Tuesdays with Story
August 6th, 2024
The first word…
“Work like hell! I had 122 rejection slips before I sold a story.” F. Scott Fitzgerald.
Tuesday’s Meeting
Five writers met on Tuesday to discuss four pieces of writing from four works in progress. Here are their summaries of comments they received:
What Blood Runs Through Me-Wendy B. The rewrite of the baseball game scene was well received-with some reservations! Clarification needs to be made upfront exactly where Michael will be spending his Sunday afternoon (game or Mom’s), and if at Mom’s maybe add a little guilt that he missed Mark game. Some confusion also on time and place when reviewing report on the basement stairs. Adding mention of Poe re fear of bodies buried in basement and several other great thoughts. As always, need to up the tension on Mom’s illness and dying wish to identify the killer. Thank you all!
Kaleidoscope Suzanne G. Larry thought the beginning was too long. The chapter should start with San Francisco. Kashmira thought I should play up that Brandon’s grandmother is accepting of his sexuality. Wendy said this was a strong chapter but wanted more information on the trip to San Francisco. She also noted that Carey and Brandon were too affectionate for a business event. Mike thought Brandon was still over the top with his reactions which will lessen the reader’s sympathy toward him. Situations and character read as real, even Grandmother has a depth Brandon doesn’t see. Thanks to everyone for the helpful comments. I appreciate them all!
Mike A. Fishing Camp. It sounds like I have a good start here with character portrayals and Bob’s loss of his friend. Everyone agreed that this loss should be mentioned more than once, and more in depth. Cedric could be more of an unknown to Bob and maybe the reader. The father’s repetitions of everything being “great” is too, well, repetitious. There are way too many “dialog tags” (Mike said) and I really need to cut back on those. There’s a metric ton of “good” that can be trimmed, as well as much paring down and editing in the re-writing. Thanks everyone for your comments and encouragement.
Kashmira S. Kashmira submitted chapters 19-21 of her MG novel. Everyone seems to enjoy the story. There were two concerns. One was regarding Karna’s reaction when he sees Hamsa after a long time. Other one was about Chitrak’s mood that seemed to change quite abruptly. I have addressed both these concerns and have revised it. I’m still looking for a title. Any suggestions? Thank you for reading this story.
Presenting at our next meeting. Which will be either August 20th or September 3rd…
Amit T.
Wendy B.
Kashmira S.
Mike A.
Suzanne G.
Larry S.
The last word…
“You take people, you put them on a journey, you give them peril, you find out who they really are.” Joss Whedon, on writing.
“Live with a man 40 years. Share his house, his meals. Speak on every subject. Then tie him up, and hold him over the volcano’s edge. And on that day, you will finally meet the man.” (Shan Yu, Firefly)
I was a fan of the series “Firefly,” produced by Joss Whedon. And I kind of got a kick out of his thoughts on writing and the similarity to the quote by one of his fictional characters. And it occurred to me that, in a way, we are holding our characters over a volcano and finding out who they really are. Or is that grasping too far? Either way, I’m sticking to it.
Leave a Reply