Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
1/7/2025

The first word . . .

Write a landscape in three different moods. Imagine that someone dear to you has died and you are now gazing at the landscape. Describe it without any reference to this event in your life. The second time you write it as if you were experiencing a moment of great joy, and you’re looking at that landscape. The third time, imagine you are in a terrible rage and you are describing this landscape. This allows you to explore how descriptions of the physical world can reflect the various moods of characters.

Abraham Verghese Physician and novelist (The covenant of Water)

Tuesday evening. . .

Seven writers attended the meeting. Three presented.

Suzanne Gillingham (Kaleidoscope, Ch. 29-30 rewrite) – My rewrite was generally well received. It flows well, but does need some clarifications in some areas. More depth needs to be added to the Grandmother; more on why she’s kept her synesthesia from Brandon and how that has affected her. Carey’s story of his past is glossed over too quickly. There needs to be more emotion, more detail on how he’s led a hollowed out life and has used his brother’s passion as his own vocation. Thanks to all for your comments. They are greatly appreciated.

Wendy B. (What Blood Ch. 45) – What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 46-47. Generally speaking, the chapters were well received. An area to address is the need for more internal thought/actions to give Michael more depth. The cemetery scene with the flowers is overexplained and needs to be more subtle to be effective. And food! Is Michael always eating? Guess so. Have to limit his calorie intake. Some other excellent word choices and edits. Thank you!

Continue Reading »

Writer’s Mail

Dec 18, 2024

First Word from Mark Twain:

“When you catch an adjective, kill it. No, I don’t mean utterly but kill most of them–then the rest will be valuable. They weaken when they are close together. They give strength when they are far apart.”

12/3 Manuscript Discussion: Six member writers gathered in person or by Zoom to discuss four submissions.

Kashmira submitted chapters 8-11 of her Valmiki book 2

“Everyone still seems to enjoy Val. The term “jungle brain” could cause a problem. I’ll wait and see if the editor finds it inappropriate. There was a concern about Val speculation about what Anji’s stare meant. Anji must ask permission before taking a video of the robin’s nest. One question raised was, is this too formulaic? Thank you for your thoughts and comments. They are very helpful.”

Happy holidays to you all.”

Wendy submitted What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 44-45

“The chapters were well received with several suggestions for fine-tuning as well as creating a greater sense of urgency for Michael to identify the man who abducted Tommy. The suggestion that the conversation between Michael and the Doc needs to be shorter and more focused is well taken. Thank you for all your feedback!” 

Continue Reading »

Writer’s Mail

Dec 3, 2024

Schedule Change Announcement: Our December 17 meeting has been moved to Wednesday, December 18. 7-9:00 p.m. as usual  

12/3 Manuscript Discussion: Six member writers gathered in person or by Zoom to discuss three submissions.

Kashmira submitted chapters 5-7 of her Valmiki book 2

“Overall, the character seems to entertain everyone. There are some grammatical and spelling mistakes. Some questions about Val’s interaction with Dadaji and Angi and word choices. Other than that, a correction about goose and gander is needed. A few extra words floating around could be cut to tighten the story. Thanks so much for your comments and suggestions.” 

Wendy submitted What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 44-45

“The chapters were well received with suggestions for tightening narrative portions, a few word choices, and typos. Will definitely delete the ‘limp as the green beans we had for dinner’ line. The need for a smoother transition to Michael’s conflicting feelings on setting up Tear Drop was made.   Thank you for all your feedback!” 

Continue Reading »

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays With Story

November 5, 2024

First Word…

A writer is a person who cares what words mean, what they say, how they say it. Writers know words are their way towards truth and freedom, and so they use them with care, with thought, with fear, with delight. By using words well they strengthen their souls. Storytellers and poets spend their lives learning that skill and art of using words well. And their words make the souls of their readers stronger, brighter, deeper.

— Ursula K. Le Guin

Tuesday evening…

Six TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, four of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Kashmira S. – Kashmira submitted the last two chapters of her (chapter book) Valmiki story. All the comments were good and there were no suggestions to change anything. everyone felt that it was ready to be submitted. Thank you all for your input.

