Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Tuesdays With Story

June 2, 2026

First Word…

“In the end we tell stories because we must. And the real source of that must isn’t talent or knowledge or the authenticity that derives from research and lived experience. It’s mystery. What we don’t understand is what beckons to us.”

– Richard Russo

Tuesday evening…

Seven TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, four of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Kashmira S. – Kashmira submitted chapter 5-8 of the Surya story. The scene when Surya overhears boatmen needs to be tweaked. He can’t hear why underwater! In one day too many events happen and it doesn’t seem possible. Other than that, the chapters were well received. 

Mike A.– Doppelganger. This was only the beginning rough draft of a short story. But I received some very helpful comments. The opening needs more of a sense of place. Is it a large city or small town. Why does the Farmer seem so out of place? I need more details of the diner where Jeff works as well. And the biggest question is, why were there no news stories about the supposed murder? No investigation? Thanks for all of your comments and suggestions! Mike

Sue G. – Betrayal of Sabathea, Ch. 6. There were many good comments provided during the session. Some of the suggestions focused on how to add more realistic scientific information to enhance the story. There was a suggestion to change the punishments in the classroom to be more Sabathean based. There was also a comment regarding examples of how to avoid narration echoes in the chapter.

Bob K. – Say What You Want, Ch. 4. Along with the encouraging comments came some interesting questions. Namely: is Mead an HR person or a department head? Also, the interview that takes place between Mead and the visiting nimrod was opaque to some. One suggestion was to give additional detail relating to the personal appearance of the characters as well as to their actions. Thanks to all.

Amit T. – Eternal Moments. The poem was well received by all.  The feedback was very inspiring and it was suggested I try to publish it.

Here’s who’s up on June 16…

Bob K.

Kashmira S.

Sue G.

Larry F. S.

Susan S.

We only have five pieces scheduled for June 16, so we could accommodate one more.  One slot available to the first taker.

Next Word…

“The loneliness of writing is that you baffle your friends and change the lives of strangers.”

– Richard Powers

Grace Paley on Storytelling…

“A lot of them begin with a sentence—they all begin with language. It sounds dopey to say that, but it’s true. Very often one sentence is absolutely resonant. A story can begin with someone speaking. “I was popular in certain circles,” for example; an aunt of mine said that, and it hung around in my head for a long time. Eventually I wrote a story, “Goodbye and Good Luck,” that began with that line, though it had nothing to do with my aunt. Another example: “There were two husbands disappointed by eggs,” which is the first sentence of “The Used-Boy Raisers.” I was at the house of a friend of mine, thirty-five years ago, and there were her two husbands complaining about the eggs. It was just right—so I went home and began the story, though I didn’t finish it for months. I’m almost invariably stuck after one page or one paragraph—at which point I have to begin thinking about what the story could possibly be about. I begin by writing paragraphs that don’t have an immediate relation to a plot. The sound of the story comes first.” 

– Paris Review, Art of Fiction, no. 131

Last Word…

“Books remember all the things you cannot contain.”

– Elizabeth McCracken

Tuesdays with Story April 21, 2026

The first word . . .

“There are three rules for writing a novel. Unfortunately, no one knows what they are.” — W. Somerset Maugham

Tuesday Evening . . .

Four group members read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Sue G. Betrayal of Sabathea, Ch. 2 and Ch. 3: The critiques for chapters 2 and 3 were very favorable. For chapter 2, it was suggested to tighten up the speech and maybe to have Mr. Schultz appear earlier in the chapter. For chapter 3, there was a suggestion to remove the first sentence of the chapter, and to remove the sentence at the end about how the trip would affect his parents because it’s an echo of what his parents just said to each other.

Jack F. A Walk Upon the Water, Ch. 61. No comment summary received.

Larry F. S,The Golden Thread, Ch. 1-2:This foray into narrative nonfiction as a denominational illumination project met with interest. Kashmira said she found it interesting from a viewpoint completely outside Western religious culture, so I think that’s good. Jack hankers for more depth and detail than this project will be likely to provide. Sue felt there were opportunities for explaining the tradition more fully by answering a seeker’s questions. Kashmira, not surprisingly, wanted more interiority from the author/narrator, and an answer to the question, “Why am I writing this book?” Thanks, everyone. Very helpful comments.

