Tuesdays with Story
May 21, 2024
The first word . . .
“You don’t write about the horrors of war. No. You write about a kid’s burnt socks lying in the road.” Richard Price
Tuesday Evening . . .
Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)
The general consensus was chapters 23-24 were solid but several sections needed more details and/or scene setting. Always good recommendations! Specifically: When Tag refers to the prospective ‘shoppers’ at the orphanage, how did they know he was a troublemaker? Jack suggested a black eye or body language hints. The reference to a cut-throat game of baseball should have (and didn’t) prompt a huge reaction from June. The skimpy line on Liz and Mother not responding to June’s wedding invitation cried out for an explanation. Why didn’t they? Hmm. Will have to think about that a bit. And lastly, Claudia’s going around the bend state of mind was way too short and a disservice to June’s mother. Thanks all! Some great suggestions for improving the story. Much appreciated.
Mike A. (Fishing Camp)
Everyone seemed to like the characters and the scenes. I got some really great suggestions for paring down and clarifying portions, especially young Bob’s observations and interactions with the new girl. It’s still pretty rough and nebulous, but I see it’s going to need a direction soon, as well as many rewrites. Bob needs more of a personality, for one thing, instead of being an almost passive observer. I’m sticking with the idea of Fishing Camp as being a world apart from the rest of the world for Bob. Thanks!
Kashmira S. (Agaria’s Story)
Kashmira submitted chapters of her Agaria story. Overall, it was well received. There was some confusion about Karna’s physical presence in relation to the salt pan, their hut, and his mother. It was confusing to use word painting and not sketching or drawing. Some clarification is needed for how Karna and his family saved Chitrak’s life. Many would like to see the car journey through Karna’s eyes. Thank you all for your comments and suggestions.
Bob K. (Say What You Want)
Most of the comments centered around page one. There was a question about Phil Duffy’s wake being held at a working-class dive called Moe Greene’s bar and grille. Other comments suggested that I either spent too much time leading up to the wake, or that I spent too few words telling Lennie’s reaction to the circus-like happenings there. Also, the scatter-shot presentation of events was sometimes too much. More generally, there was agreement on how well-observed the descriptions were. Great suggestions, all. Thank you.
Who’s up next . . .
Bob K.
Kashmira S.
Wendy B.
For the good of the order . . .
Nothing to report.
The last word . . .
“The mind has plenty of ways of preventing you from writing, and paralyzing self-consciousness is a good one. The only thing to do is ignore it, and remember what Vincent Van Gogh said in one of his letters about the painter’s fear of a blank canvas—the canvas, he said, is far more afraid of the painter.” Philip Pullman
And for the fun of it . . .
Things native English speakers know, but don’t know they know: Adjectives in English absolutely have be in his order: opinion-size-age-shape-color-origin-material-purpose-Noun. So, you can have a lovely, little, old, rectangular, green, French, silver, whittling knife. But, if you mess with that word order in the slightest, you will sound like a maniac. It’s an odd thing that every English speaker uses that list. But none of us could write it out. And as size comes before color, green great dragons can’t exist. (from the Language Nerds)
Leave a Reply