Tuesdays with Story
December 5, 2023
The first word . . .
“Truth is stranger than fiction but it is because fiction is obliged to stick to possibilities; truth isn’t.” Mark Twain
Tuesday Evening . . .
Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)
Some excellent suggestions were made for the three chapters reviewed. First and foremost was the need to identify that June is the narrator and not a reference to the month of June. Needless to say, this caused some confusion. Also pointed out was the need for reorganizing some of the sentences and paragraphs, as well as trimming certain descriptions. The suggestion for increased internal thought was spot-on and greatly appreciated. Thank you all for taking the time to review!
Mike A. (Backroads, Chapters 21-22)
Mike A., Backroads Chapters 21-22, received favorable reviews all around. There was some confusion about Red being the bank robber and whether Stevens had hired him, or he was robbing it on his own (which he was). I also need to use more active verbs instead of passive. And I just looked up “past simple vs past progressive” in reference to “He wore” (for instance) versus “He was wearing.” I hadn’t thought about there being words to define those forms, but see that those are forms I need to keep in mind. I’m learning grammar! Thanks everyone.
Kashmira S. (Soaring High, Landing Home)
Kashmira S. submitted two picture book manuscripts. The age group they are intended for is 4-8.
There was a suggestion to use shapes, geometry to describe alphabets.
To use words that signal vertical trajectory, like crawling, jumping.
To use more metaphor with wings earlier in the story.
Multiple people like what parents had to say and mention of the saffron milk.
Thank you all.
Bob K. (Say What You Want, Chapter 1)
Several comments focused on the sense of intrigue operating in the narrative as well as the underlying humor. There were a few mentions regarding Lennie’s contract with Tom, the unhoused biochemical engineer – hope that he should show up later in the story, and also about how uncomfortable it is coming face to face with abject poverty. Some questions came about Melinda’s identity, as well as why Lennie feels disturbed around her.
Suzanne G. (Kaleidoscope, Chapters 17-18)
The consensus was that the scene with the support group was handled well. There should be a scene wrapping up Brandon connecting with his long-lost dad and brother. A couple of “stage movements” were missed and should be added. Two comments were made regarding the knife and making sure it reappears at some point in the future. Thanks to all for the feedback. I appreciate it.
Larry S. (Brother’s Blood, Chapter 4)
Larry S., Brother’s Blood Ch. 4–All agreed it is well-written. Kashmira wanted more indication of Jag’s emotions on leaving the injured Hal behind. There was some discussion of whether the dollar amount of Jag’s bank account was well-chosen, and of whether Jag would really leave a perfectly good suitcase behind in the washroom. Ann and Bob pointed out opportunities for more striking ambience at the railroad station (auditory) and the stationery store (visual). Great feedback as usual. Thanks, all.
Who’s up next . . .
Mike A.
Ann S.
Larry S.
Wendy B.
For the good of the order . . .
A HAT TRICK! Larry S. scored a triple victory last week when Kira Henscchel of HenschelHaus Publishing, Milwaukee, committed to publishing the middle-reader novel Izzy Strikes Gold! (41,000 words) and re-publishing the 19th-century historical novel Price of Passage. The third leg of the victory was simply becoming an author in the HenschelHaus catalog, recruiting Kira–a capable and helpful publisher–to the Larry S. Team. Yippee!
The last word . . .
“A book is made from a tree. It is an assemblage of flat, flexible parts (still called “leaves”) imprinted with dark pigmented squiggles. One glance at it and you hear the voice of another person, perhaps someone dead for thousands of years. Across the millennia, the author is speaking, clearly and silently, inside your head, directly to you. Writing is perhaps the greatest of human inventions, binding together people, citizens of different epochs, who never knew one another. Books break the shackles of time-proof that humans can work magic.” Carl Sagan
Leave a Reply