Kashmira S. Surya Book 1, Ch. 1-2: Kashmira submitted the first two chapters of her MG novel. There were a lot of questions about the events in the story and about the relationship dynamics. I needed consistency in spelling of names. All the comments are very helpful. Thank you. I will revise the chapters and resubmit them next time.  

Who’s up next . . .  

Here’s who’s up on May 5th:

Jack F.

Kashmira S.

Larry F. S.

Sue G.

Susan S.

For the good of the order . . .

Kashmira will be the editor for the May 2026 newsletters.

For the fun of it . . .

“I’m writing a book. I’ve got the page numbers done.” — Steven Wright

The last word . . . “There is nothing to writing. All you do is sit down at a typewriter and bleed.” — Ernest Hemingway


Tuesdays with Story April 7, 2026

The first word . . .

“The road to hell is paved with adverbs.” – Stephen King

Tuesday Evening . . .

Five group members read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Jack F. (A Walk Upon the Water, Ch. 60)  Divergent options as to the third to last chapter. I took notes during the discussion and will do some rewriting.  Have two other chapters to revise as well, plan presenting two weeks, so much on my plate.

Susan S. (2 poems + Letters to My Children) Generally positive feedback. Some suggestions for clarifying word choice in “April in Paris”. Acknowledged the intensity of the personal essay (Note: as a variation on a memoir, it includes uncomfortable events – but life often does.)

Sue G. (The Betrayal of Sabathea, Ch. 1) Overall, the critique was very favorable. There was a consensus that the opening section needs some revision, moving some of the high impact paragraphs to the first page or two to create a better hook for the reader.

Bob K.  (Say What You Want, Ch. 1)  The general reaction is that this rewrite of chapter one is the most fully-realized and compelling yet. Also, a few remarks about the jokes that appear now and then. As for questions, there are many. Such as: Who is this character named Melinda? Is she a prostitute, or what? Does money even exist in this version of the future? Thanks to all for the great suggestions,

Mike A. (“January 1963 or 4”) This short piece was well received by everyone. I was given great suggestions for editing and perhaps expanding the piece. Thanks everyone!

Who’s up next . . .  

Here’s who’s up on April 21:

Sue G

Jack F

Larry S

For the good of the order . . .

Three slots are available for April 21st, if anyone wants them.

We need a volunteer for the May 2026 newsletters.

For the fun of it . . .

Carrie by Stephen King was rejected by 30 publishers. “We are not interested in science fiction which deals with negative utopias. They do not sell,” one letter said. It was finally published in 1974. When the paperback version was released a year later, it sold over a million copies in 12 months.

The last word . . .

“You fail only if you stop writing.” — Ray Bradbury

Writer’s  Newsletter

Tuesdays With Story

March 17, 2026

First Word…

 

“It is a magical thing for a handful of words, artfully arranged, to stop time. To conjure a place, a person, a situation, in all its specificity and dimensions. To affect us and alter us, as profoundly as real people and things do.”

– Jhumpa Lahiri

Tuesday evening…

Six TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, five of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Kashmira – Kashmira submitted three picture book manuscripts. Everyone liked “Beach Friends”. Jack liked “What’s that in the Dal”. Sue suggested I explain what dal is somewhere in the manuscript. “Library on the Landing” was a little confusing. Maybe illustrations will complete the story? Thank you all.

Susan – Colorado Packers. Positive feedback including developing it into a longer play (if given the opportunity). I just found out that this version was accepted by Broom Street Theater as part of their June production.

Jack- A Walk Upon the Water, Ch. 59. Just two suggestions, both of them on 

point.  One descriptive issue that needs work and the other poor wording. As crazy as the chapter is, from my point of view, the group seemed to find it fitting.  

Sue – The Dill Pickle War, Part II. Overall, the critiques were very positive and there were several suggestions regarding storylines for the next book in the series. 

