dropped altogether. Thanks all for the thought-provoking comments.

Kashmira S.  Agaria’s Story Ch.13-14

The story seems to be moving along well. There were some questions about the Hamsa and the Karna’s question about him being a pet of Hamsa. The Nala and Damyanti story is working out well. The swing scene needs to be flashed out more. The pace is good. More description about the city through Karna’s eyes is needed. Thank you all!

Who’s up next . . . 

Wendy B.

Suzanne G.

Kashmira S.

We have three more slots open.

The last word . . .

“A writer can do nothing for men more necessary, satisfying, than just simply to reveal to them the infinite possibility of their own souls.” — Walt Whitman.

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
June 4 2024

The first word . . .

Ultimately, literature is nothing but carpentry. With both you are working with reality, a material just as hard as wood.

Gabriel Garcia Marquez

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me June Ch. 23)

What Blood Runs Through Me. Wendy’s chapters received good reviews with many excellent suggestions for strengthening the writing. Just what is the “second chance” Tag refers to when talking to June the night before he leaves for the army? Good question. It needs to be defined more fully. There was a snafu or two on accuracies relating to the era, some word choices that need to be cleaned up, and as always, the tricky little grammatical tenses. The main, and most important suggestion is to withhold information and not rush into revealing too much too early.

Next read will be a like a patchwork quilt: a short revision on the very first page, the ending of Part 1 (June’s story), and the opening of Part 2 (Michael’s story). Curious how y’all think the transition flows. Thank you always!

Larry F. Sommers, Brother’s Blood, Ch. 12:

The lead sentence needs re-wording. Harold’s memory of the fairgrounds airplane incident from childhood occasioned some confusion. There should be more sense of Harold’s feelings about being denied the opportunity to play football, and his family’s view of his plight. Were his parents involved in the decision? There’s discord at the end between the difficulty the cross-country runners experience and Harold’s perception that it’s too easy. Maybe the coach could offer him a job as equipment manager. And what of Margaret? Does she play a part in Harold’s life now that he’s back in school? Good suggestions, all, for a chapter that’s in its early formative stage.

Jaime Nelson Noven NYAA Ch, 13 Rewrite

The group generally liked chapter 13. We discussed making it clearer the orientation in the room and the lighting situation. The question was raised whether Lindyhop would notice Danny opening the door. We also discussed the penlight and whether people would have them in the future, as they are already out of fashion. Readers liked the chemistry between Lindyhop and Danny. Thanks, all!

Kashmira Sheth, Agaria’s Story Ch.11-12

Overall, these two chapters were well-received. Some of the sentences needed to be shorter in order to pack more punch. There were also several suggestions for word choice and grammar. The story seems to be moving at a good pace and magical realism works well. Thank you all for your help!

Who’s up next . . . 

Wendy Bialek

Kashmira Sheth & Amit Trivedi

Suzanne Gillingham

Something to share . . .

Kashmira Sheth’s verse novel I’m from Here too (Peachtree Publishers) was reviewed in PW and Kirkus Reviews. The book will be available on July 2,2024. Thank you for all your feedback on this story.

“[A] moving verse novel . . . Sheth evocatively explains Sikhism in this compassionate story in which characters combat hate with reason.”—Publishers Weekly

“An informative coming-of-age journey.”—Kirkus Reviews

The last word . . .

Life is not what one lived, but rather what one remembers, and how it is remembered to tell the tale.

Gabriel Garcia Marquez

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
May 21, 2024

The first word . . .

“You don’t write about the horrors of war. No. You write about a kid’s burnt socks lying in the road.” Richard Price

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)

The general consensus was chapters 23-24 were solid but several sections needed more details and/or scene setting. Always good recommendations! Specifically: When Tag refers to the prospective ‘shoppers’ at the orphanage, how did they know he was a troublemaker? Jack suggested a black eye or body language hints. The reference to a cut-throat game of baseball should have (and didn’t) prompt a huge reaction from June. The skimpy line on Liz and Mother not responding to June’s wedding invitation cried out for an explanation. Why didn’t they? Hmm. Will have to think about that a bit. And lastly, Claudia’s going around the bend state of mind was way too short and a disservice to June’s mother. Thanks all! Some great suggestions for improving the story. Much appreciated. 

