Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
6/3/2025

The first word . . . “Tell me and I’ll forget; show me and I may remember; involve me and I’ll understand.”
— Chinese Proverb


Tuesday evening. . .

Seven writers attended the meeting. Five presented. 

Sue G.

Some critique suggestions included bringing up JP and Ant’s bad home life to the story opening. Other suggestions were to provide more personality differentiation between the two characters which would increase the tension.

Mike A. Charlie at 68. 

This short piece was well-received. Most of the discussion was about the river bed. Should I say right away that it’s dry? And where did the couch come from? Thanks! 

Jack F. (A Walk Upon the Water 2025)

Thanks for being all willing to read what was a double the usual helping of Walk Upon the Water.  Now a third of the way through the novel all seemed to perceive our hero (anti-hero?) incorporating something from his long afternoon with Lester the sage.  I have not had time to read the comments you have submitted, but the discussion was helpful. Another near disaster approaches and then a different sort of adolescent adventure will literally be thrust upon Sean.

Suzanne G. (Kaleidoscope rewrite of Chapters 20 and 21) 

The two chapters were well-received. Suggestions were made to clean up some confusion over POV, clarifying why Brandon doesn’t immediately answer Carey when he tells his big secret, capitalizing on a paragraph about rabbits, i.e. adding some insights about Carey running as the rabbits did. Grammatical errors were also pointed out, and finally BRING IN THE FOOD!

Kashmira S. (Valmiki chs. 6-9) 

The revised chapters were well received. There were some suggestions to make small changes and some typos. Thank you all. 

Presenters for our next meeting on June 17th

Larry S.

Suzanne G.

Jack F.

Sue G.

Susan S.

Kashmira S.

5th Tuesday:

From Jack

I’d enjoys hosting a Fifth Tuesday at the Farm, but Larry appears to be already booked.  Might a Third Wednesday work?

The Last word:

“Poetry is when an emotion has found its thought and the thought has found words.” ― Robert Frost

Writer’s Newsletter

Tuesdays With Story

May 27, 2025

First Word…

“Storytelling, like rhetoric, pulls us in through the cognitive mind as much as through the emotions. It answers both our curiosity and our longing for shapely forms: our profound desire to know what happens, and our persistent hope that what happens will somehow make sense. Narrative instructs us in both these hungers and their satisfaction, teaching us to perceive and to relish the arc of moments and the arc of lives. If shapeliness is an illusion, it is one we require — it shields against arbitrariness and against chaos’s companion, despair. And story, like all the forms of concentration, connects. It brings us to a deepened coherence with the world of others and also within the many levels of the self.”

— Jane Hirshfield

Tuesday evening…

Six TWS writers attended the meeting via Google Meet, three of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Kashmira S. – Valmiki, Chs. 1-5, revised. The overall comments about the voice were positive. There were a few suggestions for improvement. Valmiki’s age needs to be included in the beginning. Some other tweaking of the opening sentences might make it better. There was a question about what part of the bike was scratched. Other than that, Valmiki seems to be doing fine with his jungle brain. Thank you all for your feedback. 

Bob K. – Thank You, Ann Landers. Although several readers found the characters intriguing, their relationships remain a bit too vague. Likewise, the reason for Dave being at the festival is not convincing. Others mentioned the sense of menace and anticipation that runs through Ann Landers. Whether this is enough to carry it through to the end is anybody’s guess. Thank you for the thought provoking comments.

Susan S. – Bill essay. Positive and encouraging comments including writing the experience as a poem and as an essay expanding it with more descriptive details.

Jack F. – Walk Upon the Water, Ch. 19. The responses to Lester’s story was various. Most accepted the bard like story telling line and the limited responses from Sean, the listener.  One reviewer found the chapters seemingly confusing. Larry found  Lester a  bit too poetic, so “rosy fingers” of dawn will go, but I want that paragraph to remain a memory enhanced by the knowledge that he now was “home”, which he did not know back then.

Wendy B. – What Blood Runs Through Me, Cha. 66-68. The primary suggestion in these closing chapters was to develop Lucy as a more complex character, especially in her relationship with Michael. Thank you all!

