March 5, 2024
First Word… “If you don’t have time to read, you don’t have the time (or the tools) to write. Simple as that.” —Stephen King
Which begs the question, what are you reading? I am spellbound with Attica Locke’s novel, Bluebird, Bluebird.
Announcements: Larry reported recent contacts with currently inactive members Mike A, Judy C, John S, and Paul W. All are doing well and send along their best regards to the group. Look for Mike, Judy, and maybe Paul to return to active participation soon. John is still extremely busy in the cow business.
Manuscript Discussion: Eight member writers and one guest gathered in person or by Zoom to discuss six submissions.
Larry F. S. Brother’s Blood, Ch. 9: Jack suggested the search plane’s recovery by crane ought to be mentioned as well as its launch by catapult and also gave some help on sharpening the tension between ROTC boys and regular Navy crew members. Suzanne pointed out that Peggy could easily be confused with Margaret, since Peggy is a short form or nickname for Margaret. There was general agreement that more conflict is needed. Thanks, everyone.
Jack F. Jesus Walked Into the IHOP. It is very helpful for me to get Amit and Kashima’s assessment of my work, unclouded by theological presumptions all Christians have. They seem to be enjoying the story as story, which is necessary for anyone to read the eventual full piece. They asked if Jesus visited India, as some Hindu tests make that suggestions. Very briefly I found the following.
A seminar was also organized under the aegis of Jagannath Gabeshana Parishad where eminent scholars like Dr Harekrushna Satapathy, Dr Siddheswer Mohapatra, Jagabandhu Padhi, Dr Debendra Dash and others deliberated over the Hindu religious texts which mentioned the activities of Jesus. Dr Trebst said 2,000 years ago Puri was a famous seat of learning and history has revealed that over the centuries religious leaders of various sects and cults had visited this holy shrine. It was most likely that Jesus had also visited this holy seat of learning, he said, though adding that it was a very difficult task to trace the history of his visit to Puri.
It appears I must do more research. Wendy and I have exchanged emails regarding her corrections and questions, all very helpful.
Amit T. INFTP
1. Weave in the theme of abandonment and chaos (British leaving) in Kedar’s chapter. 2. Tighten-up the paragraph pertaining to Mohan Kaka. 3. Use holy man instead of Sadhu 4. Kedar’s poem should also emphasize abandonment and sense of loss.
Thanks all for reading. Amit and Kashmira
Kashmira S. Kashmira submitted the first three chapters of her MG novel about agarias. Overall, it was well received. The name of the protagonist made people think it was a girl. There was a discussion about what a flock of flamingos are called. Also, many felt that more details about the setting, salt pan etc. would be nice to have. Thank you all for your comments and feedback.
Editor’s Note: According to Wikipedia, Agariya or Agarias translates as Salt Farmers. Kashmira, please correct if not correct.
Jaimie N. We took up a rewrite of chapter 7 of New York, After All. The group asked for a sense of how Lindyhop feels about her family’s living conditions when she is living in Carnegie Hall. It also needs to be clearer that she had been told by her family that her father died when she was five. The “four men” who are missing from the table should also probably be named. Thanks, all!
Wendy B. What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 13-14. Thoroughly enjoyed the well-deserved evisceration of June’s tracking of her father. Having fun writing something doesn’t count for much! The group is correct; it’s out of character for June, reads rather cutesy and contrived, and totally lacks tension. It’s great to get such invaluable feedback! That’s the big picture, too many smaller suggestions to mention. Thank you all:)
Next Up on March 19: Bob K, Suzanne G, Kashmira S and Amit T, Wendy B, and Jack F.
Last word… “We write to taste life twice, in the moment and in retrospect.” —Anais Nin
Leave a Reply