Mike A. (Fishing Camp)

Everyone seemed to like the characters and the scenes.  I got some really great suggestions for paring down and clarifying portions, especially young Bob’s observations and interactions with the new girl. It’s still pretty rough and nebulous, but I see it’s going to need a direction soon, as well as many rewrites. Bob needs more of a personality, for one thing, instead of being an almost passive observer. I’m sticking with the idea of Fishing Camp as being a world apart from the rest of the world for Bob. Thanks! 

Kashmira S. (Agaria’s Story)

Kashmira submitted chapters of her Agaria story. Overall, it was well received. There was some confusion about Karna’s physical presence in relation to the salt pan, their hut, and his mother. It was confusing to use word painting and not sketching or drawing.  Some clarification is needed for how Karna and his family saved Chitrak’s life. Many would like to see the car journey through Karna’s eyes. Thank you all for your comments and suggestions. 

Bob K. (Say What You Want)

Most of the comments centered around page one. There was a question about Phil Duffy’s wake being held at a working-class dive called Moe Greene’s bar and grille. Other comments suggested that I either spent too much time leading up to the wake, or that I spent too few words telling Lennie’s reaction to the circus-like happenings there. Also, the scatter-shot presentation of events was sometimes too much. More generally, there was agreement on how well-observed the descriptions were. Great suggestions, all. Thank you.

Who’s up next . . . 

Bob K.

Kashmira S.

Wendy B.

For the good of the order . . .

Nothing to report.

The last word . . .

“The mind has plenty of ways of preventing you from writing, and paralyzing self-consciousness is a good one. The only thing to do is ignore it, and remember what Vincent Van Gogh said in one of his letters about the painter’s fear of a blank canvas—the canvas, he said, is far more afraid of the painter.” Philip Pullman 

And for the fun of it . . .

Things native English speakers know, but don’t know they know:  Adjectives in English absolutely have be in his order:  opinion-size-age-shape-color-origin-material-purpose-Noun. So, you can have a lovely, little, old, rectangular, green, French, silver, whittling knife. But, if you mess with that word order in the slightest, you will sound like a maniac. It’s an odd thing that every English speaker uses that list. But none of us could write it out. And as size comes before color, green great dragons can’t exist. (from the Language Nerds)

Tuesdays With Story

April 16, 2024

Please see note below from Larry regarding Fifth Tuesday (April 30, 2024)

First Word…

 “The lyf so short, the craft so long to lerne” – Chaucer, Geoffrey

Tuesday evening…

Seven TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, five of which read from their works in progress.  Larry mentioned Jack’s surgery went well and he is recovering.  We had Johanna N. participate from Michigan but will not be joining the group.

Here is a summary of what was said:

Jaime N. – The group took up a couple chapters of New York, After All. It was suggested to describe the setting of the comedy club a little more. Suzanne asked if Lindyhop could have more of a reaction to the surprising joke that was told. Kashmira suggested that not all the planes would be gone if there are private planes, which fits with a theme of the book. Bob pointed out the club chapter is disorienting in a good way but lacks the energy of the previous version. Larry likes Alexei’s character. He suggested re-looking at the past and past perfect tenses. Thanks, all!

Mike A. – “Waiting for Coffee as a Measurement of Time.” This short piece got some great reviews and encouraging comments. Some of you liked the title, others did not. Some liked the thoughts on the eyes being the window to the soul, others did not. Everyone liked the monolog and reading about the subject’s pain, and all of the comments were helpful. Thanks everyone for your comments and encouragement!

Kashmira S. & Amit T. – If Not For the Partition, Chs. 43-45)

—Kedar’s response (after the rewrite) to his situation is now much stronger.

—Descriptive writing about Mumbai is very well done.

—A bit of confusion regarding time of the day was felt. Need to revise that.