Susan G. – Kaleidoscope Ch. 19, rewrite. There were a few grammatical and word changes suggested, along with one suggestion that will help with Carey’s future motivations: adding a few sentences indicating that Rattlesnake Man learns Carey’s name and address and threatens him. Thanks everyone for all of your helpful comments. 

Here’s who’s up on June 3…

Mike A.

Kashmira S.

Suzanne G.

Sue G

Jack F.

Next Word…

“Good fiction is made of what is real, and reality is difficult to come by.” 

— Ralph Ellison 

Colum McCann On Writing…

Gogol said that the last line of every story was, “And nothing would ever be the same again.” Nothing in life ever really begins in one single place, and nothing ever truly ends. But stories have at least to pretend to finish. Don’t tie it up too neatly. Don’t try too much. Often the story can end several paragraphs before, so find the place to use your red pencil. Print out several versions of the last sentence and sit with them. Go to your park bench again. Discover silence. Read each version over and over. Go with the one that you feel to be true and a little bit mysterious. Don’t tack on the story’s meaning. Don’t moralise at the end. Don’t preach that final hallelujah. Have faith that your reader has already gone with you on a long journey. They know where they have been. They know what they have learned. They know already that life is dark. You don’t have to flood it with last-minute light. 

You want the reader to remember. You want her to be changed. Or better still, to want to change. 

— excerpted from Letters To A Young Writer: Some Practical and Philosophical Advice.

Last Word…

“To be a person is to have a story to tell.”

— Isak Dinesen

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays With Story

May 6, 2025

First Word…

“A writer is a person who cares what words mean, what they say, how they say it. Writers know words are their way towards truth and freedom, and so they use them with care, with thought, with fear, with delight. By using words well they strengthen their souls. Story-tellers and poets spend their lives learning that skill and art of using words well. And their words make the souls of their readers stronger, brighter, deeper.”
― Ursula K. Le Guin

Tuesday evening…

Six TWS writers attended the meeting via Google Meet, three of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Suzanne G. – The rewrite of Kaleidoscope. Chapters 17 and 18 were well received. There were very few notes: cleaning up some confusing sentences, clarifying if Carey is afraid of walking alone at night, an abrupt chapter change that needs more detail as to how much time has passed.

Mike A. – Short story,Lloyd:  Lloyd  got some good reviews and helpful comments. Joey’s bleak hopelessness and lack of direction went over really well. We had some discussion of how much information is too much, and how the narration mirrored Joey’s personality. That was some fun food for thought. Lloyd needs to be introduced more clearly so we know who and what he is. Introducing a third party, whose repossessed car Lloyd is driving, so late in the short story is a little jarring. I’d like to keep it somehow just because it shows the kind of person Lloyd is. But then again, maybe his actions with his daughter pretty much says it. And I need to explain just where the black dust of a battery factory comes from. Thanks everyone! 

Continue Reading »

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
April 15, 2025                                                              Editor: Wendy Bialek

The first words…

“There’s not much to be said about the period except that most writers don’t reach it soon enough.”  Excerpt from On Writing Well

“Write with a combination of short, medium, and long sentences. Create a sound that pleases the reader’s ear. Don’t just write words. Write music.” Gary Provost

Congratulations Kashmira! Her book signing event on April 8 at Mystery to Me Bookstore in Madison was a standing room only event. Several members of Tuesdays with Stories attended and were rewarded with an entertaining and informative presentation by Kashmira.

Continue Reading »

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
April 1, 2025                                                              Editor: Wendy B.

The first, first word…

Wishing Kashmira safe travels and an amazing book signing event on April 8 at Mystery to Me Bookstore in Madison!

The first word . . .

“One must not put a loaded rifle on the stage if no one is thinking of firing it.”

Anton Chekhov, 1889

It never hurts to be reminded of a basic narrative principle—every element in a story should have relevance and contribute to the plot.

Tuesday Evening Summaries . . .

Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 59-60)

‘Social-path’ instead of sociopath? Uh-oh. It only goes to show you that ‘disturbing’ is in the eyes of the reader! Looks like I need to ramp up the tension and authenticity of the journal entries, big time. A critical juncture in the story, so thank you all for your suggestions.

Jack F. (Chapters 12-14)

The chapters that I feared were rather flat, were accepted as readable. These are actually important chapters as they are like page 2 of Sean’s biography and set the reader up for the next long disastrous chapter.  I’m writing in rhythm, or trying to, with ups and downs in information and intensity. That seems to be like life.

I’ve noted that there is a questing theme in the novel, Jason and the Argonauts with Lester as Chrion, but the majority of the mythic structure under the novel, which most readers will never observe, is Celtic or Brittonic. The next chapter is Welsh folklore, The Mabinogion in particular, with a trip into the underworld where the quester has to climb a revolving mountain of glass or ice, where almost all visitors are killed. There is a magic cauldron inside the mountain. 

The Welsh underworld is Annwn and is guarded by dogs (Cwn Annwn)  reached through a multi-door gate, the Hayton bridge in the next chapter.  Annwn  is home to the souls of the dead (Sean’s ancestors) and is a world “between worlds” where reality is often deeper and has lessons to teach. Not much of this is important for the reader, but as a writer I am looking back at ancient and perhaps universal themes.  Some author once said that Celtic myth underlies much of our literature “like Merlin complaining under his rock”. It is an ancient voice, not audible, but still there as an echo of earlier writers, prophets and priests. Thank you all for your comments.

Suzanne G.  (Kaleidoscope, Chapter 14 rewrite)

The main takeaway from the group was that Carey’s anger and fear over Brandon’s revelation of having synesthesia needed more buildup. Other notes: Brandon needed to remember what happened to Carey on his birthday; and Brandon should make more of an effort to care for Carey when he’s hurting over memories of his family. Thanks everyone for the always helpful comments. 

Continue Reading »

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
March 18, 2025

The first word . . .

“Writers aren’t just people who sit down and write. They hazard themselves. Every time you compose a book your composition of yourself is at stake.” E.L. Doctorow

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B (What Blood Runs Through Me)

Tension at the cabin scene was well received. The main issue was Lucy’s lackluster response to the news that Mom’s house would have to be sold. Disappointment just didn’t cut it. A great catch. Thank you all!

Suzanne G (Kaleidoscope rewrite of Chaps 12 & 13)

The consensus was that Brandon’s and Carey’s characters blended well together and were much clearer and more well-defined than at the last reading of these chapters. Overall, the chapters flowed much more smoothly although the rainbow metaphor didn’t work as intended. It will be rewritten. Thanks everyone for the comments. As always, I greatly appreciate your efforts.

Jack F (A Walk Upon the Water Chaps 10-11)

The chapter was well received.  The usual format issues persist, but I’m concentrating on compression, rhythm, humor and bad Modernist jokes.

Thanks for all the helpful feedback to date on these first dozen chapters and the close reading you are providing.

Continue Reading »

Writer’s Mail

March 4, 2025

The first word . . .

“Exercise the writing muscle every day, even if it is only a letter, notes, a title list, a character sketch, a journal entry. Writers are like dancers, like athletes. Without that exercise, the muscles seize up.” Jane Yolen

Tuesday Evening . . .

Wendy B (What Blood Runs Through Me)

The chapters were well received, but as always, some excellent comments to enrich the piece. Word choices, a few typos to keep readers on their toes, needless repetition, And, of course, an old Derringer wouldn’t have a safety.  Roughly just 40 more pages to go. Thank you all!

Suzanne G (Kaleidoscope rewrite of Chaps 10 & 11)

Most of the suggestions were for Chapter 10: the racist man seemed to be a bit of a caricature and should be reworked; the kiss at the end should evolve more and not have them slamming together; a scene with the coffee cake could be added; and last but not least—they need to lock up their bikes. In Chapter 11 the main comment was that Brandon should focus more on Carey’s needs and not his own. It would make Brandon a stronger character and emphasis his own growth. Thanks for all the comments. As always, they strengthen my work.

