Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays With Story Newsletter

November 4th Meeting

First Word…

“I’m glad that I didn’t have the Internet when I started writing. I started writing when I was 20 and didn’t show a word of it to anyone until I was 28. I had the sense to keep it to myself. Now the temptation with blogs and such, they’re just getting it out there; maybe it would have been best to keep it to themselves.”

–David Sedaris

Seven writers attended the November 4th meeting. Five of them presented work. Here are their summaries of the critiques they received from us.

Kashmira S. Kashmira submitted chapters 14-17 of Veena’s story. Overall the comments were positive. The place she hides diary may not work for everyone. Also, needed a little more from Veena to convince Mayur to take her with him to help her brother. The glimpse behind Veena’s father and her own growth works well. Thank you all.

Susan G. The overall critique was good. Some suggestions were to enhance the makeup section and to have the owners of the RIP Inn more excited/scared about their encounters with the ghosts so they don’t seem as flat. 

Mike A. Fishing Camp, chapter 8. Though the scene in the supper club is well received, there isn’t anything moving the story forward. And I’ll admit, I did kind of lose focus on my original plot. Which is kind of nebulous through the middle. I’m also kind of stalled at this point. I need names! Names for the lakes, names for the twins. I’m thinking I’ll shelve this while I get a few things figured out. Thank you all for your comments.

Susan S. State of the Union (working title) Everyone acknowledged this is the initial portion of a work in progress. Helpful comments included incorporating the audience through asides, considering adding actors for certain scenes, and staging instructions.

Larry S. Brother’s Blood, “July 1927″and new Ch.1–There was general agreement the various scenes or episodes were well-written, but there was also general agreement that this mode of presentation muddies the waters as to whose story it was and which characters were most important. Back to the drawing board. Thanks, everybody.

Here’s who’s presenting work for November 18

Larry S.

Sue S.

Jack F.

Kashmira S.

Suzanne G.

There’s an opening or two if anyone has something they would like to submit.

Your editor this month is Mike. Let him know if there are any events or news that you would like in the next newsletter.

Another word…

“Give the reader at least one character he or she can root for.”—Kurt Vonnegut

Writer’s Mail

Writer’s Newsletter

Tuesdays With Story

October 21, 2025

First Word…

“ Literature adds to reality, it does not simply describe it. It enriches the necessary competencies that daily life requires and provides; and in this respect, it irrigates the deserts that our lives have already become.”

—C. S. Lewis, An Experiment in Criticism

Tuesday evening…

Seven TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, six of which read from their works in progress.

Here is a summary of what was said:

Susan S. –  When the Wells Run Dry, 4

Positive comments overall, with suggestions to include more personal details and the impact of events on others, as well as perhaps add attempts by Elle to do something about the pending disaster.

Sue G. –  The tail of Boris

The critiques were overall positive regarding the submission. There were suggestions to tighten up some of the dialogue, separate some of the compound sentences, and to remove some of the dialogue tags.

Mike A. – Fishing Camp” Chapters 6-7.

So far the dialog is working pretty well. But I need some physical descriptions of Chloe. It doesn’t have to be a lot, not at first. Short or tall? Dark hair or light? Expression on her face and eyes. I need an indication of her age as well. It would be good to explain some terrain. How is there a shortcut to town when the road takes so long? My thought is that it was too swampy in parts for a road straight to town. But I need some explanation of that. I’m going to have to flesh out the cluster or line of cabins along the lake. How far back from the highway is Doug’s family’s cabin if it’s at the end of the lane. How close are the other places? How many are there? Thanks for all the input and discussions. 

Jack f. –   A Walk Upon the Water, 44-45

            Comments were positive on the St Dom chapter, a difficult one to write and at one of two centers of the book as Sean gets a lesson he actually seems to hear from a very short priest with a tall talent.

Sue was concerned that Catholic readers may take offence at the use of words the priest selects, but I believe that he represents much of the Church during the ferment of Vatican II when the liberalizing of the church tried to make it relevant, thus I will go with history as a defense. Sue is correct that the Church today is conservative.  Many who came out of Vatican II left the church a decade later, as the hoped for changes began to be reversed under more conservative popes than John XXIII, born Angelo Joseppi Roncardi. 