Larry – Hard Feelings, Ch. 29-36. In the opening scenes, there could be more development of Harold’s feelings about the possibility of getting killed in a pretend war, and the sergeant/referee at the bridge is impossibly nice. The climactic scene of confrontation between Harold and Jag in the upstairs bedroom needs to be much stronger, fuller, better developed. The first version is just a place-holder, too sketchy.  And at least one person felt the book ends on an intolerable cliffhanger, and now she’ll have to buy the sequel. Right on target, everybody. Thanks. 

Here’s who’s up on March 17…

Jack F

Susan S

Kashmira S

Mike A

Bob K

Next Word…

We are what we imagine. Our very existence consists in our imagination of ourselves. Our best destiny is to imagine, at least, completely, who and what, and that we are. The greatest tragedy that can befall us is to go unimagined.

– N. Scott Momaday

For the Good of the Order…

March 31 is the Fifth Tuesday of the month. Accordingly, we will have our typical Fifth Tuesday social gathering at 7:00 pm at my house. Just food and light conversation–no writing assignments! PLEASE LET ME KNOW AS SOON AS POSSIBLE WHETHER OR NOT YOU WILL ATTEND.

We will provide the usual paper plates, cups, napkins, cutlery. Plus wine, beer, water, and Crystal Light Raspberry Lemonade (AKA  Pink Juice). Plus pulled pork sandwiches.

Please come and bring a salad, dessert, or side. 

If you favor a particular beverage that we’re not providing, feel free to bring it with you. If you are vegetarian or vegan, let me know and we’ll accommodate that in a mutually agreeable way.

REMEMBER:  RSVP sooner rather than later. 

Cheers,

Lar

Last Word…

“The very reason I write is so that I might not sleepwalk through my entire life.”

– Zadie Smith

Writer’s  Newsletter

Tuesdays With Story

March 3, 2026

First Word…

 

“To learn which questions are unanswerable, and not to answer them: this skill is most needful in times of stress and darkness.”

– Ursula K. Le Guin

Tuesday evening…

Nine TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, six of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:

Kashmira S. – Veena’s Story, Ch. 42-45: Kashmira submitted the last chapters of Veena’s story. The chapters were well received but the ending needed some work. The title of the book is still not clear. Something to decide later? Thank you all for reading Veena’s story.

Jack F. – A Walk Upon the Water, Ch. 57, 58: No runaway freight trains allowed, especially pre-

verbal ones.  Other than that, readers seemed to enjoy the story, including me.  Have not had time 

to look at the emailed and printed comments yet.

Sue G. – The Dill Pickle War, first half: Show more frustration/arguing when Emily is teaching Sparkle and Becky to embroider. This will increase the conflict in the piece. Have Emily cheer them on, but show her doubts as she thinks about if this will work. Reveal Emily as a leader.

Larry F. S. – Brother’s Blood, Ch. 27-28:  Some of Harold’s pre-Army interests (poetry, math, chemistry) could somehow be woven into his Army experience. There are places where more detail and depth could be added, such as the platoon’s discussion, over shoe-shining, of the upcoming Louisiana Maneuvers. Jag’s exact viewpoint on his Japanese house-servants needs to be made clearer. And Landerud’s jumping back and forth between the Navy and Pan Am does not seem credible. Thanks to all for insightful comments.

Suzanne G. – The Project. Everyone enjoyed my heartfelt confession in The Project. A few excellent improvements were suggested. Thanks to everyone. I appreciate all of your suggestions.

Bob K. – Whistling in the Dark. Reactions were split. On one hand, there was an appreciation of the unsettling nature of the story as well as the temperament of the people renting the first floor of the house. On the other, there were questions about the ghostly presence in the basement. A few comments suggested that the opening is wobbly and needs shoring up. Thanks for all the thoughtful comments.

Here’s who’s up on March 17…

Kashmira S.

Jack F.

Susan S.

Larry F. S.

Susan G.

Next Word…

“The nature of good fiction is that it dwells in ambiguity.”