Continue Reading »

Writer’s Mail

February 18th, 2024 Meeting

The First Word…

“The short story, if you really are intense and you have an exciting idea, writes itself in a few hours. I try to encourage my student friends and my writer friends to write a short story in one day so it has a skin around it, its own intensity, its own life, its own reason for being. There’s a reason why the idea occurred to you at that hour anyway, so go with that and investigate it, get it down. Two or three thousand words in a few hours is not that hard. Don’t let people interfere with you. Boot ’em out, turn off the phone, hide away, get it done. If you carry a short story over to the next day you may overnight intellectualize something about it and try to make it too fancy, try to please someone.” Ray Bradbury

Seven writers met in the warm glow of the internet to discuss the work of five presenting writers. Those presenting were Wendy, Jack, Kashmira, Larry, and Amit. Here are some of the comments that were received on their work:

What Blood Runs Through Me-Wendy B. The chapters were well received. The primary issue was that Michael made no comment on the Larry Owens tape adding no new info/clues to the investigation. Admittedly a big omission. I have added just a line to that effect. Larry will return at the end of the story with a clue to help solve the case. The other point was the minimal reaction of Michael to June’s passing. Next week’s chapters (still at the funeral) will address that issue. Thank you!

A Walk on the Water, Jack F. The feedback is various with two readers liking the chapters more or less for the small town feel and humor.  I’ve not had time to look at most of the suggestions mailed to date, but thanks for them.  

Amit noted that Lester is speaking to the boat when he taps it.  If the boat and Lester are main characters, perhaps they can have a conversation, so Amit recommends Lester speak to the boat. I will work that in as it is a great idea and the result of a good insight.

Larry noted the Argos is the ship in Jason and the Argonauts and asked about possible meanings.  I said that the myth was an undercurrent, but failed to explain that Lester was Chiron the Centaur, who trains Jason and the crew, then send them off. There is a hint as in “his hair flow like a horse’s mane before brushing” in the Lester description. Lester later canters down the shore in excitement, as the crew comes back from the first crossing of the bar. This is not parallelism, but as with Modernism, the use of myth to inform the writing, the old man-horse shapes the youth for an adventure in which he cannot participate.

Will get next few chapters out shortly, while I revise those presented.  Have a lull in work, so more writing time available.

The Saltmaker’s Son, Kashmira S. Kashmira submitted the revised Chapter 10-13 of The Saltmaker’s Son. Karna’s internal growth, where he comes from and what possibilities and opportunities are there for him were shown well. There were some places where more observations were needed. The magical realism scene could use some trimming. Thank you all for your input!

Larry F. S.–Brother’s Blood: Transition from Ch. 16 to 17 is abrupt. Also, Jag and Margaret move to San Francisco and suddenly they’re living in Hawaii. It’s not obvious that Pearl City is near Pearl Harbor. Dialog between Jag and Oliveiras needs improvements. Ditto for Jag’s internal state in Ch. 17 when the flight is recalled to Wake on account of Japanese hostilities; his emotional distress still needs to be in keeping with his overall character. Good points, everybody. Thanks.

Amit T., Betrayal. The first stanza of the poem was well received but the second and third were not up to par.
Suggestion was made to remove the second stanza all together. In doing so the poem will have more of an impact.
Thanks!

Our next meeting will be on Tuesday, March 4th. Presenters will be:

Mike

Jack

Wendy

Kashmira

Larry F.

Writer’s Mail

February 4th, 2024

The First Word…

“The easy, conversational tone of good writing comes only on the eighth rewrite.”

            Paul Graham

Seven of us attended Tuesday’s meeting. Five people presented work. They were:

Amit T., “Anna.”

Wendy B., “What Blood Runs Through Me.” Chapters 49-51

Kashmira S., “The Saltmaker’s Son.” Chapters 6-9

Suzanne G., “Kaleidoscope.” Chapters 32-33 and Epilogue

Jack F., “A Walk Upon the Water.” Chapters 3-5

Here are some of the comments about their work.

Suzanne G.

