Tuesdays With Story Newsletter
for
November 18 Meeting
The first word…
“When you make music or write or create, it’s really your job to have mind-blowing, irresponsible, condomless sex with whatever idea it is you’re writing about at the time.”
–Lady Gaga
That concept kind of intimidates me. And causes me to put down my pen. But it made me laugh. —Mike
Tuesday evening…
Seven writers attended Tuesday’s meeting. Five of them had stories to present and be critiqued. Here are their summaries of their feedback:
Suzanne G. Suddenly! (short story) There was agreement that this short story has a lot of possibilities, including a potential novel. There does need to be more character development of Stuart. Thanks to all for the feedback. You’ve given me a lot to think about!
Suzanne
Jack F. A Walk Upon the Water. Lots of discussion again. Seems we need some mention of lobstering earlier, so I’ll go back and look and see what is currently in the text. That Alvin is usually not around, being on the boat for long periods, also needs to be established.
Kashmira S. Veena’s Story Kashmira submitted chapters 18-21 of her historical YA novel. The tension throughout the chapters work and Veena’s shaky faith in Mayur is done well. Maybe create more tension by police arriving after Veena, Mayur and the driver get to the haveli? A sentence needed to be uttered by Mr. Graham instead by Mrs. Graham. Mahatma’s Gandhi’s ashram should be mentioned earlier in the story so the readers know that. Thank you all for your comments and suggestions.
Sue G. A Sparkle in the Dark Some of the commenters had suggested tightening the walk to make it more dramatic. Possibly making it more of a survival situation, and then have the ghost save them. When the picture of the person saving them is taken, show the girls are shocked that he wasn’t there.
Larry F. Brother’s Blood, Ch. 1-4: There was general agreement these chapters were better than the previous submission because there was a more consistent focus on the two brothers. A lively discussion ensued as to the best way to start the story, with strong points made in favor of framing the earlier material with either the coal mine scene or the start of WWII. All agreed that Harold’s and Jag’s voices are too adult for the kids that they are. Gee, Wally, guess I’ll have to do something about that! Thanks for your keen input, everybody.
Presenting for December 2nd
Kashmira S
Jack F
Larry S
Sue G
It’s a short list here, so if anyone wants to submit, this is your chance.
For the Good of the Order:
From Larry S.
Hi, all–
Last night (November 18) I made a heartfelt appeal for standard manuscript formatting in our submissions. We have not had any rules about this in our group except not to exceed approximately 20 pages per submission (which is flexible anyhow). By disposition, I am the last person to wish to impose a new rule. I don’t have a high regard for rules. So look on this as simply a friendly request which, if you honor it, will make my life easier.
Standard manuscript format can be found at https://www.shunn.net/format/story/1/. This guide is simple, straightforward, brief, and exhaustive. It applies to all prose fiction or non-academic nonfiction. It does not apply to screenplays, but none of us are submitting screenplays. If you want to do a screenplay, I can advise you.
To make me happy, you need not worry about whole-document externalities like title page and headers/footers. I’m just concerned about how the actual pages of prose are laid out.
My concerns, specifically, are:
Type size: If it’s less than 12 points, even if it’s 11 or 11.5, it’s harder for me to read. With my compromised eyesight, even 12 is demanding.
Double spacing is standard. If you submit single-spaced, or 1.5 spaced, it’s harder for me to read and annotate. And, obviously, it makes nonsense of our 20-page limit.
Extra space between paragraphs may be a default setting on your Word doc, but you can change that default by going to Format…Paragraph…Spacing… Extra space between paragraphs is not only nonstandard per the website shown above, it also hashes up the page count and makes it more difficult to discern whether your chapter is broken into sections.
It is not a requirement of this cozy little club to use standard formatting, but it would gratify me if you would do so. Also, if you intend ever to submit anything, you might as well have it in standard format; otherwise you’ll have to convert it anyway.
Cheers,
Lar
Last Word(s)…
“Words do not express thoughts very well. They always become a little different immediately after they are expressed, a little distorted, a little foolish.”
—Hermann Hesse
“I am irritated by my own writing. I am like a violinist whose ear is true, but whose fingers refuse to reproduce precisely the sound he hears within.”
—Gustave Flaubert
Leave a Reply