Wendy B. – What Blood Runs Through Me, Chs. 38,39. Overall, the chapters were well received. A few excellent suggestions on clarifying the Cubs/Sox reference, cleaning up a few sentences, reorganizing some paragraphs, and a POV issue, as well as adding a stronger reference on the key were made. Thank you all so much!

Mike A. – “Family”received encouraging comments, though it definitely needs some revisions. Ed getting beat up worked well, as well as that incident waking up something dark in John. There needs to be more interactions between Ed and John, and a lot of rearranging of conversations and events, and some hints of John’s darker side below the surface. Thanks

Larry F. S. – Brother’s Blood, Ch. 15 partial–The reason for the journey is not clear. Jag seems unduly harsh and critical, needs humanization. What does Margaret think of all this? It should be possible to show her reactions, even within Jag’s overall POV. The division of the aircraft into 8-passenger compartments is mystifying, and if Jag’s attire is important, then Margaret’s must be, too. Thanks, everybody. Good comments.

Bob K. – Rialto, part 1. There are several problems with part 1 of the story, least of all being the point at which it begins. Kashmira found the opening far too relaxed and wanted more urgency. Others wanted the flashback scene moved up to the start. On a positive note, several comments came in about the genuineness and emotional depth of the dialogue. Thank you.

Suzanne G. – Kaleidoscope Ch, 26 rewrite. Everyone thought the chapter rewrite read well. There was a note to add reader reminders, concerning color, in a few places. More explanation was needed in the first scene regarding Brandon not seeing the emotions of Michael and Joe. Thanks everyone for the comments. They all help to make my work stronger.

Here’s who’s up on November 19…

Kashmira S.

Wendy B.

Suzanne G.

Next Word…

“I love the feeling of being on the hunt – the feeling that the story is refusing to be solved in some lesser way and is insisting that you see it on its highest terms.”

— George Saunders

Allegra Goodman on Writing…

 
“Carpe diem. Know your literary tradition, savor it, steal from it, but when you sit down to write, forget about worshiping greatness and fetishizing masterpieces. If your inner critic continues to plague you with invidious comparisons, scream, ‘Ancestor worship!’ and leave the building.” (Writers on Writing: The New York Times, March 2001)

Last Word…

 “You have to write the book that wants to be written. And if the book will be too difficult for grown-ups, then you write it for children.

— Madeleine L’Engle

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
Oct 15, 2024

The first word . . .

“When writing a novel, a writer should create living people; people, not characters. A character is a caricature.” Ernest Hemmingway

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)

Once again, the Madison group came through with a rich bounty of great suggestions! The Indigo Rose scene is in need of more flavor, more atmosphere. While the scene is rich in detail, it contrasts with other scenes that lack the same richness. I need to go back and flavor them up. Indigo Rose’s recollection of Tommy’s abduction could be tightened up. The proximity of the alley to the Sommer family apartment calls for clarification. And Michael’s voice needs fine tuning to reflect his inner conflicts-a teacher or a cop? Thank you all for your suggestions. Mucho appreciated!

Suzanne G. (You Can’t Go Home Again)

There were three take-aways. The second paragraph works better as the beginning of the story. It gives it more punch. The story of the transgender woman, through interesting, should be dropped since it has little to nothing to do with my family. There needs to be more on my mom and dad. Oh, yeah. The title sucks! Thanks to all for your suggestions!

Glen M (The Disappointment of Mothers Chapter 1)

He really overused the word ‘really,’ and needs to fix his use of
commas, and maybe keep the interpersonal conflict going a bit stronger
in the middle of chapter one. 

Larry S (Brother’s Blood Chap 14 Revised)

Several people agreed there was too much info about chemistry. Mike felt Harold lacks an emotional spark or core that would allow him to respond to other people in a realistic way; Wendy thought he often seems slow or obtuse. The writing was a bit too cute in a couple of places, such as application of the “code id da doze” gag to Europe’s prolonged political/military crisis.–Thanks for all the good insights, everybody!

Who’s up next . . . 

Wendy B.

Larry S.

