Writer’s Mail
Tuesdays with Story
6/17/2025
The first word . . .
“Writing is an exploration. You start from nothing and learn as you go.” – E.L. Doctorow
Tuesday evening. . .
Eight writers attended the meeting. Six presented.
Sue G. (Legion’s Mark Ch.2)
Some of the critique suggestions were to have JP react more to Ant’s tattoo moving from the back of his hand to his wrist, to have JP hope that Ant is still alive when he is taken via ambulance to the hospital, and to increase tension by focusing on JP’s guilt of leaving Ant alone in the hotel room before the MD states Ant is dead. It was also suggested to show more of Ant’s behavioral changes in the hotel room prior to JP leaving to pickup food.
Larry S.
Larry F. Sommers, Brother’s Blood, Ch. 21–The main discussion was around Harold’s character: How greatly was he affected by his pre-existing disability? Why is he so fatalistic about his chances of survival? Can he become more capable and commanding, or offset his disability with some other ability that’s actually enhanced? And how can his thinking and philosophy develop in a more coherent way? There were good observations also about practical matters such as feeding the troops and how much info was shared about their mission. Great discussion. Thanks, everybody!
Jack F. (A Walk Upon the Water 2025)
Pushing the edge with some descriptions, but it seems the chapter was not too far over the top. I toned down the next chapter, where the kids regain the shore a bit. Then we go back to plan old exposition for a while as a relief from the intensity of a couple of chapters.
The ups and downs of intensity to me mirror teenage life when everything was massively important, until it wasn’t, and then things were maybe a bit boring. Until the next crisis!
Suzanne G. (Kaleidoscope epilogue and first chapter)
Most of the comments concerned the prologue. Brandon is not a sympathetic character as written. More detail needs to be added about Brandon’s loneliness and his wish to change his life. He needs to be more human. There were also a couple of votes for ditching the prologue altogether. Thanks to everyone for the comments, you’ve given me a great deal to think about.
Susan S.
Basically – well received – all mentioned about expanding it.
Kashmira S. (Valmiki chs. 10-11)
The revised chapter 10 had most comments. The background story of Sage Valmiki needed expansion. Val’s interaction with Dadaji worked well. Chapter 11 was enjoyable. As always, there were some suggestions to make small changes and some typos. Thank you all.
Presenters for our next meeting on July 1st.
Jack F.
Bob K.
Susan S.
Amit T.
Kashmira S.
There is one spot open!
The Last word:
“Fill your paper with the breathings of your heart.” – William Wordsworth
Leave a Reply