Larry F. S. –  Brother’s Blood, Ch.11–In Commander Barr’s geostrategic musing, he should mention Hirohito by name, as he does with Hitler and Mussolini. Why is Jag staying in Washington all summer after the cruise? Is he trying to avoid his family? Does he feel guilty about Harold’s injury? Maybe a letter from home, perhaps from Dorie, would precipitate some good internalities.  Thanks all.

Kashmira S. –  Kashmira submitted three picture books.

The response was positive for all three of the books. There was a question about how some things will be illustrated for Walls. Maybe it was better suited for adult flash fiction. Jungle Meeting was more refined. Imagination has shifts in the text that is jarring. Jaime suggested that maybe it needs some kind of palate cleanser. 🙂

Thank you all. 

Here’s who’s up on May 8…

Mike A.

Amit T. and Kashmira S.

Jaime N. N.

Suzanne G.

Our Editor for May…

Suzanne Gillingham will serve as editor of Writer’s Newsletter. You have her email – use it.

News…

From Larry…

On April 30 at 7:00 pm we will hold OUR TRADITIONAL FIFTH TUESDAY GATHERING at my place. I know that Suzanne, Mike, and I will be here, with good food. We three will enjoy ourselves regardless, but it sure would be nice if we had a bigger turnout, so please come. Send me an email and let me know you are planning to attend. 

For this fifth Tuesday, our first in some time, there is no writing prompt. Just bring yourself, a guest of your choosing, if you choose, and a dish to pass. We here will provide paper plates, cups, napkins, and utensils, plus one or two main dishes. So bring a main dish, a dessert, a salad or appetizer. We’ll have iced tea, raspberry-lemon Crystal Light, some kind of wine and some kind of beer–but if you have exquisite tastes for something exotic like soda pop or Château Lafitte-Rothschild, feel free to bring your own.

Please respond fairly soon, because it’s less than two weeks away, and I relish the pleasure of anticipating your company.

We will not be Zooming this get-together, but you are welcome to attend in person from New York or Virginia if it suits you.

Cheers,

Lar

(Update: Seven total gathered at Larry’s place for a wonderful meal and fellowship.)

Last Word…

“Writing a book is an adventure. To begin with it is a toy and an amusement. Then it becomes a mistress, then it becomes a master, then it becomes a tyrant. The last phase is that just as you are about to be reconciled to your servitude, you kill the monster and fling him to the public.”

-Winston Churchill

Writer’s Mail

April 2, 2024

First Word…

The only end of writing is to enable the readers better to enjoy life or better to endure it.

—B. Johnson, A free enquiry (1857)

Tuesday evening…

Seven TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, five of which read from their works in progress. Mike Austin joined us after undergoing a successful hip surgery. Welcome back Mike!

Here is a summary of what was said:

Bob K. – Say What You Want, Ch. 4.  The good news is that the humor and general sense of paranoia is enough to maintain interest in what is going on. But then, what is going on? Lennie’s reason for writing a column about Phil Duffy is opaque. As is Edgar Paris’s motivation for agreeing to an interview with Lennie. At this point in the revision, only Edgar knows. Thanks for all the excellent suggestions.

Wendy B. – What Blood Runs Through Me: Chapters 17-18,  which focus on June’s summer stay at the Missouri farm, were well received. Some excellent issues were pointed out, including confusion on Tag’s age and the time line. The logistics of the conversation between Aunt Laura and Uncle Frank regarding the telegram, were off kilter, as was the conversation between Aunt Laura and June regarding the contents of the telegram. Equally important, was the misrepresentation of the number of times one could be baptized. An excellent suggestion was made by Bob to show the location of Spake’s Diner in relationship to other Chicago landmarks. All great recommendations that will enhance the chapters. Thanks so much!

Kashmira S. & Amit T. – If Not For the Partition, Chs. 41-42)

—Rewrite the first paragraph. It is confusing.

—Kedar’s is very passive. Need to show him taking charge.

—Kedar thinks he has seen some on akin to the flower women before. Mention if for the readers.

