Tuesdays with Story
1/7/2025
The first word . . .
Write a landscape in three different moods. Imagine that someone dear to you has died and you are now gazing at the landscape. Describe it without any reference to this event in your life. The second time you write it as if you were experiencing a moment of great joy, and you’re looking at that landscape. The third time, imagine you are in a terrible rage and you are describing this landscape. This allows you to explore how descriptions of the physical world can reflect the various moods of characters.
Abraham Verghese Physician and novelist (The covenant of Water)
Tuesday evening. . .
Seven writers attended the meeting. Three presented.
Suzanne Gillingham (Kaleidoscope, Ch. 29-30 rewrite) – My rewrite was generally well received. It flows well, but does need some clarifications in some areas. More depth needs to be added to the Grandmother; more on why she’s kept her synesthesia from Brandon and how that has affected her. Carey’s story of his past is glossed over too quickly. There needs to be more emotion, more detail on how he’s led a hollowed out life and has used his brother’s passion as his own vocation. Thanks to all for your comments. They are greatly appreciated.
Wendy B. (What Blood Ch. 45) – What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 46-47. Generally speaking, the chapters were well received. An area to address is the need for more internal thought/actions to give Michael more depth. The cemetery scene with the flowers is overexplained and needs to be more subtle to be effective. And food! Is Michael always eating? Guess so. Have to limit his calorie intake. Some other excellent word choices and edits. Thank you!
Kashmira S. (Valmiki 2 Ch. 12 + Series pitch) Most of the comments for chapter 12 were positive. A few words, contractions etc. were suggested. There was a concern about the spelling in the apology letter that Val writes to his mom. The series pitch had some duplication. The last paragraph needed to be tweaked so as to wrap up the series in a cohesive manner. Thank you!
Presenter for our next meeting on January 21
Larry S.
Suzanne G.
Wendy B.
Bob K
Jack F.
Kashmira S.
The Last word:
Thank you for sharing this Larry!
The Authors Guild’s “Writing Profession General” discussion board currently features a useful conversation on point of view.
Patrick Andersen kicked it off with the following question:
What is the current trend on Point of View in writing fiction? I received criticism from some writers for using Limited Ominscient, saying I should stick to one lead character’s POV. But I am seeing many successful novelists jump from one character’s mind to another even within the same chapter. Is there a trend current in literary circles that I should be aware of?
There have been several early responses to his inquiry, but I found these two especially cogent:
First, from Lenore Hart,
Patrick, First Person POV has been very popular over the last 20 years or so, especially in YA novels and the retelling/re-envisioning of singular historical characters. But Third Person Limited, the use of one third person point-of-view character/protagonist as narrator, also gives the writer the added ability (which is not available in First Person POV) to look at the Third Limited protagonist from the outside, if needed. Third person singular is almost as close and intimate as First Person, but the added distance of Third Limited can also make it seem more credible than a First Person narrative voice, which lends itself well to narrative irony, also.
Third Person Omniscient is still around and not outdated. Its still being used successfully, even brilliantly, in many novels, including bestsellers and major prizewinners. I’m reading Mega-bestselling (and excellent fiction craftsperson) Lee Bardugo’s THE FAMILIAR right now, for example, and it’s a good example of the skilled use of Third Person Omniscient to tell a complicated and many-faceted story that really could not be successfully and completely relayed if the viewpoint was restricted to Third Limited or First Person singular.
What should really determine the best POV for a story isn’t the current trend, but rather how much access to minds and thus to more locales and events you will need in order to tell a story the way it needs to be told. For example, many of my historical novels work well in First Person, because they are intimate accounts of one historical protagonist’s experiences and challenges — and they are often a neglected viewpoint normally seen only in conjunction with a more famous personage whose story has already been repeatedly told from their POV. But my husband’s literary naval thriller series has a worldwide stage and the plots are complex, including worldwide events and many major players. So it would end up seeming both ridiculous and impossible to fully try to tell that kind of story with a single Zelig-like narrator having to zoom around to all those far-flung places and to pretend they could have been present for all of the events while also subbing for the all the other important character PsOV. So rely on practical sense: Whose story is it, really? How many additional viewpoints do you need to fully and vividly tell it? (Maybe only one, maybe a lot more). And how much distance — more, or less? — will make the story feel more credible?
So decide these things before you choose. In fact, the only thing I would urge you to avoid in a novel (besides First Person narrators in a realistic novel who keep telling us what everyone around them is thinking, as if they have ESP) is what I used to call, when teaching in the MFA program, “grasshopper POV”. That is, when a scene or chapter which is meant to be dedicated to a main character’s viewpoint, yet the author kept dipping into the minds of other minor players in the room — often including those we don’t know and will never see again, like the random waitstaff in a restaurant scene. That is not a benefit to the story; it’s just an annoying interruption of the profluence and the real dedicated viewpoint. That’s jarring and annoying. Unlike the more restricting borders of short stories, novels give us the luxury of time and space to fully develop our main characters, so why interfere with that advantage for some brief, meaningless side journey?
If you feel like you may have an unwieldy number of Omniscient Third viewpoints, try to figure out how you can instead show some events that are not not accessible to your preferred main characters/viewpoints in some other way. Perhaps a terrorist bombing that’s a side plot is seen by them on the news, instead of them having to be there, for example. If you keep all of this in mind, then you’ll have a better idea of what your best choice of person and distance will be, for any given story or novel. And POV should always be determined before you begin writing, since that choice will drive the story and what can be shown and revealed within it.
Hope that’s helpful!
And then, from the venerable Milton Trachtenburg:
Each story demands its own formula to best tell it. Forget the labels, but, before you write, make your questions less generic. Nothing is “all or nothing” in writing. It is the either/or thinking that limits possibilities to two. Another point is that it is the writers who find the best perspective from which to tell their stories who attract the publishers to show the only interest that we need to start off: a willingness to take a flier on our work. The key is finding the best method to tell your story. Where does the narrator fit into the story? Does this story call for an involved narrator or a distant one? Does the narrator also serve as a character such as the one in Moby Dick? Distance is the core element in developing a narrator. I do not worry about labels. Labels can oversimplify your needs. All or nothing approaches lead to books which do not resonate with readers. The “who tells the story” is as important as any character in the story. In 99% of the fiction that sits lonely and unread on Amazon, most of the narrators could put a shark to sleep. A narrator, even a distant one, is a character and adds or subtracts from the story. The more you look at narration as a core element in the story, the better you will be at making the story flow in a seamless manner.
Best of luck developing the story and getting it into print.
And I even learned a new word, courtesy of Lenore—profluence, a copious or smooth flowing.
Hope you find this helpful, as I did.
Lar
Leave a Reply