Writer’s Mail
Tuesdays with Story
March 11, 2016
“The courage of the poet is to keep ajar the door that leads into madness.” – Christopher Morley
How to Critique poetry – Sent by Eva Mays – Thanks!!
by Chanti Niven
To kick this off, I put forward a few ideas and suggestions that will help you in the critique process. I chose the letter ‘I’ to do this to remind us all that poetry is subjective and so is a critique. What one person may love may leave another cold. I have posted a poem in a few different poetry forums and received rave reviews in some and have had my work ripped to shreds in others. Remember when you critique the work of others, always be constructive and positive. Rather than say something offensive and hurtful, say nothing at all. When you express how you feel about a person’s work, be careful to state ‘I feel…’ and ‘I think…’ rather than to say ‘This poem is…’ etc. When you do make these statements, always substantiate your words e.g. ‘I felt that this poem could have been more effectively rendered by…’ or ‘I would suggest that you…’ Always ask yourself the question ‘How have I added value with this critique?’ Critique should always add value. Your intention should never be to hurt the feelings of the poet. It should be to encourage, to educate and to inspire.
When you examine a poem you could use this checklist to help you to critique and provide constructive feedback.
| Insight | A poem will often give us insight into a person’s thoughts. What does this poem tell you about the poet? |
| Interpretation | What was your interpretation of the poem? What do you believe the poet meant for you to interpret? |
Read more at the full article here http://www.authorsden.com/visit/viewArticle.asp?id=16980
What’s Trending? Hot Themes in Kidlit and what we want to see
By Elizabeth Bird on January 1, 2015
Is there any more disparaging term than “trendy”?
It drips with disdain. To be trendy is to be of the moment rather than of all time. Little wonder authors and illustrators shy away from the label when at all possible. But on the flip side, the librarian who ignores trends might miss something along the way.
It is the mixed blessing and curse of the 21st-century children’s librarian that if you delve deep into the full spectrum of children’s books published in a single year, you will begin to spot unexpected trends. Trendwatching is a spectator sport in the best sense of the term. It can be fun to do. Travis Jonker, for example, has already noted the sheer number of whales taking up space on our shelves, as well as the plethora of picture books featuring photography. But it’s not all fun and games. There are trends and then there are monumental shifts in what is or isn’t being published. If nothing else, the We Need Diverse Books movement is giving us a new set of criteria with which to examine publishing years as a whole.
Read the full post in the School Library Journal here http://www.slj.com/2015/01/feature-articles/whats-trending-hot-themes-in-kidlit-and-what-we-want-to-see/
Who’s up next . . .
March 15: Lisa McDougal (chapters ???, Tebow Family Secret), Kashmira Sheth & Amit Trivedi (chapter, novel), Hannah Marshall (poems), Kashmira Sheth (???), Judith McNeil (???), and Millie Mader (poem).
March 22: ?
March 29: Fifth Tuesday
April 5: Liam Wilbur (???), Pat Edwards (???), Lisa McDougal (McPederson . . . ???),
Eva Mays (chapter 3, Dhuoda), Bob Kralapp (???), Randy Slagel (???), and Jerry Peterson (chapter 27-30, Killing Ham).
Fifth Tuesday coming . . .
This is the month of FIFTH TUESDAY.
Yes, March 29 our two groups will come together for an evening of good food and good times at Ella’s Deli, 2902 East Washington Avenue. Plug that in your GPS and you’ll get there. First-and-third group hosts.
TWS alumni and published sci-fi author Pat Tomlinson will be with us to talk about how he got a book contract.
Here’s our Fifth Tuesday writing challenge: Write a story, essay, or poem using this as your writing prompt: “I’m a curious person. No, I’m a nosy person. No, I’m a snoop, and it’s finally gotten me into trouble.”
Do not, repeat, do not use the prompt as the first sentences of your short short story, essay, or poem.
Max length: 500 words.
Deadline for getting your mini-masterpieces to Jerry Peterson is March 24.
Editing for March . . .
Pat Edwards, our Writers Mail February editor, continues on this month. Send your good stuff for our e-newsletter to her.
Leave a Reply