Tuesdays with Story
March 18, 2025
The first word . . .
“Writers aren’t just people who sit down and write. They hazard themselves. Every time you compose a book your composition of yourself is at stake.” E.L. Doctorow
Tuesday Evening . . .
Wendy B (What Blood Runs Through Me)
Tension at the cabin scene was well received. The main issue was Lucy’s lackluster response to the news that Mom’s house would have to be sold. Disappointment just didn’t cut it. A great catch. Thank you all!
Suzanne G (Kaleidoscope rewrite of Chaps 12 & 13)
The consensus was that Brandon’s and Carey’s characters blended well together and were much clearer and more well-defined than at the last reading of these chapters. Overall, the chapters flowed much more smoothly although the rainbow metaphor didn’t work as intended. It will be rewritten. Thanks everyone for the comments. As always, I greatly appreciate your efforts.
Jack F (A Walk Upon the Water Chaps 10-11)
The chapter was well received. The usual format issues persist, but I’m concentrating on compression, rhythm, humor and bad Modernist jokes.
Thanks for all the helpful feedback to date on these first dozen chapters and the close reading you are providing.
Larry S (Brother’s Blood Chap 19-20)
In Jag’s internal dialog on the flight home, he comes across as more self-pitying than truly grief-stricken and concerned for Elspeth. Pop’s reaction to the tragedy seems unaccountably harsh, even “out of control,” and Dorie’s protective response would hardly be comforting or reassuring to Elspeth. And shouldn’t Margaret’s own family be more involved? As to Harold’s embarkation for war, there’s some cognitive dissonance between his Army service and his status as “a cripple” that needs to be ironed out. Thanks so much for all this helpful feedback, folks!
Kashmira S (The Saltmaker’s Son Chaps 18-21)
The chapters were well received for additional details as well as the writing. There were some questions about the interaction between Karna and his father, About Baba’s inaction and Karna’s muddied feelings. Though his emotional struggles seem true to his circumstances and age. Thank you all for your comments.
Who’s up next . . .
Wendy B.
Larry S.
Suzanne G.
Kashmira S.
Jack F.
Bob K.
For the good of the order . . .
Our own Kashmira Sheth will be at Mystery to Me on Tuesday, April 8th at 6 pm to promote her book I’m From Here Too. Tickets to the event are required but are free. (the bookstore has limited space) You can get a ticket by clicking on the link below:
Livestream: https://www.crowdcast.io/c/im-from-here-too
Tickets:
https://www.eventbrite.com/e/livemtm-kashmira-sheth-tickets-1235104162799?aff=oddtdtcreator
Kashmira Sheth
Nina Soni Series
I’m From Here, Too (July 2024)

I’M FROM HERE TOO is a beautiful book that explores universal themes of belonging, confidence, and identity from a perspective that’s too often overlooked – a young Sikh boy.
Simran Jeet Singh, Sikh Scholar and author of FAUJA SINGH KEEPS GOING and THE LIGHT WE GIVE
The last word . . .
“Never use a metaphor or a simile, or other figure of speech which you are used to seeing in print. Never use a long word when a short one will do.” George Orwell
And for the fun of it . . .
Lalochezia: The emotional relief gained from swearing.
Leave a Reply