Tuesdays With Story
November 5, 2024
First Word…
Tuesday evening…
Six TWS writer attended the meeting via Google Meet, four of which read from their works in progress. Here is a summary of what was said:
Kashmira S. – Kashmira submitted the last two chapters of her (chapter book) Valmiki story. All the comments were good and there were no suggestions to change anything. everyone felt that it was ready to be submitted. Thank you all for your input.
Wendy B. – What Blood Runs Through Me, Chs. 38,39. Overall, the chapters were well received. A few excellent suggestions on clarifying the Cubs/Sox reference, cleaning up a few sentences, reorganizing some paragraphs, and a POV issue, as well as adding a stronger reference on the key were made. Thank you all so much!
Mike A. – “Family”received encouraging comments, though it definitely needs some revisions. Ed getting beat up worked well, as well as that incident waking up something dark in John. There needs to be more interactions between Ed and John, and a lot of rearranging of conversations and events, and some hints of John’s darker side below the surface. Thanks
Larry F. S. – Brother’s Blood, Ch. 15 partial–The reason for the journey is not clear. Jag seems unduly harsh and critical, needs humanization. What does Margaret think of all this? It should be possible to show her reactions, even within Jag’s overall POV. The division of the aircraft into 8-passenger compartments is mystifying, and if Jag’s attire is important, then Margaret’s must be, too. Thanks, everybody. Good comments.
Bob K. – Rialto, part 1. There are several problems with part 1 of the story, least of all being the point at which it begins. Kashmira found the opening far too relaxed and wanted more urgency. Others wanted the flashback scene moved up to the start. On a positive note, several comments came in about the genuineness and emotional depth of the dialogue. Thank you.
Suzanne G. – Kaleidoscope Ch, 26 rewrite. Everyone thought the chapter rewrite read well. There was a note to add reader reminders, concerning color, in a few places. More explanation was needed in the first scene regarding Brandon not seeing the emotions of Michael and Joe. Thanks everyone for the comments. They all help to make my work stronger.
Here’s who’s up on November 19…
Kashmira S.
Wendy B.
Suzanne G.
Next Word…
“I love the feeling of being on the hunt – the feeling that the story is refusing to be solved in some lesser way and is insisting that you see it on its highest terms.”
Allegra Goodman on Writing…
“Carpe diem. Know your literary tradition, savor it, steal from it, but when you sit down to write, forget about worshiping greatness and fetishizing masterpieces. If your inner critic continues to plague you with invidious comparisons, scream, ‘Ancestor worship!’ and leave the building.” (Writers on Writing: The New York Times, March 2001)
Last Word…
Leave a Reply