– E. L. Doctorow

George Saunders on Writing…

“We often think that the empathetic function in fiction is accomplished via the writer’s relation to his characters, but it’s also accomplished via the writer’s relation to his reader. You make a rarefied place (rarefied in language, in form; perfected in many inarticulable beauties—the way two scenes abut; a certain formal device that self-escalates; the perfect place at which a chapter cuts off); and then welcome the reader in. She can’t believe that you believe in her that much; that you are so confident that the subtle nuances of the place will speak to her; she is flattered. And they do speak to her. This mode of revision, then, is ultimately about imagining that your reader is as humane, bright, witty, experienced, and well-intentioned as you, and that, to communicate intimately with her, you have to maintain the state, through revision, of generously imagining her. You revise your reader up, in your imagination, with every pass. You keep saying to yourself: ‘No, she’s smarter than that. Don’t dishonor her with that lazy prose or that easy notion.’ And in revising your reader up, you revise yourself up too.”

– excerpted from Big Other

Last Word…

“Storytelling reveals meaning without committing the error of defining it.”

– Hannah Arendt

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
Feb 17, 2026

The first word . . .

“The characters make their own plot. The dimensions of the characters determine the action of the novel.” Harper Lee

“Fantasy deals with things that are not and cannot be. Science Fiction deals with things that can be, that someday may be.” Frederick Brown

Eight writers met, in person and via Zoom. The following six presented work. 

Tuesday Evening . . .

Susan S (Grief and Guilt)

Favorable comments overall, with suggestions about deleting the first few paragraphs and resequencing others for greater impact.

Mike A (What Remains)

I received some really great feedback on this piece. I need to do some more research on the urgency of Angie’s condition. All I’ve gone with so far was from a friend whose girlfriend had to wait until the next day, and the clinic was two hours away and fronted by protesters when they got there. Angie and Roger also need discharge instructions! That’s a great point. A few of you even found some words I can delete. I agree with most of them. Thanks for all your comments and encouragement!

Jack F (A Walk Upon the Water Chaps 56)

I was surprised at the warm reception of last night’s chapter.  The cutting it to the bone left it feel as much poetry as prose, but the group actually liked that.  The theme of the kids becoming a crew and investing in Lester’s story in practicing for and making this trip to the bootlegger’s cave also seems to have come through.  Sean, our narrator, remains somewhat unsure of himself, but he is still a leader of a coalition of equals, all of whom realize the danger they have found themselves in. As Lester was dragged away from his shaggy hermit life, Sean is evolving into a better version of himself.  Many thanks to my readers.

Larry S (Brother’s Blood Chap 23-24)

Readers need a bit more context on why joining the National Guard was tantamount to joining the Army.  It would be good if Harold showed some consciousness of the European war unfolding as he and Grady were enlisting. The narrative seems to get bogged down a bit in details of basic training. Thanks as usual, good comments.

Sue G (Sparkle Industries)

The comments regarding the submission were good. Some suggestions were to have Snake inspect the clothing to see if they would be good enough to sell at their stores, to have the girls discuss the time commitment it would take to make the clothing and if it would be worth going forward with the business, and to have the grandparents state they will assist them financially rather than saying it would be a loan.

Kashmira S (Veena’s Story Chaps 38-41)

Kashmira submitted chapters 38-41 of Veena’s Story. They were well received. One of the suggestions was to move a part of the story around. Other than that, the story is moving at a good pace and Veena’s growth is evident. Everyone agreed that the title, Journey to Swaraj needs to be changed. Any suggestions? Thank you all. 

Who’s up next . . .  

Suzanne G.

Larry S.

Sue G.

Kashmira S.

Jack F.

Bob K.

For the good of the order . . . 

We have no editor scheduled for March. If someone would like to volunteer, they can contact Larry S. Otherwise we will offer it again during the March 3 meeting.

The last word . . .

“Let’s get one thing clear right now. There is no Idea Dump, no Story Central, no Island of the Buried Bestsellers. Good story ideas seem to come quite literally from nowhere, sailing at you right out of the empty sky: two previously unrelated ideas come together and make something new under the sun. Your job isn’t to find those ideas but to recognize them when they show up.” Stephen King

And for the fun of it . . .