Suzanne G.

Bob K.

Mike A.

For the good of the order . . .

There will be no fifth Tuesday get-together.

The last word . . .

“You always need that spark of imagination. Sometimes I’m midway through a book before it happens. However, I don’t wait for the muse to descend, I sit down every day and I work when I’m not delivering lambs on the farm.” Barbara Kingsolver

And for the fun of it . . .

Ubuntu, a Zulu word, is the concept that emphasizes the universal interconnectedness between people and can be translated as “I am because we are”.

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
Oct 1, 2024

The first word . . .

“Be a sadist. No matter how sweet and innocent your leading characters, make awful things happen to them—in order that the reader may see what they are made of.” Kurt Vonnegut

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)

Despite a few clunky sentences, a couple of missed opportunities, and the need to rework Boyle’s memo, the chapters were well received. We are about halfway through the story. Thank you all for your amazing suggestions!

Suzanne G. (Kaleidoscope Chap 33 and Epilogue)

The last chapter and the epilogue were thought by all to be a satisfying ending. Carey and Brandon seemed more confident which is a good progression. Adding Lizzie in at the end was an important element. It brings Brandon’s and Grandmother’s synesthesia out in the open. Hopefully this is a sign that they can see their synesthesia as a gift and not a curse. Thanks all for the wonderful suggestions and all of your help with this project! Who knows where I’ll go from here.

Kashmira S. (Valmik Chapters 10-14)

Jack F (3 Poems)

Three poems of various styles were emailed and I read only the most recent, a sparsely worded semi-minimalist on Wind.  These are part of a last chapter of a book of poetry dealing with being older.  I have noted increased comments over the last two years, possibly because a few members no longer find evaluating poetry to be a foreign language.  That is very helpful as most people who purchase poetry are not poets.

Larry did not like Threnody, a lovely Greek word meaning a song or wailing lament, which I used to describe the bare branches.  In defense I say “Emerson used it!” Yes, he and I studied Greek in college and add Dryden as well.  Then there is Countee Cullen with Threnody for a Brown Girl and the music of Penderecki Threnody for the Victims of Hiroshima.

But I’ll search the synonymic dictionary:  coronach, dirge, lament, elegy, keening, gol.  Gol looks too much like a typo and coronach….well, I’ll keep looking.

Amit and Kashmira (Untitiled Chap 1-3)

1.  Group felt the first four chapters were much improved after the rewrite.

2.  There is still a bit of confusion about the characters and their names and relationships.

3.  A suggestion was made to develop the story first with the two brothers and then introduce other characters.

Thanks all!

Bob K. (2 Poems: Sightings and See Here)

The poems submitted were well received, both for their imagery and the memorable characters presented in them. Several comments came in regarding the use of the word ‘grimy’ in “Sightings”- that it stands out as harsh in relation to the rest of the poem. Jack made several helpful suggestions regarding the commas in “See Here”. Thanks all.

Mike A. (Red Corolla Convertible, Invisible)

Readers enjoyed “Corolla.” One of the bigger problems was that the woman would have to really be trying to drink that much beer in such a short time. There should also be a little more time in there for her to open up as much as she does. And when was the pizza put into her car? It would be good to mention what Doug is driving, something that looks ratty and rough compared to her car, which could maybe be a more expensive car than a Corolla. And nobody puts grey highlights in their hair. I should pay more attention to things like that. “Invisible” was well received, but could use a different title. Thanks everyone!

Who’s up next . . . 

Wendy B.

Larry S.

Suzanne G.

For the good of the order . . .

Nothing to report.

The last word . . .

“Find out what you’re interested in and pursue passionately. That means not caring what anyone else thinks about it, or what anyone else is writing or reading. All that matters is what you’re interested in, what you think is cool or funny or sexy or profound. The moment you start wondering other people will think of it, you’re lost. It’s hard, I know, since you’re one day going to share this work with other people who will absolutely tell you what they think about it, and on some days, it can seem like your entire career hinges on whether someone likes it or not—but it doesn’t matter. You can’t change what you’re curious about. All you can do is pursue it.” William Kenower  

And for the fun of it . . .