I will post the next chapters shortly with extensive notes.  This is the second center of the book, as we see in Lester his participation in the history of his race. Please read those chapters before the notes so the notes to now affect how you relate to it.

Jack

Amit T. –  Beneath Every Edifice

There was much discussion about the poems meaning and imagery. Though the human desire to search for the supernatural was understood the poem’s theme was still confusing and felt a bit disjointed.

Kashmira S. –  Veena’s Story, 10-13

Kashmira submitted revised chapters 10-13 of her YA novel. The additional parts about Veena and Mayur as well as other characters work well. Some of the details make the story more grounded. Maybe add a little more? Also wanted to see more concerns and fear from Veena, 

The writing can be tightened up in a few places. The knitting analogy worked well. The complexity in this draft worked well. Thank you all!

Here’s who’s up on November 4

Mike A

Jack F

Sue G

Kashmira S

Susan S

Larry S

Our Editor for November…

Mike will serve as editor of Writer’s Newsletter.

Last Word…

“But words are things, and a small drop of ink,

Falling like dew upon a thought, produces

That which makes thousands, perhaps millions, think”

—Don Juan, Lord Byron

Writer’s Mail

Writer’s Newsletter

Tuesdays With Story

October 7, 2025

First Word…

 

I’m only really alive when I’m writing. 

—Tennessee Williams

Tuesday evening…

Eight TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, five of which read from their works in progress.

Here is a summary of what was said:

Susan S. –  When the Wells Run Dry, 3

Generally positive feedback. Suggestions included clarifying the distinction/distance between the family cottage, homestead, and the parents’ home, adding a character as interlocuter to flush out Elle’s concerns regarding the pending environmental cataclysm.

Mike A. – “Fishing Camp” Chapters 3-5. 

Fishing Camp received favorable reviews. There was a brief bar fight about how to order an Old Fashioned. Excuse me, Brandy Old Fashioned. I also have to watch how many times certain words appear in a paragraph. For instance, I have a lot of “they” in one paragraph. I need to have more of Doug’s thoughts, not just his observations about what’s going on around him. What is Doug feeling? Thanks everyone for your thoughts and discussion. 

Jack f. –   A Walk Upon the Water, 42-43

There was general agreement, including from me, that the Barb reminiscence was a stumble in the narration.  I was uncomfortable for it whinny voice, so that longer paragraph is now gone along with a repetition when standing at the Argos,  It is amazing what I do not see!     

Larry F. S. –  Brother’s Blood, Ch. 25-26:  

There were some practical concerns, such as: Were litters strapped to the floor or hung from the ceiling on DC-3s flying the Hump?  How much detail should we provide on the engine-start cycle for the Boeing 314? How best put readers in the picture on LaGuardia Airport and the Marine Air Terminal? And a big concern: What about the overall plot, staggering from one locale to another? Does Jag’s sojourn in the Himalayas have any relevance to the overall story? Good questions all. Thanks.

Kashmira S. –  Veena’s Story, 6-10. 

Kashmira submitted revised chapters 6-10 of her YA novel. The story moved well. There were some questions about the word choices and also overuse of the word “fighters”. There was a comment about showing emotions during the dinner scene to enhance family dynamics. Thank you all for your comments. 

Here’s who’s up on October 21

Mike A

Jack F

Sue G

Kashmira S

Susan S

Amit T

Our Editor for October…

Amit will serve as editor of Writer’s Newsletter. 

Last Word…

A poet is a nightingale who sits in darkness and sings to cheer its own solitude with sweet sounds; his auditors are as men entranced by the melody of an unseen musician.”
— A Defence of Poetry

Writer’s Mail

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
September 16, 2025

The first word . . .

“We write to taste life twice, in the moment and in retrospect.” Anaïs Nin

Tuesday Evening . . .

Susan S (To Sleep, Perchance to Dream) Suggestions including adding some description of the dreamscape at the end, and breaking up some of the emotionally dense paragraphs.