Kaleidoscope: Rewrite of Chapters 32, 33 and Epilogue

Everyone liked the last chapters though there were some things that needed clarification or added detail: Rattlesnake Man, his escape and capture were both skated over too quickly; the reader would want more on how Carey felt about this and how it affects his life beyond Rattlesnake Man’s death. The addition of Brandon’s family and the wedding was good, but there were too many people added at one time. More was needed about the family to give them all distinctive personalities. The conversation with Brandon’s dad and Carey worked well. As usual there were a few POV confusions and more than a few grammatical errors. The Oxford comma is not my friend!  Thanks to all for your help and encouragement.

Kashmira S.

Kashmira submitted chapter 6-9 of The Saltmaker’s Son. There were spelling and grammar mistakes as well as too many “I” usage. There was also concerns about using poetic language and if it is right for this age group.  Overall, the chapters were well-received. Karna is twelve and that age seems perfect for this coming of story.  Thank you all for your comments.

Wendy B.

What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 49-51.  Wendy Bialek. As the group was quick to point out, the primary issue with the chapters evolved around Darla’s intent in getting inside the cabin, and why Michael was so reluctant to go inside with her. It wasn’t his foreboding, or fear that unauthorized police records would be inside. No, he was afraid Darla had misplaced expectations of a rendezvous. Something needs to happen. Problem solved! Thanks, everyone:) 

Presenting for our February 18 meeting:

Jack F.

Wendy B.

Kashmira S.

Larry F. S.

Amit T.

Kashmira’s Book Signing!

Here is the info about my April signing at the Mystery to Me bookstore. It is on Tuesday night and we don’t have a meeting so I’d love to see some friends there!

Livestream: https://www.crowdcast.io/c/im-from-here-too
https://www.eventbrite.com/e/livemtm-kashmira-sheth-tickets-1235104162799?aff=oddtdtcreator
Website: https://www.mysterytomebooks.com/kashmira-sheth
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/events/1669727313927906/

Some last words…

“I have never started a poem yet whose end I knew. Writing a poem is discovering.”

            Robert Frost

            This surprised me. Robert Frost’s poems always seem so perfectly planned and crafted, as if he knew all along where he was going, when in fact he didn’t really know. But it worked for him. John Updike, on the other hand, said that he can’t start writing a story unless he knows where it’s going to end. And that works for him. He also said that it took him three novels before he realized that it was the method he would always write with, and there was nothing wrong with it. So it seems that there is no right or wrong method to writing, so long as it gets done. Yes, I’m lecturing myself.

Book recommendation…

“Writing Fiction. A Guide to Narrative Craft,” by Janet Burroway.

            This is, for me, the best book on writing I’ve seen. Burroway discusses the basics of writing, creative methods, styles, rewrites, and accepting criticism. The book is filled with short stories of various styles, and makes for good reading if you’re bored with instruction. I’ve had my copy, the third edition, for years and years, and still open it when I need some inspiration or instruction. I see that now it’s in the tenth edition.

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
1/21/2025

The first word . . .

Yesterday is but a dream. Tomorrow is only a vision. But today well lived makes every yesterday a dream of happiness and every tomorrow a vision of hope.

Poet Kalidas (Author of Shakuntala and other works written in Sanskrit, 4th-5th century CE)

Tuesday evening. . .

Seven writers attended the meeting. Six presented.

Bob K. (Rialto) – Although Rialto has grown as a story, several key issues still need work. What, for instance, is happening in the present and what is happening as a flashback. Also, the time period of the story needs to be clearer. On a positive note, Jim’s aimlessness and the desperation he feels about his job at the movie theater is convincing. Thanks for all the thoughtful comments.

Wendy B. (What Blood, Ch. 48-49) – What Blood Runs Through Me-Wendy B. What I thought was a pretty clean submission…wasn’t. Thanks to the observations of the group, I’ve corrected the crystal ball somehow (magically!) being in two places at one time, a lackluster response from Michael after learning Boyle stole evidence from the homicide scene and created more mystique about Indigo Rose’s reading of JJ and Mark’s future. And an assortment of other little things, including cleaning up the timeline. Thanks so much!

Continue Reading »