Rastrophiliopustrocity: a spontaneous combustion of creative spark that is followed by action in order to manifest and bring into existence.

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
Sep 17, 2024

The first word . . .

“Write to please just one person. If you open a window and make love to the world, so to speak, your story will get pneumonia.” Kurt Vonnegut

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)

Some excellent suggestions were made for building up the tension in the bank robbery scene. By defining Michael’s character even more deeply, the reader will connect with Michael and the decisions he makes. The need to concretely connect the robbery to Michael’s investigation on Tommy’s murder was a noteworthy comment. Thank you all very much!

Larry S. (Brother’s Blood Chap 14)

There is a choppy, disordered chronology. Things need to be told in a somewhat different order. Allie seems like a really wonderful character but is seriously slighted in Harold’s estimation. Also–what attracts her to Harold?  Grady is interesting but needs his background developed more. There are places where the characters don’t talk like teenagers from a small, semi-rural community. Good points, all. Thanks very much for searching input.

Kashmira S. (Valmik Chapters 6-9)

Everyone liked various characters. There was a confusion about laundry chute and a suggestion that it might be best to call it a hatch. Also, there was a question if the baby oil was easily available. There was a suggestion that a scene from when Vik goes upstairs again (after going down the laundry hatch) would be good. Thank you!

Amit and Kashmira (Untitiled Chap 3-4)

The narrative language was good but the tension was lacking and felt ponderous. More dramatic dialogues and action needed. The end of chapter 4 with the conflict was done well. It was not easy to understand where the two brothers live. The dates on the top of the chapters were confusing. The claustrophobia that Himanshu felt was evident. Thank you all for your input. 

Who’s up next . . . 

Jack F

Kashmira S.

Wendy B.

Mike A.

Larry S.

Suzanne G.

For the good of the order . . .

Nothing to report.

The last word . . .

“There was a moment when I changed from an amateur to a professional. I assumed the burden of a profession, which is to write even when you don’t want to, don’t much like what you’re writing, and aren’t writing particularly well.” Agatha Christie 

“There are a lot of opinions about what makes you a real writer, so let me tell you the truth: You become a real writer when you notice a typo and it’s too late to do anything about it.” John Wiswell             

And for the fun of it . . .

Lethologica: a term used to describe the phenomenon of experiencing the temporary inability to recall a specific word or phrase from your memory, even though you know the word and can describe its meaning.

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
Sep 17, 2024

The first word . . .

“Write to please just one person. If you open a window and make love to the world, so to speak, your story will get pneumonia.” Kurt Vonnegut

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)

Some excellent suggestions were made for building up the tension in the bank robbery scene. By defining Michael’s character even more deeply, the reader will connect with Michael and the decisions he makes. The need to concretely connect the robbery to Michael’s investigation on Tommy’s murder was a noteworthy comment. Thank you all very much!

Larry S. (Brother’s Blood Chap 14)

There is a choppy, disordered chronology. Things need to be told in a somewhat different order. Allie seems like a really wonderful character but is seriously slighted in Harold’s estimation. Also–what attracts her to Harold?  Grady is interesting but needs his background developed more. There are places where the characters don’t talk like teenagers from a small, semi-rural community. Good points, all. Thanks very much for searching input.

Kashmira S. (Valmik Chapters 6-9)

Everyone liked various characters. There was a confusion about laundry chute and a suggestion that it might be best to call it a hatch. Also, there was a question if the baby oil was easily available. There was a suggestion that a scene from when Vik goes upstairs again (after going down the laundry hatch) would be good. Thank you!

Amit and Kashmira (Untitiled Chap 3-4)

The narrative language was good but the tension was lacking and felt ponderous. More dramatic dialogues and action needed. The end of chapter 4 with the conflict was done well. It was not easy to understand where the two brothers live. The dates on the top of the chapters were confusing. The claustrophobia that Himanshu felt was evident. Thank you all for your input. 

Who’s up next . . . 

Jack F

Kashmira S.

Wendy B.

Mike A.

Larry S.

Suzanne G.

For the good of the order . . .