Mike A (Fishing Camp Chaps 1-2) I had some really good feedback for this piece. The setting and some of the situations went over well. I really need to flesh Doug out, and get into his emotions. His unresolved breakup with his best friend needs to be more on his mind. And I need to show more of why Doug, and others, might be upset that Frank is missing. What’s so great about Frank, except that he and his wife seem to be part of the cabin community. There’s a lot of editing that needs to be done in these first two chapters. Thanks for the great input!  

Larry S. (Spinal Tap and a Bit More) Everyone was entertained by this flight of fancy and wanted to know where it would go next. Mike opined that it would take a long story, possibly a novella, to work through the implications of the initial setup.  

Jack F (A Walk Upon the Water Chaps 40-41) Comments on writing were positive, Grammer?  Well, I need help! Perhaps I’ve invented a new game Find the Quote Marks.  

Who’s up next . . .  

Kashmira S

Jack F

Mike A

Susan S

Larry S

For the good of the order . . .

5th Tuesday September 30th at 7 pm at Larry’s house. Wine, beer, and non-alcoholic beverages will be available. Please bring some snack or light refreshment item, and if you have a special preferred beverage, bring it yourself.  He’ll have napkins and paper plates.

Amit will be the editor for October. 

The last word . . .

“If my doctor told me I had only six minutes to live, I wouldn’t brood. I’d type a little faster.”
Isaac Asimov

And for the fun of it . . .

“Here is a lesson in creative writing. First rule: Do not use semicolons. They are transvestite hermaphrodites representing absolutely nothing. All they do is show you’ve been to college.”
Kurt Vonnegut Jr.

“If you see a footnote, quick kill it before it can breed.” S. Shoemaker

Writer’s Mail

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
September 2, 2025

The first word . . .

“If there’s a book that you want to read, but it hasn’t been written yet, then you must write it.” Toni Morrison

Tuesday Evening . . .

Jack F (A Walk Upon the Water Chaps 37-39)

Sue helped with lots of corrections.  Thanks. Amazing how I cannot read what I write!  These chapters seemed well received and are the end of a section of the book, ended with no resolution, at least for Sean.  Now we will head someplace completely different with a teenaged boy acting much like … a teenaged boy. The tone will change and I shall see if you enjoyment continues.

Susan S (When the Wells Run Dry Chap 2)

Concensus was to work in a bit more foreshadowing of the future environmental disaster/water shortage.

Kashmira S (Venna’s Story Chaps 3-5)

Kashmira submitted the next 3 chapters of her YA novel. Mostly, the revision was satisfactory. There was a a scene with Veena and Mayur that maybe needed a little tweaking and a couple of smiles that didn’t ring very true. There were some grammar mistakes. I’ll revisit the chapters with all the comments in mind. Thank you. 

Larry S (Sparky)

The first sentence should make clear that the “F-150” in question is a Ford pickup truck, not a stealth fighter with a handbrake. Other than that, everyone liked the flow, feel, and pace of the story. The question is, where does it go? Plenty of good ideas: The vague personages could turn out to be a meerkat and space aliens. But everyone thought it was a bad idea for Erik to confront the squatters without precautions. He should (a) Call the cops, (b) go armed, (c) be an auxiliary deputy with weapon and flashlight, (d) have a dog. Something like that. We’re all waiting with bated breath to see what develops. Thanks, everyone!

Sue G (Sparkle on the Water)

The reviewers liked the chapter and the interaction between the characters. One of the reviewers especially liked how the girls didn’t get along at the beginning, made up in the end. Another reviewer suggested not explaining as much to maintain the flow of the story.

Who’s up next . . .  

Jack F

Larry S

Susan S

Mike A

Kashmira S (provisionally)

For the good of the order . . .

Larry’s recovery continues to go well.

The wedding of Jack’s daughter was a successful event.

The last word . . .

“Either write something worth reading or do something worth writing.” Benjamin Franklin

And for the fun of it . . .

