Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘Book Review’

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
Feb 3, 2026

The first word . . .

“I write entirely to find out what I’m looking at, what I see and what it means. What I want and what I fear.” Joan Didion

“Writing is a job, a talent, but it’s also a place to go in your head.” Ann Patchett

Seven writers met, in person and via Zoom. The following six presented work. 

Tuesday Evening . . .

Susan S (Bienvenue a Nice)

Positive feedback with only a couple of minor edit suggestions.

Bob K (Call Me)

Call Me works as a slice-of-life piece, but less so as an actual story. Mainly because there is no real conflict or growth. Nothing at stake. Larry pointed out that the introduction of the arguing couple and the woman at the jewelry counter raises the tension which gives the situation greater depth. A small improvement. Another small improvement is that the relationship between the central characters is better defined than before. Thanks to all for the excellent comments.

Jack F (A Walk Upon the Water Chaps 54-55)

We got Lester into a suit and Skip into a handpainted tie.  Readers seemed to appreciate the change in Lester and found it believable. These were slight chapters, move the story ahead chapters, and I received multiple typo corrections.

Larry S (Brother’s Blood Chap 22-23)

No detailed report. All comments were considered and the necessary changes to the manuscript were made accordingly,

Sue G (A Sparkle in the Swamp 2nd half)

Overall, the critiques were positive. There were some rephrasing suggestions to tighten up the dialogue. Also, several people thought it would be good to show Marcus smiling, winking, etc at Emily, causing her to misinterpret these behaviors.

Kashmira S (Veena’s Story Chaps 34-37)

Kashmira submitted chapter 34-37 of Veena’s story. The historical part of the story comes out well. Sardar being arrested and jailed and how it encourages people needs to be reworked to make it clear. Dadima’s character is well developed throughout the story and her death scene was moving. Veena’s concerns and participation in the freedom fight is believable. Overall, good chapters.

Who’s up next . . .  

Susan S.

Larry S.

Sue G.

Kashmira S.

Jack F.

Mike A.

For the good of the order . . . 

If you’re looking for a small, but excellent writer’s conference try The Lakefly Writer’s Conference. It will be held in Oshkosh on May 1-2, 2026

The last word . . .

“When a reader puts a story aside because it ‘got boring,’ the boredom arose because the writer grew enchanted with his powers of description and lost sight of his priority, which is to keep the ball rolling.” Stephen King

And for the fun of it . . .

“Many people hear voices when there is no one there. Some of them are called ‘mad” and are shut up in rooms where they stare at the walls all day. Others are called ‘writers’ and do pretty much the same thing.” Ray Bradbury

Read Full Post »

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
1/20/2026

The first word . . .

“I love deadlines. I love the whooshing noise they make as they go by.”

-Douglas Adams

Tuesday evening. . .

8 writers attended the meeting. 3 presented. 


Larry S, Brother’s Blood, 7-9: The reader needs more clarity on how single-wing football differs from the modern game. It would be good to work in some earlier references to the rise of Hitler and other totalitarian rulers. Harold’s voice is not quite immature enough in viewpoint narrative sections. How sympathetic a character is Taylor meant to be? And what the heck is Harold doing working with Jag at the mine? Good points all. Thanks.

Susan G: A Sparkle in the Swamp: The critiques were overall positive. One suggestion was to delete how long the trip was from the airstrip to Swamp Rat Bayou Tours and to describe the scenery as they drive there. Another person questioned why Emily and Becky left their luggage unsupervised next to Sparkle as she repacked her luggage. 

Jack F. A Tested Mooring: The two chapters were generally well received but exactly how the rope and mooring worked to injure Sean was unclear.  I’d reread it myself before sending it off, but if the reader can’t easily get it, I need to rewrite. 

Susan had concerns about the lack of Muriel  calling Sean’s parents to tell then he nearly killed himself, but that was the way it was.  Our super-protectiveness of children is not something I grew up with. I recall my friend Joel Garreau scuba diving, no training, no certification, no tank testing, so he could steal lobsters from pots in high school.  It was a different world for us as kids and we were lucky to survive!

You might enjoy his books, especially The Nine Nations of North America and Edge City.  Believe he now has seven out.

J

Presenters for our next meeting on February 3th

Larry S.

Susan S.

Jack F.

Sue G.

Bob K.

Kashmira S.

Writing Tips:

I found a great article dated 1/2/2026 posted on the Hidden Gems Website by Roland Hulme, aka Ginger, called How and When to Use Humor in Your Writing (https://www.hiddengemsbooks.com/how-and-when-to-use-humor-in-your-writing/).