Larry F. S. –  Brother’s Blood Ch. 10:  More of Jag’s personal reaction to events is needed. Some people felt the violence of the hazing was excessive, while others felt it needed to be sharpened. The near-drowning of the pilot while his plane was being recovered was exciting, but not easy to visualize. And the attitude of the captain and others toward the search seemed unprofessional and unrealistic. Thanks all.

Kashmira S. –  Agaria Story. Kashmira submitted chapters from her Agaria story. They were well-received. The magical realism seems to work for most of you. There was a question about what age range this book is for. (It is a middle grade novel for ages 8-12.). Wendy wondered if the writing style is appropriate. Thank you. 

Here’s who’s up on April  18…

Kashmira S.

Mike A.

Amit T. and Kashmira S.

Larry F.S.

Jaime N. N.

Our Editor for April…

Amit Trivedi will serve as editor of Writer’s Newsletter. Email:Runik2@yahoo.com

News…

From Larry…

H, all. I just viewed this half-hour talk by Skip Press at Pepperdine University. He has a lot to say, and I found my thinking stimulated. You might enjoy it: 

Cheers,

Lar

Last Word…

“Poetry turns all things to loveliness.” — Percy Bysshe Shelly, A Defense of Poetry.

Writer’s Mail

March 19, 2024

March is Women’s History Month—a celebration of women’s contributions to history, culture, and society.  There are so many amazing women writers!

First Word: “Writing is a process, a journey into memory and the soul. Write what should not be forgotten.” Isabel Allende

Announcements:  There will be five Tuesdays in April. An in-person gathering in the works?

Manuscript Discussion: Six member writers gathered in person or by Zoom to discuss six submissions.

Kashmira S. submitted chapters 4-5 of the Agaria story.

The group as a whole enjoyed it. There were some questions about logistics. For example, how Chitrak ended up sleeping there and needed clarification. There was also a comment about how mother’s skin may have suffered under the harsh sun and if Karna should mention that. Please remember that Karna is a boy and it is important to the story later on. Thank you for all your feedback. 

Jack F.  submitted chapter 12 of Jesus Walked into the IHOP

I was pleasantly surprised by the positive comments on the Imagine chapter.  I do need a bright chapter on this part of the book because the next set of His adventures is still rather heavy.  Jesus, like Christianity, has his ups and downs.

Taking April off for hip replacement will allow some writing time as well as research time.  Who knows, maybe he goes to India next instead of Africa? Thanks for all the comments.

Amit T. and Kashmira S. INFTP, chapters 39 and 40

  1. Kedar’s reaction is very passive when he sees Uma with Hari.  A more spirited reaction on his part is necessary than to just give in. 

2.  Kedar’s reaction to when Hari mentions Uma’s family is also very mild. 

3.  Should Uma take the lead in finding Kedar?

4. Show more of Kedar’s reflection on immediate past in his current thinking.

Suzanne G. submitted Chapter 21 of Kaleidoscope

Wendy thought the first two paragraphs could be stronger with some rewriting. She didn’t like the reference to the movie. It took her out of the scene. She wanted more detail in the sex scene. Larry thought the scenes were going the way they should and is hoping for a story climax soon. Several people don’t like the character of Emily (she seems unreal) nor Carey and Brandon’s fear of her. Kashmira wants more of a growth arc for Brandon. He’s too unsure of himself and their relationship. Amit thought the descriptions often slowed the story down. As always, thanks to everyone for your comments. They are helpful and much appreciated.

Wendy B. What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 15-16

               Excellent feedback on fine-tuning the chapters. Flush out Clarksville with descriptions other than the church scene. Some solid word choices suggested. Changing whistle pigs to ground hogs—but don’t you just love the word(s) whistle pigs? Good chapter ending.

               The short story, Jingle Bell Ginny, was also well received by the group. Interesting to know that It’s a Wonderful Life, did not become the Christmas classic it is today until almost thirty years after its 1946 release!