“Substitute ‘damn’ every time you’re inclined to write ‘very’; your editor will delete it and the writing will be just as it should be.” Mark Twain

Writer’s Mail

Writer’s Newsletter

Tuesdays With Story

August 19, 2025

First Word…

“I have only one reason to write novels, and that is to bring the dignity of the individual soul to the surface and shine a light upon it. The purpose of a story is to sound an alarm, to keep a light trained on The System in order to prevent it from tangling our souls in its web and demeaning them. I fully believe it is the novelist’s job to keep trying to clarify the uniqueness of each individual soul by writing stories—stories of life and death, stories of love, stories that make people cry and quake with fear and shake with laughter. This is why we go on, day after day, concocting fictions with utter seriousness.”

– Haruki Murakami

Tuesday evening…

Eight TWS writers attended the meeting via Google Meet, five of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Kashmira S. – Kashmira submitted the first two chapters of her YA novel. The working title is Veena’s Story.

There was a good discussion about the lunch scene in the first chapter when Jasu tells his father that he has quit his studies. There were also some disagreements about the scene between Veena and Mayur. The main question was did it feel like a romantic scene or not? There were some spelling mistakes and word choices that needed corrections. Other than that the story seems to move at a good pace.

Thank you all for your comments and suggestions.  

Susan G. – “Sparkle”. Some of the critique group didn’t find the story amusing and didn’t like the young adult story overall. Others felt the main character needed more desire and more reasons why she wanted to spend the weekend with her best friend on a camping trip before they leave for college. 

Bob K. – “Atlas”. Just what is this story about? What is going on here? Who are these characters and what is their relationship? These were a few of the reactions to Atlas. Other comments were focused on the mess of Albert’s life and the shortcomings of his character. One reader suggested that Atlas may be less of a story than a yarn, while another pointed out that there is another, more effective story hiding somewhere inside of it. Thanks for all of the thoughtful comments.

Jack F. – A Walk Upon the Water, 35-36. In the last two chapters I presented, our hero Sean is tossed from the Argos and is caught in a rip current in medium to heavy seas.  His consciousness ebbs as he near drowns, but once far enough out that the current slackens, he does surface and is picked up semi-conscious by the crew. I was heartened that the somewhat mad and disoriented writing was accepted as descriptive and the third-person describer seemed to bother no one in the last few paragraphs.

The following chapter is just a history of his thoughts and reactions after the near-death experience and a decision to talk to Lester. That leads up to a long Lester tale, which I will distribute shortly.

Both chapters seem to have been well received and multiple typos surfaced and were corrected. Thanks to all.

Larry F. S. – Brother’s Blood, Chs. 22-24:  It was generally agreed that Harold’s foray into corporalship by censoring Stanley’s tent display of a risqué pinup, and Jag’s experience of flying the Hump, were immediate and well-written. However, large sections of Chapters 22 and 23 were more explanatory in nature, needing to be trimmed and placed in an action context. Also, as usual, more relational material is needed, delineating the two brothers’ emotions around the family dynamics of love, death, and geographic separation. I’ll work on those things. Thanks, everybody.

Here’s who’s up on November 19…

Jack F.

Susan S.

Kashmira S.

Larry F.S.

Sue G.

Next Word…

“Imagination is not a means of making money. It has no place in the vocabulary of profitmaking. It is not a weapon, though all weapons originate from it, and their use, or non-use, depends on it, as with all tools and their uses. The imagination is an essential tool of the mind, a fundamental way of thinking, an indispensable means of becoming and remaining human.”

– Ursula K. LeGuin

For the Good of the Order…

We are in need of an editor for September. As I have mentioned before, it’s a pretty low-stress job. Pretty much a cookie-cutter approach. I have the template, in case you have misplaced it. With our current level of participation in the group, it appears that everybody would need to volunteer about twice a year. So please, somebody, volunteer. Blessings.

Miranda July on Writing…

“Often I’ll have a feeling which is sometimes a sad or desperate or some kind of unresolved feeling, and I’ll marry it to some detail from the world, and those two things combined kind of set me on a course for writing a story. I don’t know what it’s going to be about. For example, I wrote down a few things the woman behind me on the plane said. She was talking about someone who was housesitting for her and the bird had escaped and she was describing how to catch the bird and what to do with it, and just little things she said, like, “Were you watching the house when Gabriel, the dove, escaped?” and it was like these little things which, in and of themselves, it’s like I’m not just interested in people’s dialogue, but that kind of loaned to some really personal thing in myself. That’s kind of where energy comes from for me… Yeah.”

