Writer’s Newsletter
Tuesdays With Story
October 21, 2025
First Word…
“ Literature adds to reality, it does not simply describe it. It enriches the necessary competencies that daily life requires and provides; and in this respect, it irrigates the deserts that our lives have already become.”
—C. S. Lewis, An Experiment in Criticism
Tuesday evening…
Seven TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, six of which read from their works in progress.
Here is a summary of what was said:
Susan S. – When the Wells Run Dry, 4
Positive comments overall, with suggestions to include more personal details and the impact of events on others, as well as perhaps add attempts by Elle to do something about the pending disaster.
Sue G. – The tail of Boris
The critiques were overall positive regarding the submission. There were suggestions to tighten up some of the dialogue, separate some of the compound sentences, and to remove some of the dialogue tags.
Mike A. – Fishing Camp” Chapters 6-7.
So far the dialog is working pretty well. But I need some physical descriptions of Chloe. It doesn’t have to be a lot, not at first. Short or tall? Dark hair or light? Expression on her face and eyes. I need an indication of her age as well. It would be good to explain some terrain. How is there a shortcut to town when the road takes so long? My thought is that it was too swampy in parts for a road straight to town. But I need some explanation of that. I’m going to have to flesh out the cluster or line of cabins along the lake. How far back from the highway is Doug’s family’s cabin if it’s at the end of the lane. How close are the other places? How many are there? Thanks for all the input and discussions.
Jack f. – A Walk Upon the Water, 44-45
Comments were positive on the St Dom chapter, a difficult one to write and at one of two centers of the book as Sean gets a lesson he actually seems to hear from a very short priest with a tall talent.
Sue was concerned that Catholic readers may take offence at the use of words the priest selects, but I believe that he represents much of the Church during the ferment of Vatican II when the liberalizing of the church tried to make it relevant, thus I will go with history as a defense. Sue is correct that the Church today is conservative. Many who came out of Vatican II left the church a decade later, as the hoped for changes began to be reversed under more conservative popes than John XXIII, born Angelo Joseppi Roncardi.
I will post the next chapters shortly with extensive notes. This is the second center of the book, as we see in Lester his participation in the history of his race. Please read those chapters before the notes so the notes to now affect how you relate to it.
Jack
Amit T. – Beneath Every Edifice
There was much discussion about the poems meaning and imagery. Though the human desire to search for the supernatural was understood the poem’s theme was still confusing and felt a bit disjointed.
Kashmira S. – Veena’s Story, 10-13
Kashmira submitted revised chapters 10-13 of her YA novel. The additional parts about Veena and Mayur as well as other characters work well. Some of the details make the story more grounded. Maybe add a little more? Also wanted to see more concerns and fear from Veena,
The writing can be tightened up in a few places. The knitting analogy worked well. The complexity in this draft worked well. Thank you all!
Here’s who’s up on November 4
Mike A
Jack F
Sue G
Kashmira S
Susan S
Larry S
Our Editor for November…
Mike will serve as editor of Writer’s Newsletter.
Last Word…
“But words are things, and a small drop of ink,
Falling like dew upon a thought, produces
That which makes thousands, perhaps millions, think”
—Don Juan, Lord Byron
Leave a Reply