The article description states:  In today’s article, Ginger goes into detail as to why humor works in the first place, where it belongs in your writing, and how any author can learn to use it effectively without turning their novel into a comedy. From subtle character quirks to well-timed irony and exaggeration, humor can strengthen a story rather than undermine it. Regardless of genre, a few well-placed laughs may be the missing ingredient that makes readers remember your book and come back for more.

The Last word:

“The road to hell is paved with adverbs.”

—Stephen King

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays with Story
April 1, 2025                                                              Editor: Wendy B.

The first, first word…

Wishing Kashmira safe travels and an amazing book signing event on April 8 at Mystery to Me Bookstore in Madison!

The first word . . .

“One must not put a loaded rifle on the stage if no one is thinking of firing it.”

Anton Chekhov, 1889

It never hurts to be reminded of a basic narrative principle—every element in a story should have relevance and contribute to the plot.

Tuesday Evening Summaries . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 59-60)

‘Social-path’ instead of sociopath? Uh-oh. It only goes to show you that ‘disturbing’ is in the eyes of the reader! Looks like I need to ramp up the tension and authenticity of the journal entries, big time. A critical juncture in the story, so thank you all for your suggestions.

Jack F. (Chapters 12-14)

The chapters that I feared were rather flat, were accepted as readable. These are actually important chapters as they are like page 2 of Sean’s biography and set the reader up for the next long disastrous chapter.  I’m writing in rhythm, or trying to, with ups and downs in information and intensity. That seems to be like life.

I’ve noted that there is a questing theme in the novel, Jason and the Argonauts with Lester as Chrion, but the majority of the mythic structure under the novel, which most readers will never observe, is Celtic or Brittonic. The next chapter is Welsh folklore, The Mabinogion in particular, with a trip into the underworld where the quester has to climb a revolving mountain of glass or ice, where almost all visitors are killed. There is a magic cauldron inside the mountain. 

The Welsh underworld is Annwn and is guarded by dogs (Cwn Annwn)  reached through a multi-door gate, the Hayton bridge in the next chapter.  Annwn  is home to the souls of the dead (Sean’s ancestors) and is a world “between worlds” where reality is often deeper and has lessons to teach. Not much of this is important for the reader, but as a writer I am looking back at ancient and perhaps universal themes.  Some author once said that Celtic myth underlies much of our literature “like Merlin complaining under his rock”. It is an ancient voice, not audible, but still there as an echo of earlier writers, prophets and priests. Thank you all for your comments.

Suzanne G.  (Kaleidoscope, Chapter 14 rewrite)

The main takeaway from the group was that Carey’s anger and fear over Brandon’s revelation of having synesthesia needed more buildup. Other notes: Brandon needed to remember what happened to Carey on his birthday; and Brandon should make more of an effort to care for Carey when he’s hurting over memories of his family. Thanks everyone for the always helpful comments. 

(more…)

Read Full Post »

March 4, 2025

The first word . . .

“Exercise the writing muscle every day, even if it is only a letter, notes, a title list, a character sketch, a journal entry. Writers are like dancers, like athletes. Without that exercise, the muscles seize up.” Jane Yolen

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B (What Blood Runs Through Me)

The chapters were well received, but as always, some excellent comments to enrich the piece. Word choices, a few typos to keep readers on their toes, needless repetition, And, of course, an old Derringer wouldn’t have a safety.  Roughly just 40 more pages to go. Thank you all!

Suzanne G (Kaleidoscope rewrite of Chaps 10 & 11)

Most of the suggestions were for Chapter 10: the racist man seemed to be a bit of a caricature and should be reworked; the kiss at the end should evolve more and not have them slamming together; a scene with the coffee cake could be added; and last but not least—they need to lock up their bikes. In Chapter 11 the main comment was that Brandon should focus more on Carey’s needs and not his own. It would make Brandon a stronger character and emphasis his own growth. Thanks for all the comments. As always, they strengthen my work.

(more…)

Read Full Post »

Writer’s Mail

February 4th, 2024

The First Word…

“The easy, conversational tone of good writing comes only on the eighth rewrite.”

            Paul Graham

Seven of us attended Tuesday’s meeting. Five people presented work. They were:

Amit T., “Anna.”

Wendy B., “What Blood Runs Through Me.” Chapters 49-51

Kashmira S., “The Saltmaker’s Son.” Chapters 6-9

Suzanne G., “Kaleidoscope.” Chapters 32-33 and Epilogue

Jack F., “A Walk Upon the Water.” Chapters 3-5

Here are some of the comments about their work.

