March 4, 2025
The first word . . .
“Exercise the writing muscle every day, even if it is only a letter, notes, a title list, a character sketch, a journal entry. Writers are like dancers, like athletes. Without that exercise, the muscles seize up.” Jane Yolen
Tuesday Evening . . .
Wendy B (What Blood Runs Through Me)
The chapters were well received, but as always, some excellent comments to enrich the piece. Word choices, a few typos to keep readers on their toes, needless repetition, And, of course, an old Derringer wouldn’t have a safety. Roughly just 40 more pages to go. Thank you all!
Suzanne G (Kaleidoscope rewrite of Chaps 10 & 11)
Most of the suggestions were for Chapter 10: the racist man seemed to be a bit of a caricature and should be reworked; the kiss at the end should evolve more and not have them slamming together; a scene with the coffee cake could be added; and last but not least—they need to lock up their bikes. In Chapter 11 the main comment was that Brandon should focus more on Carey’s needs and not his own. It would make Brandon a stronger character and emphasis his own growth. Thanks for all the comments. As always, they strengthen my work.
Jack F (A Walk Upon the Water Chaps 8-9)
Chapters seemed to be well received. Kashmira wanted to see a bit of work underway, way, more back and forth with crew, which I will look.
Larry S (Brother’s Blood Chap 17-18)
Margaret’s demise in the Pearl Harbor attack was a major downer for everyone, which in its own way validates the choice. There was a bit of confusion about the Flying Tigers, and several comments on the welter of different airplane names. Jag at last seems to be looking more like a human being, but it was noted that “foolish” was an inadequate way to describe his feelings on seeing the wrecked car. Thanks, everyone, for all the trenchant comments.
Mike A (Second Chance)
The feedback for this piece was short, but very helpful and encouraging. The time travel explanation worked and was acceptable to everyone. I need to clarify where Caroline is in the house near the beginning of the story. Same with Cab. Is he sitting or standing? This was also pointed out about the end of the story. Is Caroline in the boat when she shoots Cab? If it’s an action story, the placement of the characters needs to be more clear. Thanks everyone.
Kashmira S (The Saltmaker’s Son Chaps 14-17)
Overall, everyone liked the revised version. The addition of grandmother telling the story as well as Karna using his fingers etc for painting was nice. The main question was will the targeted readers understand the story’s themes? There was some grammar and some word choices were pointed out. Thanks everyone!
Who’s up next . . .
Wendy B.
Larry S.
Suzanne G.
Kashmira S.
Jack F.
For the good of the order . . .
If you’re looking for a small, but excellent writer’s conference try The Lakefly Writer’s Conference. It will be held in Oshkosh on May 2-3, 2025
The last word . . .
“There are secret opportunities hidden inside every failure.” Sophia Amoruso
And for the fun of it . . .
“Sometimes, if you aren’t sure about something, you just have to jump off the bridge and grow your wings on the way down.” Danielle Steele
Leave a Reply