Last Word…

“Hate is a lack of imagination.”  
– Graham Greene

Writer’s Mail

Writer’s Newsletter

Tuesdays With Story

August 5, 2025

First Word…

“When it comes to fiction, the whole point of it is that you have to let go. You have to be willing to go wherever it takes you. That I think, is the fundamental requirement of writing good fiction — a certain kind of truth, a certain kind of, what I like to call radical honesty.

– Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

Tuesday evening…

Six writers attended the meeting via Google Meet, five of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Kashmira S. submitted the last few chapters of The Saltmaker’s Son. Jack had many questions and suggestions about revising some part of the stories. The main parts were why does Karna go to the house with two pairs of eyes watching him, the newspaper article by Rekha Ben, does she look at the paintings again after Karna runs away. Bob saw that doubts deplete imagination. Krna must realize that and have thoughts about it. Larry felt that Karna feels like an imposter. The ending worked well.

Bob K. – Atlas, part one: The general reaction was that Atlas could have started with the phone call, with all the opening business about Ed driving to New York and Albert being out of work used later as backstory. Others felt that the call itself sounded like a scam and that Albert had no reason to keep listening. There was a comment about using the newspaper classifieds to find a job rather than a computer-based search. Thank you all for the thoughtful comments.

Susan S. – When the Wells Run Dry Tuesdays, Chapter 1: Interesting concept and strong character – a few would like to see more exposition at the beginning to better understand the location and character’s history.

Jack F. – Walk Upon the Water: xxx

Jerry P. – Welcome to Barkery Bliss, part 2: xxx

Here’s who’s up on August …

Kashmira S.

Bob K.

Sue G.

Jack F.

Larry F. S.

Next Word…

“That is the mystery about writing: it comes out of afflictions, out of the gouged times, when the heart is cut open.”

― Edna O’Brien

Colum McCann On Writing…

You should be exhausted when you finish your story. You should feel as if you have just ripped yourself open and that there is nothing more to give. Doubt yourself. Be convinced that you are a charlatan. Anything good you wrote was entirely accidental. Be sure that you will never be able to do it again. You’ve somehow delivered something special. You have no idea how you got here and you have no idea if you will ever do it again. In fact, be convinced that you won’t. This exhaustion is the moment of greatest celebration. That’s when you know you’re finished. And if at first you do succeed, be entirely astonished.

Last Word…

I think hard times are coming when we will be wanting the voices of writers who can see alternatives to how we live now and can see through our fear-stricken society and its obsessive technologies to other ways of Being, and even imagine some real grounds for hope.

We will need writers who can remember freedom, poets, visionaries — the realists of a larger reality.

– Ursula LeGuin

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
Jul 15, 2025

The first word . . .

“Nobody really believes that beauty can rescue the world, but there will always be writers whose main talent is to imagine it could.” Andrew O’Hagan

Tuesday Evening . . .

Sue G (Legion’s Mark, Chap 3)

Critique participants suggested describing why JP ran from the hotel room. Having Ant and the two women appear in his room could also ramp up the sinister tension, as well as having JP outline why he needs to risk his life to escape to Vera’s shop. 

Jerry P (Welcome to the Barkery Bliss)

xxxx

Jack F (A Walk Upon the Water Chaps 29-31)

Sent three short chapters from mid-book for last Tuesday with Lester spinning a yarn, actually a true story, perhaps with a bit of added drama on remembrance.  The old man looks back on a long life and its adventures without nostalgia, seeming regret or fear, whereas our Sean looks darkly, thinks darkly, often feels darkly.  Is this why he is so drawn to Lester….there is different way to live?

The reports were that it was an enjoyable read with the usual plethora of grammar and spelling corrections.  Made a few changes based on comments and did lots of text clean-up.

Susan S (Animal House)

Lots of positive feedback including suggestions to tighten up some parts.