Suzanne G.

Kaleidoscope: Rewrite of Chapters 32, 33 and Epilogue

Everyone liked the last chapters though there were some things that needed clarification or added detail: Rattlesnake Man, his escape and capture were both skated over too quickly; the reader would want more on how Carey felt about this and how it affects his life beyond Rattlesnake Man’s death. The addition of Brandon’s family and the wedding was good, but there were too many people added at one time. More was needed about the family to give them all distinctive personalities. The conversation with Brandon’s dad and Carey worked well. As usual there were a few POV confusions and more than a few grammatical errors. The Oxford comma is not my friend!  Thanks to all for your help and encouragement.

Kashmira S.

Kashmira submitted chapter 6-9 of The Saltmaker’s Son. There were spelling and grammar mistakes as well as too many “I” usage. There was also concerns about using poetic language and if it is right for this age group.  Overall, the chapters were well-received. Karna is twelve and that age seems perfect for this coming of story.  Thank you all for your comments.

Wendy B.

What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 49-51.  Wendy Bialek. As the group was quick to point out, the primary issue with the chapters evolved around Darla’s intent in getting inside the cabin, and why Michael was so reluctant to go inside with her. It wasn’t his foreboding, or fear that unauthorized police records would be inside. No, he was afraid Darla had misplaced expectations of a rendezvous. Something needs to happen. Problem solved! Thanks, everyone:) 

Presenting for our February 18 meeting:

Jack F.

Wendy B.

Kashmira S.

Larry F. S.

Amit T.

Kashmira’s Book Signing!

Here is the info about my April signing at the Mystery to Me bookstore. It is on Tuesday night and we don’t have a meeting so I’d love to see some friends there!

Livestream: https://www.crowdcast.io/c/im-from-here-too
https://www.eventbrite.com/e/livemtm-kashmira-sheth-tickets-1235104162799?aff=oddtdtcreator
Website: https://www.mysterytomebooks.com/kashmira-sheth
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/events/1669727313927906/

Some last words…

“I have never started a poem yet whose end I knew. Writing a poem is discovering.”

            Robert Frost

            This surprised me. Robert Frost’s poems always seem so perfectly planned and crafted, as if he knew all along where he was going, when in fact he didn’t really know. But it worked for him. John Updike, on the other hand, said that he can’t start writing a story unless he knows where it’s going to end. And that works for him. He also said that it took him three novels before he realized that it was the method he would always write with, and there was nothing wrong with it. So it seems that there is no right or wrong method to writing, so long as it gets done. Yes, I’m lecturing myself.

Book recommendation…

“Writing Fiction. A Guide to Narrative Craft,” by Janet Burroway.

            This is, for me, the best book on writing I’ve seen. Burroway discusses the basics of writing, creative methods, styles, rewrites, and accepting criticism. The book is filled with short stories of various styles, and makes for good reading if you’re bored with instruction. I’ve had my copy, the third edition, for years and years, and still open it when I need some inspiration or instruction. I see that now it’s in the tenth edition.

Read Full Post »

July 3, 2024

First Word…

“A word after a word after a word is power.”

— Margaret Atwood

Tuesday evening…

Seven TWS writers attended the meeting via Google Meet, four of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Kashmira S. – Kashmira submitted chapters 15-16 from Agaria. Here were some comments. Great scene setting. Karna has a good heart. His life seems very different than Chitrak’s life. One critical comment was about watercolor painting. It needs more fleshing out. Make the process more challenging for Karna. Need to say who is Ritish Bhai. It needs more work to make it feel magical. Thank you for the comments and suggestions.

Wendy B. –What Blood Runs Through Me/Part 2

The two chapters were well received, and many excellent comments were made. As always, the need to increase the tension (especially in regard to June’s failing health) was voiced. Kashmira suggested Michael’s troubled sleep with an overactive mind trying to figure things out. Made a few notes where he puts pressure on himself. An example or two of Tag being ‘troubled, moody, and secretive” will be added. Will add Michael pondering if they took crime scene photos and fingerprints back in the 30’s. A great way to show how out of his depth he is. Will add Michael going to other precincts to talk to cops about the Others. Many great suggestions that will enrich the story. Thanks!

Jack F. – Received very good reading of Barn Swallows, a minimalist style new poem. Kashmira though she’d read it before, but I think she is recalling Last Hay and Avibus, both of which deal with the same subject, but in different poetic forms.

