February 18th, 2024 Meeting
The First Word…
“The short story, if you really are intense and you have an exciting idea, writes itself in a few hours. I try to encourage my student friends and my writer friends to write a short story in one day so it has a skin around it, its own intensity, its own life, its own reason for being. There’s a reason why the idea occurred to you at that hour anyway, so go with that and investigate it, get it down. Two or three thousand words in a few hours is not that hard. Don’t let people interfere with you. Boot ’em out, turn off the phone, hide away, get it done. If you carry a short story over to the next day you may overnight intellectualize something about it and try to make it too fancy, try to please someone.” Ray Bradbury
Seven writers met in the warm glow of the internet to discuss the work of five presenting writers. Those presenting were Wendy, Jack, Kashmira, Larry, and Amit. Here are some of the comments that were received on their work:
What Blood Runs Through Me-Wendy B. The chapters were well received. The primary issue was that Michael made no comment on the Larry Owens tape adding no new info/clues to the investigation. Admittedly a big omission. I have added just a line to that effect. Larry will return at the end of the story with a clue to help solve the case. The other point was the minimal reaction of Michael to June’s passing. Next week’s chapters (still at the funeral) will address that issue. Thank you!
A Walk on the Water, Jack F. The feedback is various with two readers liking the chapters more or less for the small town feel and humor. I’ve not had time to look at most of the suggestions mailed to date, but thanks for them.
Amit noted that Lester is speaking to the boat when he taps it. If the boat and Lester are main characters, perhaps they can have a conversation, so Amit recommends Lester speak to the boat. I will work that in as it is a great idea and the result of a good insight.
Larry noted the Argos is the ship in Jason and the Argonauts and asked about possible meanings. I said that the myth was an undercurrent, but failed to explain that Lester was Chiron the Centaur, who trains Jason and the crew, then send them off. There is a hint as in “his hair flow like a horse’s mane before brushing” in the Lester description. Lester later canters down the shore in excitement, as the crew comes back from the first crossing of the bar. This is not parallelism, but as with Modernism, the use of myth to inform the writing, the old man-horse shapes the youth for an adventure in which he cannot participate.
Will get next few chapters out shortly, while I revise those presented. Have a lull in work, so more writing time available.
The Saltmaker’s Son, Kashmira S. Kashmira submitted the revised Chapter 10-13 of The Saltmaker’s Son. Karna’s internal growth, where he comes from and what possibilities and opportunities are there for him were shown well. There were some places where more observations were needed. The magical realism scene could use some trimming. Thank you all for your input!
Larry F. S.–Brother’s Blood: Transition from Ch. 16 to 17 is abrupt. Also, Jag and Margaret move to San Francisco and suddenly they’re living in Hawaii. It’s not obvious that Pearl City is near Pearl Harbor. Dialog between Jag and Oliveiras needs improvements. Ditto for Jag’s internal state in Ch. 17 when the flight is recalled to Wake on account of Japanese hostilities; his emotional distress still needs to be in keeping with his overall character. Good points, everybody. Thanks.
Amit T., Betrayal. The first stanza of the poem was well received but the second and third were not up to par.
Suggestion was made to remove the second stanza all together. In doing so the poem will have more of an impact.
Thanks!
Our next meeting will be on Tuesday, March 4th. Presenters will be:
Mike
Jack
Wendy
Kashmira
Larry F.
Leave a Reply