Next Up on April 3rd:  Bob K, Suzanne G, Larry S, Wendy B, and Kashmira S and Amit T. One open slot.

Thank you all for forwarding your summaries in a timely fashion. Good luck to Jack on his hip replacement. Happy Easter!

Last Word: “The beginning is always today.” Mary Shelley

Writer’s Mail

March 5, 2024

First Word… “If you don’t have time to read, you don’t have the time (or the tools) to write. Simple as that.” —Stephen King

Which begs the question, what are you reading? I am spellbound with Attica Locke’s novel, Bluebird, Bluebird.

Announcements:  Larry reported recent contacts with currently inactive members Mike A, Judy C, John S, and Paul W. All are doing well and send along their best regards to the group. Look for Mike, Judy, and maybe Paul to return to active participation soon. John is still extremely busy in the cow business.

Manuscript Discussion: Eight member writers and one guest gathered in person or by Zoom to discuss six submissions.

Larry F. S. Brother’s Blood, Ch. 9: Jack suggested the search plane’s recovery by crane ought to be mentioned as well as its launch by catapult and also gave some help on sharpening the tension between ROTC boys and regular Navy crew members. Suzanne pointed out that Peggy could easily be confused with Margaret, since Peggy is a short form or nickname for Margaret. There was general agreement that more conflict is needed. Thanks, everyone.

Jack F. Jesus  Walked Into the IHOP. It is very helpful for me to get Amit and Kashima’s assessment of my work, unclouded by theological presumptions all Christians have. They seem to be enjoying the story as story, which is necessary for anyone to read the eventual full piece. They asked if Jesus visited India, as some Hindu tests make that suggestions.  Very briefly I found the following.

A seminar was also organized under the aegis of Jagannath Gabeshana Parishad where eminent scholars like Dr Harekrushna Satapathy, Dr Siddheswer Mohapatra, Jagabandhu Padhi, Dr Debendra Dash and others deliberated over the Hindu religious texts which mentioned the activities of Jesus. Dr Trebst said 2,000 years ago Puri was a famous seat of learning and history has revealed that over the centuries religious leaders of various sects and cults had visited this holy shrine. It was most likely that Jesus had also visited this holy seat of learning, he said, though adding that it was a very difficult task to trace the history of his visit to Puri.

It appears I must do more research. Wendy and I have exchanged emails regarding her corrections and questions, all very helpful.

Amit T. INFTP

1.  Weave in the theme of abandonment and chaos (British leaving) in Kedar’s chapter. 2.  Tighten-up the paragraph pertaining to Mohan Kaka. 3.  Use holy man instead of Sadhu 4.  Kedar’s poem should also emphasize abandonment and sense of loss.

Thanks all for reading. Amit and Kashmira 

Kashmira S. Kashmira submitted the first three chapters of her MG novel about agarias. Overall, it was well received. The name of the protagonist made people think it was a girl. There was a discussion about what a flock of flamingos are called. Also, many felt that more details about the setting, salt pan etc. would be nice to have. Thank you all for your comments and feedback.

Editor’s Note: According to Wikipedia, Agariya or Agarias translates as Salt Farmers. Kashmira, please correct if not correct.

Jaimie N.  We took up a rewrite of chapter 7 of New York, After All. The group asked for a sense of how Lindyhop feels about her family’s living conditions when she is living in Carnegie Hall. It also needs to be clearer that she had been told by her family that her father died when she was five. The “four men” who are missing from the table should also probably be named. Thanks, all!

Wendy B. What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 13-14. Thoroughly enjoyed the well-deserved evisceration of June’s tracking of her father. Having fun writing something doesn’t count for much! The group is correct; it’s out of character for June, reads rather cutesy and contrived, and totally lacks tension. It’s great to get such invaluable feedback! That’s the big picture, too many smaller suggestions to mention. Thank you all:)

Next Up on March 19:  Bob K, Suzanne G, Kashmira S and Amit T, Wendy B, and Jack F.

Last word… “We write to taste life twice, in the moment and in retrospect.” —Anais Nin