Nothing to report.

The last word . . .

“There was a moment when I changed from an amateur to a professional. I assumed the burden of a profession, which is to write even when you don’t want to, don’t much like what you’re writing, and aren’t writing particularly well.” Agatha Christie 

“There are a lot of opinions about what makes you a real writer, so let me tell you the truth: You become a real writer when you notice a typo and it’s too late to do anything about it.” John Wiswell             

And for the fun of it . . .

Lethologica: a term used to describe the phenomenon of experiencing the temporary inability to recall a specific word or phrase from your memory, even though you know the word and can describe its meaning.

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story

September 2, 2024

The first word…

From “How to Write Good,” by Michael O’Donoghue: “My advice to the would-be-writer is that he start slowly, writing short undemanding things, things such as telegrams, flip-books, crank letters, signature scarves, spot quizzes, capsule summaries, fortune cookies and errata. Then, when he feels he’s ready, move up to the more challenging items such as mandates, objective correlatives, passion plays, pointless diatribes, minor classics, manifestos, mezzotints, oxymora, exposes, broadsides, and papal bulls.”

Meeting on Tuesday evening, five writers presented their work for discussion.

Kashmira and Amit,  untitled story.

Relationship between Sanjay and Himanshu is not clear…

The opening line is a bit confusing – need to be be reworked

Overall the chapters are interesting and the story has a lot of potential.

Kashmira’s story – Valmiki

Group liked the story and Valmiki’s character

The scene between the parents in the car can be toned down a bit.

The humor is well done throughout.

 .

Thanks!

Larrry S., Brother’s Blood, Ch12-13: Need to spell out more details on timing of Jag’s flight home, how Pop found out about the damage to the car, etc. Pop’s response to the damage seems strangely subdued; use Harold’s internal reaction to put that in context.  Thanks, all. Very helpful.

Suzanne Kaleidoscope (Chapters 31 and 32)

There were a couple of thoughts that I should use Grandmother’s mansion as a metaphor for her personality. More detail should be added, including more descriptions of the paintings. There should be more buildup over Rattlesnake Man–escaping before Carey and Brandon leave for San Francisco, and adding in more throughout the book of Carey’s worry over Rattlesnake Man. There should be more tears, either from Brandon or his grandmother over the revelation they both have synesthesia. Kashmira wants to see more about Carey and Brandon’s time in Puerto Rico which could be a way to add more depth to their relationship.

As always, thanks for the feedback! My book is stronger because of it.

What Blood Runs Through Me by Wendy B. Chapters were well received. Suggestions mostly focused on the small details that can make or break a story. Deleting a few unnecessary adjectives, shifting sentences to different location, checking the time frame on slang. Officer Montgomery as a new character was liked. And yes, Larry, only a slight exaggeration that Chicago streets can have more potholes than pavement. Thank you all for your feedback.

Our next meeting will be September 17. Writers volunteering to present their work are:

         Paul W

         Kashmira S

         Amit T

         Larry S.

         Wendy B.

Your editor for this issue is Mike Austin. Blame him. Suzanne Gillingham is editor for September 17th. If you have any news of writing events or information, send them to Suzanne.

The final word…

         “If you write one story, it may be bad; if you write a hundred, you have the odds in your favor.” Edgar Rice Burroughs

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story

August 20, 2024

The first word…

From a 2010 interview with Ray Bradbury in The Paris Review: “You can’t learn to write in college. It’s a very bad place for writers because the teachers always think they know more than you do—and they don’t. They have prejudices. They may like Henry James, but what if you don’t want to write like Henry James? They may like John Irving, for instance, who’s the bore of all time. A lot of the people whose work they’ve taught in the schools for the last thirty years, I can’t understand why people read them and why they are taught. The library, on the other hand, has no biases. The information is all there for you to interpret. You don’t have someone telling you what to think. You discover it for yourself.”

          Mike sez: This makes me feel good. I’ve read some John Irving and really wish I could write like him. But Bradbury is saying that we don’t have to in order to be a good writer. All we need is our own voice. It’s hard to remember that sometimes.

Continue Reading »