February 4th, 2024
The First Word…
“The easy, conversational tone of good writing comes only on the eighth rewrite.”
Paul Graham
Seven of us attended Tuesday’s meeting. Five people presented work. They were:
Amit T., “Anna.”
Wendy B., “What Blood Runs Through Me.” Chapters 49-51
Kashmira S., “The Saltmaker’s Son.” Chapters 6-9
Suzanne G., “Kaleidoscope.” Chapters 32-33 and Epilogue
Jack F., “A Walk Upon the Water.” Chapters 3-5
Here are some of the comments about their work.
Suzanne G.
Kaleidoscope: Rewrite of Chapters 32, 33 and Epilogue
Everyone liked the last chapters though there were some things that needed clarification or added detail: Rattlesnake Man, his escape and capture were both skated over too quickly; the reader would want more on how Carey felt about this and how it affects his life beyond Rattlesnake Man’s death. The addition of Brandon’s family and the wedding was good, but there were too many people added at one time. More was needed about the family to give them all distinctive personalities. The conversation with Brandon’s dad and Carey worked well. As usual there were a few POV confusions and more than a few grammatical errors. The Oxford comma is not my friend! Thanks to all for your help and encouragement.
Kashmira S.
Kashmira submitted chapter 6-9 of The Saltmaker’s Son. There were spelling and grammar mistakes as well as too many “I” usage. There was also concerns about using poetic language and if it is right for this age group. Overall, the chapters were well-received. Karna is twelve and that age seems perfect for this coming of story. Thank you all for your comments.
Wendy B.
What Blood Runs Through Me, Chapters 49-51. Wendy Bialek. As the group was quick to point out, the primary issue with the chapters evolved around Darla’s intent in getting inside the cabin, and why Michael was so reluctant to go inside with her. It wasn’t his foreboding, or fear that unauthorized police records would be inside. No, he was afraid Darla had misplaced expectations of a rendezvous. Something needs to happen. Problem solved! Thanks, everyone:)
Presenting for our February 18 meeting:
Jack F.
Wendy B.
Kashmira S.
Larry F. S.
Amit T.
Kashmira’s Book Signing!
Here is the info about my April signing at the Mystery to Me bookstore. It is on Tuesday night and we don’t have a meeting so I’d love to see some friends there!
Livestream: https://www.crowdcast.io/c/im-from-here-too
https://www.eventbrite.com/e/livemtm-kashmira-sheth-tickets-1235104162799?aff=oddtdtcreator
Website: https://www.mysterytomebooks.com/kashmira-sheth
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/events/1669727313927906/
Some last words…
“I have never started a poem yet whose end I knew. Writing a poem is discovering.”
Robert Frost
This surprised me. Robert Frost’s poems always seem so perfectly planned and crafted, as if he knew all along where he was going, when in fact he didn’t really know. But it worked for him. John Updike, on the other hand, said that he can’t start writing a story unless he knows where it’s going to end. And that works for him. He also said that it took him three novels before he realized that it was the method he would always write with, and there was nothing wrong with it. So it seems that there is no right or wrong method to writing, so long as it gets done. Yes, I’m lecturing myself.
Book recommendation…
“Writing Fiction. A Guide to Narrative Craft,” by Janet Burroway.
This is, for me, the best book on writing I’ve seen. Burroway discusses the basics of writing, creative methods, styles, rewrites, and accepting criticism. The book is filled with short stories of various styles, and makes for good reading if you’re bored with instruction. I’ve had my copy, the third edition, for years and years, and still open it when I need some inspiration or instruction. I see that now it’s in the tenth edition.
Leave a Reply