Kashmira S (The Saltmaker’s Son Chaps 1-3)

Kashmira submitted the first three revised chapters of her MG novel, The Saltmaker’s Son. The setting worked for everyone. There was a little discussion about magical realism and how Karna sees a swan when everyone seeds a flamingo. The paragraphs need to be shorter and some words need to be trimmed. Thanks for all your comments.

Who’s up next . . .  

Jack F

Kashmira S

Bob K

Susan S

Larry S

Mike A

For the good of the order . . . 

From Jerry P–

Novelist Susan Wiggs recently wrote a piece for Writer’s Digest titled “How to be a Writer in 10 Simple Steps.”

The first eight steps aren’t worth the time to read them, but Steps 9 and 10, that’s where the good stuff is. And here they are:

Step Nine

Just write. Get up an hour earlier every day and work on your novel. Stop cooking. Stop cleaning. Tell your kids not to interrupt you unless their eyes are bleeding. Realize it’s more important to show your kids that you’re going for your dream than it is to show them you know how to fold laundry or whip up an omelet.

Remember that Anthony Trollope finished 50 novels by writing for an hour before work every day. Forget that you’ve never read an Anthony Trollope novel.

Don’t tell anyone you’re writing a novel. They’ll only bug you, asking when that book will be done and available in stores. Tell them you’re writing worksheets for your students. If you’re a lawyer, tell them you’re writing legal briefs. If you’re a doctor, tell them you’re writing a case study. If you’re a bartender, tell them you’re writing a tell-all memoir about your friends. This will usually shut them up.

Name all the bad characters in your books after people who treated you mean in high school.

Listen to The Last of the Mohicans theme music when you write.

Get up and dance around the room when you write something gorgeous. Realize you’ll probably need to cut it later.

Love your characters. Hate them. Worry about them. Don’t let them off easy. Make their conflicts as hard and compelling and important as life itself. Make them earn their happy ending.

Feel bashful when you meet a real published writer. Stand in line for an hour, waiting to meet your idol. When you finally get to the front of the line, forget what you were going to say and stammer, “I love your books.” Then kick yourself for not saying more.

Grow your hair out so you look like a historical romance heroine. Get your author photo taken. Tear it into a million pieces because it’s awful.

Design your own covers. Picture your published book on the stands.

Send your finished book to a literary agent, one who doesn’t charge fees. Get rejected. Learn from the comments. Repeat until the end of time, or until someone says, “Yes,” whichever comes first.

Step Ten

Get an offer from a publisher. A real publisher that pays you royalties. Feel the world shift on its axis.

Realize your book is not your baby anymore. Getting feedback can be painful. When someone says, “This doesn’t work for me,” believe them. They’re always right. Learn to think like a reader. You don’t get to sit next to her and explain the parts that aren’t working for her. So when your editor gives you notes, don’t argue. Revisit the story and write it better.

But when someone says, “Here’s the way you should rewrite it,” don’t listen. You’re the one who has to fix it. Don’t write their story. Write yours.

The last word . . .

“Writing a novel is like making love, but it’s also like having a tooth pulled. Pleasure and pain. Sometimes it’s like making love while having a tooth pulled.” Dean Koontz

And for the fun of it . . .

“Looking at life from a different perspective makes you realize that it’s not the deer that is crossing the road, rather it’s the road that is crossing the forest.” Muhammed Ali

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
6/17/2025

The first word . . .

“Writing is an exploration. You start from nothing and learn as you go.” – E.L. Doctorow


Tuesday evening. . .

Eight writers attended the meeting. Six presented. 

Sue G. (Legion’s Mark Ch.2)

Some of the critique suggestions were to have JP react more to Ant’s tattoo moving from the back of his hand to his wrist, to have JP hope that Ant is still alive when he is taken via ambulance to the hospital, and to increase tension by focusing on JP’s  guilt of leaving Ant alone in the hotel room before the MD states Ant is dead. It was also suggested to show more of Ant’s behavioral changes in the hotel room prior to JP leaving to pickup food.