Suzanne G. – Kaleidoscope, Ch. 27

Mike thinks the story is getting stronger as the characters have grown.  Kashmira thought there were too many extraneous details and that the mention of colors was uneven. Jaime liked that Brandon is learning people’s expressions and not completely relying on his synesthesia to know what people are feeling. Several people mentioned that the scenes concerning Carey giving up his apartment and Lily wanting to move needed to be strengthened. As it’s written it’s confusing. Also confusing was why a businessman like Michael would hire Brandon for consulting work without knowing more about Brandon and the work he does now or why Brandon would consider quitting his job when it’s one small consulting gig. Thanks everyone for the comments. They make my work stronger. 

Here’s who’s up on July 16…

Amit T.

Kashmira S.

Jack F.

Wendy B.

Congratulations Kashmira…

I’m From Here Too (Peachtree) was published on July 2.

“A strong introduction to Sikh culture and faith.”—Booklist

“[A] moving verse novel . . . Sheth evocatively explains Sikhism in this compassionate story in which characters combat hate with reason.”

—Publishers Weekly

“An informative coming-of-age journey.”—Kirkus Reviews

THE 2024 PAGE ONE PRIZE FOR NOVELISTS

Submissions Open June 17 – July 17, 2024

The Gutsy Great Novelist Page One Prize, brought to you by award-winning novelist and writing teacher Joan Dempsey, is open to all writers internationally over 18 who are working on an as-yet-unpublished novel. 

This annual prize aims to find the best first page of a novel-in-progress written in the English language. 

On August 19, 2024, the three prize winners, honorable mentions and finalists will be announced here on the website and via social media, and all entrants will be contacted via email about the results. All winners and honorable mentions will have their Page One Prize-winning entries showcased on this website.

+ CHECK YOUR ELIGIBILITY

+ READ THE SUBMISSION GUIDELINES & SUBMIT NOW

Last Word…

“There is no time for despair, no place for self-pity, no need for silence, no room for fear. We speak, we write, we do language. That is how civilizations heal.” — Toni Morrison

Read Full Post »

Tuesdays with Story
June 18, 2024

The first word . . .

The secret of it all is to write…without waiting for a fit time or place. – Walt Whitman

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)

Wendy’s ‘What Blood Runs Through Me’ submission included the opening and closing paragraphs from Part 1 and the transition into Part 2. Suzanne posed the excellent question of why Tommy’s ghost doesn’t appear anywhere except the opening lines of chapter one. She also noticed a disconnect in the time line between parts one and two. Other suggestions included increasing the urgency of Michael’s investigation due to June’s failing health and using the scrapbook throughout the story. Great suggestions! Thank you all.  

Suzanne G. (Kaleidoscope Ch. 26)

Per the group-two of the scenes in the chapter need some clarification. In the first scene, there was a consensus that it’s confusing for there to be no emotions from Michael and Joe, even if Brandon doesn’t see any colors. Wendy and Amit had some problems with Brandon hiring a PI, without asking Carey if it was okay. Kashmira thinks Brandon is preoccupied with his relationship with Carey. Larry had a few minor questions but overall thought the chapter flowed well. Thanks to all for the input. I very much appreciate your comments. 

Amit T. and Kashmira S. INFTP – Chapter 48-end of story

1.  Story ending was well done and satisfying.

2.  The dialogue between Uma and Hari needs to show more emotions from both of them. It is good now but can be improved.

3. Need to show what Kedar and Hari are thinking of each other. Absence of this leaves the reader wondering.

4. Sail boat scene is done very nicely.

Thanks, all.

Bob K. Say What You Want, chapter 6:

Everybody loved this chapter – the dialogue, the character descriptions, etc. Except that the first half did not measure up with the second. Point taken. The second half could benefit from a little more scene painting and a lot more reaction from Lennie and Mead. The other thing was the final sentence. Opinion was split between appreciating that the mention of an umbrella bookended the chapter and suggesting that the sentence be dropped altogether. Thanks all for the thought-provoking comments.

Kashmira S.  Agaria’s Story Ch.13-14

The story seems to be moving along well. There were some questions about the Hamsa and the Karna’s question about him being a pet of Hamsa. The Nala and Damyanti story is working out well. The swing scene needs to be flashed out more. The pace is good. More description about the city through Karna’s eyes is needed. Thank you all!

Who’s up next . . . 

Wendy B.

Suzanne G.

Kashmira S.

We have three more slots open.

The last word . . .

“A writer can do nothing for men more necessary, satisfying, than just simply to reveal to them the infinite possibility of their own souls.” — Walt Whitman.

Read Full Post »