Actual analogies used by high school students in English essays:

  1. When she tried to sing, it sounded like a walrus giving birth to farm equipment.
  • Her eyes twinkled, like the moustache of a man with a cold.
  • She was like magnet: attractive from the back, repulsive from the front,
  • The ballerina rose gracefully en pointe and extended one slender leg behind her, like a dog at a fire hydrant.
  • She grew on him like she was a colony of E. Coli and he was room temperature Canadian beef.
  • She had him like a toenail stuck in a shag carpet.
  • The lamp just sat there, like an inanimate object.

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
Feb 3, 2026

The first word . . .

“I write entirely to find out what I’m looking at, what I see and what it means. What I want and what I fear.” Joan Didion

“Writing is a job, a talent, but it’s also a place to go in your head.” Ann Patchett

Seven writers met, in person and via Zoom. The following six presented work. 

Tuesday Evening . . .

Susan S (Bienvenue a Nice)

Positive feedback with only a couple of minor edit suggestions.

Bob K (Call Me)

Call Me works as a slice-of-life piece, but less so as an actual story. Mainly because there is no real conflict or growth. Nothing at stake. Larry pointed out that the introduction of the arguing couple and the woman at the jewelry counter raises the tension which gives the situation greater depth. A small improvement. Another small improvement is that the relationship between the central characters is better defined than before. Thanks to all for the excellent comments.

Jack F (A Walk Upon the Water Chaps 54-55)

We got Lester into a suit and Skip into a handpainted tie.  Readers seemed to appreciate the change in Lester and found it believable. These were slight chapters, move the story ahead chapters, and I received multiple typo corrections.

Larry S (Brother’s Blood Chap 22-23)

No detailed report. All comments were considered and the necessary changes to the manuscript were made accordingly,

Sue G (A Sparkle in the Swamp 2nd half)

Overall, the critiques were positive. There were some rephrasing suggestions to tighten up the dialogue. Also, several people thought it would be good to show Marcus smiling, winking, etc at Emily, causing her to misinterpret these behaviors.

Kashmira S (Veena’s Story Chaps 34-37)

Kashmira submitted chapter 34-37 of Veena’s story. The historical part of the story comes out well. Sardar being arrested and jailed and how it encourages people needs to be reworked to make it clear. Dadima’s character is well developed throughout the story and her death scene was moving. Veena’s concerns and participation in the freedom fight is believable. Overall, good chapters.

Who’s up next . . .  

Susan S.

Larry S.

Sue G.

Kashmira S.

Jack F.

Mike A.

For the good of the order . . . 

If you’re looking for a small, but excellent writer’s conference try The Lakefly Writer’s Conference. It will be held in Oshkosh on May 1-2, 2026

The last word . . .

“When a reader puts a story aside because it ‘got boring,’ the boredom arose because the writer grew enchanted with his powers of description and lost sight of his priority, which is to keep the ball rolling.” Stephen King

And for the fun of it . . .

“Many people hear voices when there is no one there. Some of them are called ‘mad” and are shut up in rooms where they stare at the walls all day. Others are called ‘writers’ and do pretty much the same thing.” Ray Bradbury

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
1/20/2026

The first word . . .

“I love deadlines. I love the whooshing noise they make as they go by.”

-Douglas Adams

Tuesday evening. . .

8 writers attended the meeting. 3 presented. 


Larry S, Brother’s Blood, 7-9: The reader needs more clarity on how single-wing football differs from the modern game. It would be good to work in some earlier references to the rise of Hitler and other totalitarian rulers. Harold’s voice is not quite immature enough in viewpoint narrative sections. How sympathetic a character is Taylor meant to be? And what the heck is Harold doing working with Jag at the mine? Good points all. Thanks.

Susan G: A Sparkle in the Swamp: The critiques were overall positive. One suggestion was to delete how long the trip was from the airstrip to Swamp Rat Bayou Tours and to describe the scenery as they drive there. Another person questioned why Emily and Becky left their luggage unsupervised next to Sparkle as she repacked her luggage. 

