Writer’s Mail
Tuesdays with Story
12/16/2025
The first word . . .
My childhood and youth were passed in great poverty. I received almost no education for want of means… The first made me a tramp and sent me out tramping the whole of India quite early, and the second made me a dreamer all my life.
Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay (Bengali poet and author)
Tuesday evening. . .
7 writers attended the meeting. 5 presented.
Larry S, Brother’s Blood, Ch. 6–There was considerable discussion about the ethics and family dynamics of Jag’s consumption of steaks when the others had none. Also a feeling that maybe we need to know a bit more about Pop. Does he have time for contemplation on his long walks to and from work, or does he just march forward? Good questions, I don’t know if I have answers, but they’re worth considering. Thanks, everybody.
SG: The critiques were overall positive. One suggestion was not to have Red and Oden make-up as quickly as they did, and to have them start to bicker again. Then, have Aunt Ally and Mackenzie intervene, stopping the feud in its tracks. Another suggestion was to have the group disbelieve BO’s story about killing the cougar, then have BO throw the knife and have it embed into a nearby log.
Jack F. The two chapters were well received. The group seemed to like the usual description of the coast of Maine as seen from a boat and the interaction of the two maturing teenagers. We are finally getting near the end, but first Sean, who has a knack for disas ter, has to suffer another one and Lester’s dips into memories to set up a future chapter when the old man makes a big personal step, just as the kids are making small ones.
Bob K, A Denim Shirt (short story). There were a few suggestions for improvement. The person at the wheel of the boat in the opening is not named until well into the story. He should be given a name earlier. Abigail’s name is spelled two different ways. (One being a typo). How knowledgeable is Doug (given the unique circumstances) in setting a dislocated shoulder? Thanks for all the thoughtful suggestions.
Kashmira S. (Veena’s Story Ch.26-29)–The critique was mostly positive. Nimu Daku reminded readers of Robin Hood. One choice of was questioned. Suggestion was to use “high alert” instead of “intriguing.” Due to cultural as well as specific circumstances surrounding India’s struggle for independence, “cultural suspension” was mentioned. Thank you all.
Please note that we won’t have a meeting on January 6th.
Presenters for our next meeting on January 20th
Larry S.
Suzanne G.
Jack F.
Kashmira S.
We still have two slots open, if anybody wants them.
The Last word:
Leave a Reply