Tuesdays with Story
December 19, 2023
The first word . . .
“The most valuable of all talents is that of never using two words when one will do.” Thomas Jefferson
Tuesday Evening . . .
Wendy B. (What Blood Runs Through Me)
The three chapters from What Blood Runs Through Me were well received by the group. Some excellent suggestions included defining the Chicago neighborhood more and slowing down June’s reaction to the taking of Tommy-ah, yes, that old art of unease… And then there’s that perpetual question: why doesn’t June mention the man to the police/her mother if she suspects he might have taken her brother? I’m hoping naysayers will buy into my premise that June is a 14-year-old girl who makes a bad decision because she is in denial. If she tells, it makes it real, and that makes her responsible. I will reinforce that in upcoming chapters. Thanks so much for the feedback!
Amber B. (Star-Crossed)
Amber B. read from the end of her tentatively tilted timey-wimey romance Star-Crossed. Overall, the group seemed to think these were solid chapters enough to want to continue. However, Judy thought there was a bit too much introspection and would like to see some more action. Wendy didn’t think the main protagonist’s ex sounded like a jerk, though another character called him a bad name. (Amber agreed. The ex isn’t a bad person. He deserved better than the protagonist at present (but he’s still an ex.)) Wendy didn’t get the Elsa reference. The same reference took Jamie a couple of pages, and Judy got it right away. Jamie thought the phone call to the editor could be streamlined. Larry pointed to two paragraphs that seemed to point to the main thrust of the work and wanted some expansion on those ideas.
Kashmira S. (Poets’ Daughter)
Kashmira submitted the first 14 pages of her MG novel Poets’ Daughter. There were too many “ing” words and also “would” used instead of “will’. A suggestion to compress some poems to make it more evocative. Overall, everyone enjoyed the story and thought it moved along well.
Jamie N. (New York, After All)
Jaime N: We took up chapter two of New York, After All, which introduces the protagonist Lindyhop. There was a consensus that the chapter needed more tension or thoughts from Lindyhop about her missing brother. Readers wanted more of the setting and for there to be fewer things the reader needs to figure out before the scene is set. Kashmira wondered if there could be another character for Lindyhop to play off of in the opening. Larry had some suggestions for the newspaper headlines. I will also look at tightening some of these long, cumbersome sentences. Thanks, all!
Larry S. (Brother’s Blood, Chapter 5)
Larry, Brother’s Blood, Ch. 5 partial: Kashmira and Judy both wanted more of Hal’s internal reaction to his new state. Wendy wanted to see more of his interactions with family members–more irritation, frustration, impatience, etc. Judy asked whether Hal’s problems were typical of head injuries. I need to do more research on that. Thanks, everybody.
Who’s up next . . .
Suzanne R.
Paul W.
Larry S.
Wendy B.
The last word . . .
“The worse enemy to creativity is self-doubt,” Sylvia Plath
Leave a Reply