Jack F. A Tested Mooring: The two chapters were generally well received but exactly how the rope and mooring worked to injure Sean was unclear.  I’d reread it myself before sending it off, but if the reader can’t easily get it, I need to rewrite. 

Susan had concerns about the lack of Muriel  calling Sean’s parents to tell then he nearly killed himself, but that was the way it was.  Our super-protectiveness of children is not something I grew up with. I recall my friend Joel Garreau scuba diving, no training, no certification, no tank testing, so he could steal lobsters from pots in high school.  It was a different world for us as kids and we were lucky to survive!

You might enjoy his books, especially The Nine Nations of North America and Edge City.  Believe he now has seven out.

J

Presenters for our next meeting on February 3th

Larry S.

Susan S.

Jack F.

Sue G.

Bob K.

Kashmira S.

Writing Tips:

I found a great article dated 1/2/2026 posted on the Hidden Gems Website by Roland Hulme, aka Ginger, called How and When to Use Humor in Your Writing (https://www.hiddengemsbooks.com/how-and-when-to-use-humor-in-your-writing/).

The article description states:  In today’s article, Ginger goes into detail as to why humor works in the first place, where it belongs in your writing, and how any author can learn to use it effectively without turning their novel into a comedy. From subtle character quirks to well-timed irony and exaggeration, humor can strengthen a story rather than undermine it. Regardless of genre, a few well-placed laughs may be the missing ingredient that makes readers remember your book and come back for more.

The Last word:

“The road to hell is paved with adverbs.”

—Stephen King

Writer’s Mail

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays with Story
12/16/2025

The first word . . .

My childhood and youth were passed in great poverty. I received almost no education for want of means… The first made me a tramp and sent me out tramping the whole of India quite early, and the second made me a dreamer all my life.

Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay (Bengali poet and author)

Tuesday evening. . .

7 writers attended the meeting. 5 presented. 


Larry S, Brother’s Blood, Ch. 6–There was considerable discussion about the ethics and family dynamics of Jag’s consumption of steaks when the others had none. Also a feeling that maybe we need to know a bit more about Pop. Does he have time for contemplation on his long walks to and from work, or does he just march forward? Good questions, I don’t know if I have answers, but they’re worth considering. Thanks, everybody.

SG: The critiques were overall positive. One suggestion was not to have Red and Oden make-up as quickly as they did, and to have them start to bicker again. Then, have Aunt Ally and Mackenzie intervene, stopping the feud in its tracks. Another suggestion was to have the group disbelieve BO’s story about killing the cougar, then have BO throw the knife and have it embed into a nearby log.

Jack F. The two chapters were well received. The group seemed to like the usual description of the coast of Maine as seen from a boat and the interaction of the two maturing teenagers.  We are finally getting near the end, but first Sean, who has a knack for disas ter, has to suffer another one and Lester’s dips into memories to set up a future chapter when the old man makes a big personal step, just as the kids are making small ones.

Bob K, A Denim Shirt (short story). There were a few suggestions for improvement. The person at the wheel of the boat in the opening is not named until well into the story. He should be given a name earlier. Abigail’s name is spelled two different ways. (One being a typo). How knowledgeable is Doug (given the unique circumstances) in setting a dislocated shoulder? Thanks for all the thoughtful suggestions.

Kashmira S. (Veena’s Story Ch.26-29)–The critique was mostly positive. Nimu Daku reminded readers of Robin Hood. One choice of was questioned. Suggestion was to use “high alert” instead of “intriguing.” Due to cultural as well as specific circumstances surrounding India’s struggle for independence, “cultural suspension” was mentioned. Thank you all. 

Please note that we won’t have a meeting on January 6th.

Presenters for our next meeting on January 20th

Larry S.

Suzanne G.

Jack F.

Kashmira S.

We still have two slots open, if anybody wants them.

The Last word:

“Work hard in silence, let your success be your noise.”