Larry S. Brother’s Blood, Ch. 21–The main discussion was around Harold’s character: How greatly was he affected by his pre-existing disability? Why is he so fatalistic about his chances of survival? Can he become more capable and commanding, or offset his disability with some other ability that’s actually enhanced? And how can his thinking and philosophy develop in a more coherent way? There were good observations also about practical matters such as feeding the troops and how much info was shared about their mission. Great discussion. Thanks, everybody!

Jack F. (A Walk Upon the Water 2025)

Pushing the edge with some descriptions, but it seems the chapter was not too far over the top. I toned down the next chapter, where the kids regain the shore a bit. Then we go back to plan old exposition for a while as a relief from the intensity of a couple of chapters.

The ups and downs of intensity to me mirror teenage life when everything was massively important, until it wasn’t, and then things were maybe a bit boring. Until the next crisis!

Suzanne G. (Kaleidoscope epilogue and first chapter) 

Most of the comments concerned the prologue. Brandon is not a sympathetic character as written More detail needs to be added about Brandon’s loneliness and his wish to change his life. He needs to be more human. There were also a couple of votes for ditching the prologue altogether. Thanks to everyone for the comments, you’ve given me a great deal to think about.

Susan S. 

Basically – well received – all mentioned about expanding it.

Kashmira S. (Valmiki chs. 10-11) 

The revised chapters 10 had most comments. The background story of Sage Valmiki needed expansion. Val’s interaction with Dadaji worked well. Chapter 11 was enjoyable.  As always, there were some suggestions to make small changes and some typos. Thank you all. 

Presenters for our next meeting on July 1st.

Jack F.

Bob K.

Susan S.

Amit T.

Kashmira S.

There is one spot open!

 The Last word:

“Fill your paper with the breathings of your heart.” – William Wordsworth

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
6/17/2025

The first word . . .

“Writing is an exploration. You start from nothing and learn as you go.” – E.L. Doctorow


Tuesday evening. . .

Eight writers attended the meeting. Six presented. 

Sue G. (Legion’s Mark Ch.2)

Some of the critique suggestions were to have JP react more to Ant’s tattoo moving from the back of his hand to his wrist, to have JP hope that Ant is still alive when he is taken via ambulance to the hospital, and to increase tension by focusing on JP’s  guilt of leaving Ant alone in the hotel room before the MD states Ant is dead. It was also suggested to show more of Ant’s behavioral changes in the hotel room prior to JP leaving to pickup food.

Larry S.

Larry F. Sommers, Brother’s Blood, Ch. 21–The main discussion was around Harold’s character: How greatly was he affected by his pre-existing disability? Why is he so fatalistic about his chances of survival? Can he become more capable and commanding, or offset his disability with some other ability that’s actually enhanced? And how can his thinking and philosophy develop in a more coherent way? There were good observations also about practical matters such as feeding the troops and how much info was shared about their mission. Great discussion. Thanks, everybody!

Jack F. (A Walk Upon the Water 2025)

Pushing the edge with some descriptions, but it seems the chapter was not too far over the top. I toned down the next chapter, where the kids regain the shore a bit. Then we go back to plan old exposition for a while as a relief from the intensity of a couple of chapters.

The ups and downs of intensity to me mirror teenage life when everything was massively important, until it wasn’t, and then things were maybe a bit boring. Until the next crisis!

Suzanne G. (Kaleidoscope epilogue and first chapter) 

Most of the comments concerned the prologue. Brandon is not a sympathetic character as written. More detail needs to be added about Brandon’s loneliness and his wish to change his life. He needs to be more human. There were also a couple of votes for ditching the prologue altogether. Thanks to everyone for the comments, you’ve given me a great deal to think about.

Susan S. 

Basically – well received – all mentioned about expanding it.

Kashmira S. (Valmiki chs. 10-11) 

The revised chapter 10 had most comments. The background story of Sage Valmiki needed expansion. Val’s interaction with Dadaji worked well. Chapter 11 was enjoyable.  As always, there were some suggestions to make small changes and some typos. Thank you all. 

Presenters for our next meeting on July 1st.

Jack F.

Bob K.

Susan S.

Amit T.

Kashmira S.

There is one spot open!

 The Last word:

“Fill your paper with the breathings of your heart.” – William Wordsworth