— Anonymous

Writer’s Mail

Tuesdays With Story Newsletter

for

November 18 Meeting

The first word…

“When you make music or write or create, it’s really your job to have mind-blowing, irresponsible, condomless sex with whatever idea it is you’re writing about at the time.”
–Lady Gaga

That concept kind of intimidates me. And causes me to put down my pen. But it made me laugh. —Mike

Tuesday evening…

Seven writers attended Tuesday’s meeting. Five of them had stories to present and be critiqued. Here are their summaries of their feedback:

Suzanne G. Suddenly! (short story) There was agreement that this short story has a lot of possibilities, including a potential novel. There does need to be more character development of Stuart. Thanks to all for the feedback. You’ve given me a lot to think about!

Suzanne

Jack F. A Walk Upon the Water. Lots of discussion again.  Seems we need some mention of lobstering earlier, so I’ll go back and look and see what is currently in the text.  That Alvin is usually not around, being on the boat for long periods, also needs to be established. 

Kashmira S. Veena’s Story Kashmira submitted chapters 18-21 of her historical YA novel. The tension throughout the chapters work and Veena’s shaky faith in Mayur is done well. Maybe create more tension by police arriving after Veena, Mayur and the driver get to the haveli? A sentence needed to be uttered by Mr. Graham instead by Mrs. Graham. Mahatma’s Gandhi’s ashram should be mentioned earlier in the story so the readers know that. Thank you all for your comments and suggestions. 

Sue G. A Sparkle in the Dark Some of the commenters had suggested tightening the walk to make it more dramatic. Possibly making it more of a survival situation, and then have the ghost save them. When the picture of the person saving them is taken, show the girls are shocked that he wasn’t there.

Larry F.  Brother’s Blood, Ch. 1-4: There was general agreement these chapters were better than the previous submission because there was a more consistent focus on the two brothers. A lively discussion ensued as to the best way to start the story, with strong points made in favor of framing the earlier material with either the coal mine scene or the start of WWII. All agreed that Harold’s and Jag’s voices are too adult for the kids that they are. Gee, Wally, guess I’ll have to do something about that! Thanks for your keen input, everybody.

Presenting for December 2nd

Kashmira S

Jack F

Larry S

Sue G

It’s a short list here, so if anyone wants to submit, this is your chance.

For the Good of the Order:

From Larry S.

Hi, all–

Last night (November 18) I made a heartfelt appeal for standard manuscript formatting in our submissions. We have not had any rules about this in our group except not to exceed approximately 20 pages per submission (which is flexible anyhow). By disposition, I am the last person to wish to impose a  new rule. I don’t have a high regard for rules. So look on this as simply a friendly request which, if you honor it, will make my life easier. 

Standard manuscript format can be found at https://www.shunn.net/format/story/1/. This guide is simple, straightforward, brief, and exhaustive. It applies to all prose fiction or non-academic nonfiction. It does not apply to screenplays, but none of us are submitting screenplays. If you want to do a screenplay, I can advise you.

To make me happy, you need not worry about whole-document externalities like title page and headers/footers. I’m just concerned about how the actual pages of prose are laid out. 

My concerns, specifically, are:

Type size: If it’s less than 12 points, even if it’s 11 or 11.5, it’s harder for me to read. With my compromised eyesight, even 12 is demanding.

Double spacing is standard. If you submit single-spaced, or 1.5 spaced, it’s harder for me to read and annotate. And, obviously, it makes nonsense of our 20-page limit.

Extra space between paragraphs may be a default setting on your Word doc, but you can change that default by going to Format…Paragraph…Spacing…  Extra space between paragraphs is not only nonstandard per the website shown above, it also hashes up the page count and makes it more difficult to discern whether your chapter is broken into sections.

It is not a requirement of this cozy little club to use standard formatting, but it would gratify me if you would do so. Also, if you intend ever to submit anything, you might as well have it in standard format; otherwise you’ll have to convert it anyway.

Cheers,

Lar

Last Word(s)…

“Words do not express thoughts very well. They always become a little different immediately after they are expressed, a little distorted, a little foolish.”
—Hermann Hesse

“I am irritated by my own writing. I am like a violinist whose ear is true, but whose fingers refuse to reproduce precisely the sound he hears within.”
—Gustave Flaubert